Patterns
NSTD.1 - Choose a Narrative’s Purpose and the Source Structures It Must Preserve
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Purpose: select from the source the events, relations and distinctions the intended reader needs.
NSTD.1:1 - Problem frame
Use this method when you need to choose which source relations a narrative must preserve for its intended use, or to assess those choices in an existing account. A lesson, an argument, a live commentary, a fictional scene and a future scenario can require different selections.
Identify the reader’s question, locate the available material and select the relations or events it requires. Compare an existing draft with that material, or try a short account if the selection is unclear. Revise the purpose or selection where the comparison exposes a gap. A few sentences can suffice.
If the desired effect determines what the source is said to contain, a reader may remember the story but lose an important relation, mistake uncertainty for fact or lack the material needed to check a claim.
The result identifies the material that supports the account’s purpose and any claim the available material leaves open.
Use NSTD.4 for a question about viewpoint or voice and NSTD.7 for planning or assessing generated text. Use C.35 when a generated result will inform architecture work. If the intended use raises a question about evidence, ethics or publication, obtain the relevant result for that question.
NSTD.1:2 - Problem
“Make it inspiring” can be enough direction for an expressive sketch. It leaves open which relations an explanation of an architecture must preserve, which details can be simplified for a lesson, or what a reviewer must be able to check. Clarify the purpose to the degree the reader’s intended use requires.
NSTD.1:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| The reader’s use and the available material | The purpose guides selection. The material determines which subject claims the account can support. |
| Attention and authority | A motivating account may keep readers interested. A claim about evidence, assurance, ethical clearance or permission to act needs its own grounds. |
| Domain vocabulary and distinct claims | Narrative terms help design; claims about evidence, ethics or authority still need their own grounds. |
| Drafting and source comparison | A quick draft can clarify the purpose; comparing it with the source reveals omissions and unsupported connections. |
NSTD.1:4 - Solution
Start with the reader’s question and the available material. Select what the account must preserve and examine how an existing or proposed sequence presents it. Use a short draft when it helps expose an omission or an unsupported connection. The answer can be a suitable selection, a finished account for the intended use, or a precise limit on what the material establishes.
Suppose an automatic valve is designed to open when pressure exceeds a threshold. An operator asks why it opened on one occasion. The rule explains one possible mechanism. A time-matched pressure reading and evidence that the automatic mechanism triggered the opening can establish that explanation for this event. If the only observation is an open valve, report its state and leave the cause open. Manual opening can produce the same observation.
When the reader needs an interpretation the material does not yet supply, use NSTD.9 to construct or compare accounts of the events, participants and meanings. Use an adequate diagram, chronology or interpretation directly. For fiction or a hypothetical scenario with undecided events, use NSTD.10 to develop what could happen under the selected premises. A discovered ambiguity or new possibility can change what the account needs to make available to this reader.
The optional intake below can preserve the choices needed by a collaborator, a comparison of alternatives or a maintained collection. Include the details that change that use. The examples show how the same fields can serve different tasks.
NarrativePurposeIntake@Context:
sourceBasisRefs:
selectedSourceStructureRefs:
unfoldingStructureRefs?:
demonstrativeSliceRefs?:
sourceStructureSelectionRationale:
sourceTemporalPosture:
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure | architecture-mediated | mixed
architectureMediationRef?:
sourceDefinitionOrConstraintRef?:
renderingContribution?:
narrativeVoiceOrViewpoint?:
generatedDraftInspectionRef?:
intendedReaderOrListener:
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis:
intendedReaderOrListenerUse:
narrativePurpose:
likelyMisreading?:
sourceReturn:
additionalClaimQuestion?:
refreshCondition?:
Use unfoldingStructureRefs? when A.22.CGUS, E.18.3 or a local FPF block defines a constraint-governed structure selected for this account. Use demonstrativeSliceRefs? for the particular path the narrative presents. The wider structure can also contain alternatives, returns and stops.
Use the following prompts where a choice remains open.
- Identify the material and selected relations or events, explaining their relevance to the reader’s purpose. State whether they concern past, live, proposed or fictional events when that changes the account.
- If the narrative uses an architecture description, decision or observation, let the reader find the source whose structure or claim matters to that use. A direct explanation can refer straight to the subject material.
- Identify who is writing or supplying the account and who will use it. Use
NSTD.4for a consequential choice of voice or viewpoint andNSTD.7for planning or inspecting generated text. UseA.2orA.2.1for a precise system-role or assignment claim. Use A.13 and A.15.1 when the claim needs precise attribution of a dated Work occurrence. - Relate the purpose to the selected structure and the reader’s use. If one changes, check whether the other still fits.
- Examine which inferences the draft invites given the reader’s likely preparation. Locate a consequential difficulty in the wording, presentation, source or evidence from a reading. A response can show which interpretation a particular reader gave. To attribute it to this passage or report independent understanding, establish what else the reader knew or used. Apply
F.19:4.4when choosing a correction. The optionallikelyMisreading?field can preserve the inference and its grounds for a collaborator. - Identify where to find an omitted relation or what still needs investigation if the reader requires a stronger conclusion.
For a difficult selection, use whichever of these questions could settle it.
| Pass | Question | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Which material is the account drawing on, and which relations does the reader need to recover? | Identify the material, the selected relations and when a reader will need to return to the source. |
| Use | Who will use the narrative, for what work or understanding, and which distinctions does that use require? | Name the intended reader or listener, the expected interest or purpose and the needed distinctions. |
| Mediation | Does the writer use subject material directly, an architecture description or both? Does the account concern past, live, planned or hypothetical events? | Identify the source used, its relation to the account, and the observations or later corrections needed for its claims. |
| Reliance | Which claim or feature could change what the intended reader can infer or do? | Use F.19:4.4 for a grounded difficulty. Identify the relevant condition, source or decision and revise the wording when that is the needed remedy. |
A draft can reveal a useful selection. Check its relations against the reader’s purpose and the available sources before relying on them. If the purpose is unclear, ask what the reader needs or offer a short account that helps identify it. Qualify any broader claim about completeness or fidelity on its own grounds.
Use these contrasts when the purpose remains unclear:
- Reconstructing a procedure. “Help new FPF readers recognize why the EntityOfConcern, forces and neighboring-pattern exits matter in use.” This purpose identifies relations the learner should be able to reconstruct.
- Motivating a class. “Make the seminar inspiring so people want to use FPF” gives an expressive aim. For a reconstruction lesson, also identify what learners need to reconstruct and do with the result.
- Explaining an argument. To help reviewers understand a proposal, select its premises, inferences and grounds. Include an uncertainty or rival position when it affects the argument.
For fiction or a proposed real scenario, select the relevant canon, premises, design constraints or hypotheses. The narrative can develop events under those conditions. If a proposed event conflicts with a fixed condition, change the event. Change an author-controlled premise explicitly if the task permits. For a real scenario, establish the grounds for any claim that the proposed events could occur. A maintained source collection can help compare alternatives or preserve canon.
When the narrative follows one path through a constraint-governed unfolding structure, identify the wider structure and the path shown. Possible sources include A.22.CGUS, an E.18.3 transformation flow, a P2S or improvement-loop block, and an ordering block under A.6.3.NAR. A writer can select one DemonstrativeUnfoldingSlice@Context of a ConstraintGovernedUnfoldingStructure@Context. Show omitted branches, returns, constraints or exits when the reader needs them to interpret this path or act. Identify whether the path shows an actual occurrence, an admissible possibility or a prescribed way to proceed.
These questions address common difficulties in selecting sources.
| Worker situation | Prompt | Expected answer |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher or trainer | “What should learners be able to reconstruct or do, and what help may they use?” | Identify the source relations, a task that uses them and when to return to the source. |
| Architect or analyst | “Which structure, trade-off, candidate, observation or earlier decision does the account need to convey?” | Identify the subject or architecture source, what it establishes and how the narrative draws on it. |
| Scientist or researcher | “Which mechanism, calculation, attempt, source uncertainty or unresolved tension does the account concern?” | Identify the relevant calculation, proof or evidence, what remains uncertain and where a stronger claim could be checked. |
| Story designer | “Which events, character choices and constraints must hold under the selected canon or premises?” | Identify the relevant premises and any limit on publishing or reusing the result for the intended purpose. |
| Live commentator | “What was observed, what is being inferred or predicted and what can the official account later settle?” | Locate the observations in time and identify any uncertainty and subsequent correction. |
| Tool builder | “What material and relations must the output preserve, and how will a reader or operator detect a consequential omission or invention?” | A generation plan and source-comparison question under NSTD.7; add production-history or responsibility details when the intended use requires them. |
Mood, genre, style or an audience reaction can be a narrative aim. If fidelity or learning also matters, select the source relations the audience needs. Use NSTD.4 or NSTD.5 to develop the expression. An actual claim about learning needs evidence of the learner’s performance.
Examples of the optional intake for different uses:
NarrativePurposeIntake@FPFLearningRoute:
sourceBasisRefs: selected FPF pattern bodies and relation records
selectedSourceStructureRefs: EntityOfConcern discipline; problem frame; forces; solution; neighboring exits; quality and improvement loop
unfoldingStructureRefs: A.22.CGUS only when the lesson explicitly teaches source-to-next-use unfolding
demonstrativeSliceRefs: first seminar route through selected pattern-use positions
sourceStructureSelectionRationale: learners must reconstruct how a practitioner chooses and uses a pattern
sourceTemporalPosture: prospective planned learning route over current source corpus
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure unless architecture-of-FPF explanation is opened
renderingContribution: teacher or course designer
intendedReaderOrListener: new FPF author or reviewer
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis: the learner wants to use an appropriate pattern for a case
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: reconstruct one pattern-use route and apply it to a new case
narrativePurpose: help learners locate the applicable conditions and use the source method in a case
sourceReturn: the applicable FPF patterns and, for this teaching publication, its relation to those sources
refreshCondition: FPF edition, learner telemetry, or route evaluation changes
NarrativePurposeIntake@HomotopyExplanation:
sourceBasisRefs: formal definitions, examples, diagrams, proof-status notes, and selected textbook or lecture source basis
selectedSourceStructureRefs: definition dependency; example and counterexample relation; theorem prerequisite; formal-source return
sourceStructureSelectionRationale: learner needs an intuitive route that preserves formal boundaries
sourceTemporalPosture: retrospective or atemporal explanation over existing mathematical material
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure unless a teaching architecture is explicitly used
renderingContribution: teacher, explainer, or tool-assisted author
intendedReaderOrListener: learner who must later distinguish intuition from proof
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis: learner needs recoverable dependency order and analogy boundary
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: use examples and return to formal statements without treating metaphor as theorem
narrativePurpose: make abstractions followable while preserving proof-status boundary
sourceReturn: the relevant mathematical definition, argument or qualified source for the proof
refreshCondition: source correction, learner failure, or changed learning objective
NarrativePurposeIntake@LiveCommentary:
sourceBasisRefs: live observations, official event feed, telemetry, recording, later official result
selectedSourceStructureRefs: event order; score state; possession or control changes; actor roles; uncertainty markers
sourceStructureSelectionRationale: listener needs orientation during an unfolding event stream
sourceTemporalPosture: live unfolding source with later refresh
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure
renderingContribution: commentator or live analyst
narrativeVoiceOrViewpoint: live commentator voice following the unfolding event under `NSTD.4`
intendedReaderOrListener: listener following the event and later checking the official event record
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis: listener needs distinction between observation, inference, prediction, and official correction
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: follow the event without treating provisional interpretation as fact
narrativePurpose: maintain orientation and attention under uncertainty
sourceReturn: the event observations, relevant recording or telemetry, and official source for the result
refreshCondition: official correction, telemetry, or post-event evidence changes
NarrativePurposeIntake@FictionalContinuationProbe:
sourceBasisRefs: selected canon or local source pack for private storycraft test
selectedSourceStructureRefs: canon constraints; continuity; premise and theme; character agency; causal plot support
sourceStructureSelectionRationale: the chosen action must remain intelligible under the characters' established commitments and the consequences of earlier events
sourceTemporalPosture: prospective fictional source structure
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure unless fictional organization or technology architecture is live
renderingContribution: story designer or tool-assisted writer
intendedReaderOrListener: private reviewer of storycraft plan
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis: reviewer needs to see whether continuity and agency survive the route
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: private design critique, not publication
narrativePurpose: develop a continuation whose choices can be compared with the selected premises
sourceReturn: selected canon and explicit premises of the continuation
refreshCondition: corrected source material, changed canon selection or revised premise
NSTD.1:4.1 - When claim identity matters
Use A.6.3.NAR:4.0.1 when citation, dispute or another consequential use needs identifiable source and narrative claims. Identify source episteme X, narrative episteme Y and the construction that relates them. Preserve their common EntityOfConcern and check the correspondence on which the claimed use depends. When the two expressions use different representation languages, show how each is read and which source claims the narrative preserves under those readings. Establish publication permission, evidence or assurance when the intended claim or action requires it.
NSTD.1:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.1:5.1 - Worked slice: FPF seminar from source spine to narrative route
A seminar author is asked to tell a motivating story about FPF. To develop a lesson, the author chooses what learners should be able to do: recognize a situation, select a suitable pattern and apply its conditions. The following example records the choices so a colleague can use them in teaching.
NarrativePurposeIntake@FPFSeminarOrientation:
sourceBasisRefs: selected FPF pattern bodies and relation records
selectedSourceStructureRefs:
- EntityOfConcern discipline
- Problem frame and forces
- Solution as admissible move under conditions
- neighboring-pattern exits
- quality and improvement loop entry
sourceStructureSelectionRationale: the learner needs to recognize the method's applicable conditions, first operation, result and next useful move
sourceTemporalPosture: prospective planned learning route over current FPF source corpus
renderingMediationMode: direct-source-structure
renderingContribution: seminar author
intendedReaderOrListener: new FPF practitioner; team lead evaluating local adoption
readerInterestOrUseHypothesis: reader wants a first usable route through FPF without learning every pattern first
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: recover an appropriate pattern-use route and identify any further pattern the case needs
narrativePurpose: connect the opening question to a use of the pattern in which the source conditions matter
sourceReturn: selected FPF pattern body and relation record
additionalClaimQuestion: none unless the seminar makes assurance, policy, or affected-party claims
refreshCondition: FPF edition or selected-source pattern changes; learner reconstruction test fails
The opening asks learners to choose a pattern for a difficulty they recognize. The next passage explains how the pattern’s conditions, forces and neighboring exits affect that choice. The exercise returns to the selected pattern so the learner can use those conditions in a case.
To examine the lesson with NSTD.6, use a learner’s response to another case. Did the learner choose a pattern, explain the relevant conditions and use its body for the needed method? A response that repeats the opening question establishes which words the learner supplied. To count that as recall, check whether the words remained on display or were prompted. Applying the pattern to the new case requires the relevant conditions. If the teacher needs to explain the difficulty, examine the supplied material, the task, the learner’s preparation and the help used. Change the selection, explanation or practice when the diagnosis supports that change.
For a seminar draft produced with an LLM, specify the relevant contributions separately.
renderingContribution: course-author or generator-operator role; recover the actual system, role assignment, and Work separately when those claims are made
narrativeVoiceOrViewpoint: teacher-facing explanatory voice under NSTD.4
generatedDraftInspectionRef: the NSTD.7 case that identifies the generated draft, source comparison and acceptance for its intended use; C.35 applies only when the result informs architecture work
The same participant may operate the tool, choose the voice and be authorized to select the result. To judge fidelity, compare the draft with the selected material or use an adequate comparison already made.
NSTD.1:5.2 - Worked slice: architecture-mediated narrative
An architect wants to explain a selected system structure to the team that will implement it. The architecture description and decision supply the structure, alternatives and trade-offs; the account must make the implementation-relevant choices recoverable. This is an architecture-mediated narrative.
NarrativePurposeIntake@ArchitectureDecisionStory:
sourceBasisRefs: architecture candidate set, selected architecture description, decision record, expected characteristics, known residuals
selectedSourceStructureRefs:
- problem situation and forces
- candidate structures considered
- selected structure and rejected alternatives
- expected architecture characteristics
- residual exceptions and developer continuation boundary
- telemetry or later actual-structure feedback condition
sourceTemporalPosture: prospective future holon structure before implementation
renderingMediationMode: architecture-mediated
architectureMediationRef: architecture description and candidate synthesis records
intendedReaderOrListener: developer team; product steward; later evaluator
intendedReaderOrListenerUse: understand what structure to preserve while implementing and what may be locally detailed
narrativePurpose: carry structural intent and trade-off rationale into development work
sourceReturn: architecture description, architecture decision record, and future telemetry route
refreshCondition: candidate set, selected architecture, decision, or actual-structure feedback changes
The account is intended to let the implementers recover the selected structure and reasons for preserving or varying its parts. For an unresolved design choice, use the available architecture result or obtain the missing decision from the responsible work. Use NSTD.6 with C.2.8 to assess what the team could recover, or examine an observed reading for what it did recover. Use C.33 for architecture-description adequacy, C.34 for correspondence with the realized structure and E.17 if the account is to be published.
NSTD.1:5.3 - Worked slice: franchise continuation probe
For a private critique of a continuation in a familiar space-opera setting such as Star Wars, select the canon, premises and continuity constraints relevant to the proposed scene. A draft can show which choices remain unsettled. A proposal to publish raises its own rights question.
The request “Write a surprising sequel that feels epic” leaves those choices open. For the private critique, the writer chooses a continuation premise that preserves a character’s established motivation and the consequences of earlier events. A new event may extend the story; if it conflicts with the chosen continuity, revise the event or explain the changed premise. Ordering and suspense alone cannot repair that conflict.
NSTD.1:5.4 - Role-specific first moves
| Worker | First source-selection move | Common hidden overread | Repair when that difficulty occurs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teacher | Identify the source relations and the task that calls for them. | A report of interest is treated as demonstrated learning. | Use a question or a performance that calls for the relation, with suitable existing evidence or a new observation where needed. Use NSTD.6 for the assessment. |
| Architect | Identify the selected structure, candidates, exceptions and evidence about the actual organization. | An explanatory story is treated as an authorized architecture decision. | Check the earlier decision and its authority, or refer a new decision to its authorized owner if one is needed. |
| Scientist | Identify the mechanism, calculation or event at issue and the available evidence or proof. | A coherent story is treated as settling a scientific question. | Use the relevant source result and identify where the evidence leaves the claim open. |
| Story designer | Identify the premises, continuity and character agency that matter to this scene. | A surprise conflicts with a fixed premise. | Revise the event or explicitly change a premise the author is free to change. |
| Live commentator | Identify the observed events, provisional interpretation and available official return. | A live inference is presented as an established cause. | Name its grounds and uncertainty. Use the later official or observational source for the issue it can settle. |
| AI-agent operator | Name material, required relations and the proposed use. | Fluent prose silently adds a cause or drops a constraint. | Inspect and repair through NSTD.7 and NSTD.6; apply C.35 only for an architecture use. |
NSTD.1:5.5 - Match the source return to the intended use
The relevant source depends on the question. A seminar can return to the pattern’s working conditions, a mathematics lesson to definitions and proof, a match report to dated observations and later official corrections, and a fictional continuation to its premises. Reconsider the selection when the use changes. A brief orientation may become a request to investigate a cause, or a private critique may become a publication requiring permission.
NSTD.1:6 - Bias-Annotation
Check whether the proposed account omits a material counterexample or a serious alternative. If so, revise the selection or qualify the conclusion. Document sources and roles to the degree the receiving work needs. A short explanation can use an adequate source directly.
NSTD.1:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD1-1 | The selection serves the reader’s purpose. Where reliance on the account requires fidelity, an adequate comparison identifies what it preserves from the source. |
CC-NSTD1-2 | The reason for including a relation is recoverable from the reader’s intended use and the source. |
CC-NSTD1-3 | Past, live, proposed or fictional status and any intervening description are clear wherever they change interpretation. |
CC-NSTD1-4 | Writing contribution, narrative viewpoint and intended reader are distinguishable when needed. Precise system-role, assignment or dated Work claims receive their own grounds only when asserted. |
CC-NSTD1-5 | The intended use supplies enough direction to choose or improve the account, including an expressive aim when that is the task. |
CC-NSTD1-6 | A correction aimed at a plausible misleading inference has grounds and a useful consequence under F.19:4.4. Preserve those grounds when another use relies on them. |
CC-NSTD1-7 | Additional evidence, ethics, authority or production-history claims have the grounds their actual use requires. |
CC-NSTD1-8 | The intended reader can locate the relevant source or its qualified result when omitted distinctions or changed conditions matter. |
NSTD.1:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Desired conclusion selects its own evidence | The account suppresses a relevant conflicting relation. | Compare the draft with the needed source relations and alternatives; change its selection or qualify the conclusion. |
| Unexplained selection | Neither the writer nor reader can say why a relation was included or omitted. | Recover that choice from the intended use and source; revise the selection where it fails. |
| Treating motivation as evidence | A moving narrative is taken to establish a subject claim. | Use the evidence for that claim and assess the motivational effect on its own grounds. Use A.10 when the source-to-use connection is unclear or must remain reproducible. |
| An unstated limit changes reliance | A reader uses a chronology as a causal explanation. | State which facts establish the sequence, which causal claim remains open, and any relevant source for the stronger conclusion. |
NSTD.1:9 - Consequences
The reader’s purpose and the source relations guide selection together. The cost lies in identifying and comparing the material that could change the account. Record further details when a collaborator or later comparison needs them.
NSTD.1:10 - Rationale
Audience, purpose and source material jointly shape a narrative. The author can choose what to foreground and still answer to the source for factual claims. Examining the construction from source to narrative shows what was selected, related, omitted or given a new order.
NSTD.1:11 - SoTA-Echoing
NSTD.1:11.1 - Operational comparison against domain vocabulary
Narratology distinguishes the story’s selected and organized events, the discourse through which it is told and its presentation. Cognitive studies examine event models, perspective and memory. Natural language generation distinguishes content planning, discourse planning and realization. These traditions help pose different questions about selecting material, ordering it, anticipating a possible reading or producing wording. Use their terms in their own domains and FPF distinctions where the claim needs them.
For an incident explanation, selecting only events that support the desired conclusion can produce a fluent but misleading story. Selecting the reader’s question together with the relevant events, including an unresolved alternative, yields a draft that can be compared with its source. This DPF combines the source-selection and communication distinctions above for that use. The extra comparison costs effort, so keep it to relations that could change the account or its use. A free fictional invention has a different source obligation: preserve its chosen premises rather than pretend to report an actual event.
Hoffmann’s “The Tensions of Scientific Storytelling” examines how a scientific account can organize attempts, mechanisms and unresolved questions. Schmid’s Narratology: An Introduction and Chihaia’s Introductions to Narratology: Theory, Practice and the Afterlife of Structuralism offer source-specific accounts of presentation and narratological traditions. Castricato et al.’s “Towards a Model-Theoretic View of Narratives” models a narrator’s information, changes in a reader’s story model and uncertainty. Dahlstrom and Ho’s “Ethical Considerations of Using Narrative to Communicate Science” examines the ethical issues of persuasion. Use these works for their respective claims about scientific communication, interpretation, modeling and influence. Where timing, intervening sources or participant roles change the narrative’s use, make those conditions explicit.
NSTD.1:12 - Relations
Use A.6.3.NAR for the source-to-narrative relation. A.16.1 can preserve an early cue, C.2.LS can clarify an action-changing language distinction, and G.2 can support synthesis across research traditions. For recoverable source structure see C.2.8, and for architecture-description adequacy see C.33. Use NSTD.4 for voice or viewpoint, NSTD.7 for generated narratives and NSTD.6 for evaluation. C.35 applies to a generated result used in architecture work. Use D.1–D.5 for a consequential affected-party or persuasion question, A.10 for a source connection that is unclear or must remain reproducible, B.3 for assurance, E.10 or F.18 for wording or naming, and G.11 for currentness. The Architecture and Narrative Work Bridge explains architecture mediation. The Source Use And Refresh Map identifies research grounds. NSTD.Reference:11 distinguishes working terms, and the Name And Edition Route locates the document or edition.
NSTD.1:End
NSTD.2 - Choose a Narrative Order That Keeps Needed Source Relations Recoverable
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Purpose: choose or assess a sequence that makes the source relations needed for the reader’s use recoverable.
NSTD.2:1 - Problem frame
Use this method when the order of a narrative affects which relations a reader can recover from it. A graph, mechanism, body of evidence, plot, decision history or mathematical argument may support several orders. The question may be how to arrange new material or what an existing order makes available.
Compare a short passage in its existing or proposed order with the relations it draws on. Where a feature of the passage makes chronology, cause or a prerequisite ambiguous, clarify the relation or change the order if the task calls for a revision.
A fluent sequence can invite an unsupported inference. The first event mentioned may look earliest, most important or causally decisive. A student may mistake the order of exposition for the order of proof, or a project team may mistake it for the order in which work was authorized.
A suitable order lets the intended reader follow the account and recover the dependencies the use requires.
NSTD.2:2 - Problem
To present a tree, graph, mechanism, set of alternatives or architecture view in sequence, choose where to enter and which relations to show at each step. A sequence can expose one dependency while leaving another implicit. Check how the reader could recover each relation that matters for the purpose.
NSTD.2:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Ease of following the account and fidelity to the source | A sequence can introduce a difficult relation gradually. It can also hide a branch or return that matters to the reader. |
| Teaching and formal dependency | A useful lesson can begin with an example whose full proof appears later. Make its status clear where the difference matters. |
| Suspense and prerequisites | An author can postpone the disclosure of a cause or a character’s means. Establish the prerequisites the events themselves require. |
| Compactness vs source return | The sequence needs to move, but hidden relations need return points. |
NSTD.2:4 - Solution
Choose an order for the reader’s task or examine the existing one. At a consequential point, identify what the text has stated, which clues it has supplied and what can be inferred with the reader’s relevant prior knowledge. Compare the sequence with the source. If it obscures a needed relation, a short revision or usable source return may suffice. Use the note below when another worker or a later comparison needs the choices.
NarrativeOrderingRule@Context:
narrativeRenderingRef:
sourceStructureRefs:
unfoldingStructureRef?:
demonstrativeSliceRef?:
orderingRuleKind:
orderRationale:
preservedSourceRelations:
foregroundedSourceRelations:
coarsenedOrLostSourceRelations:
sourceReturnCondition:
additionalClaimReferences?:
A sequence can follow chronology, causal or logical dependency, discovery, teaching prerequisites, tension, viewpoint or the grounds for a decision. Choose the relation the account needs to foreground. Explain a departure when an otherwise plausible reading would confuse that order with another.
If the choice is unclear, compare the passage using the questions below.
| Test | Ask | If unclear |
|---|---|---|
| Source relations | Which dependencies, cycles, alternatives or times does the intended use require? | Use a sufficient source directly. If the relevant selection is still unclear, use NSTD.1 or try a provisional order to locate the missing relation. |
| First encounter | What should this passage show first, and what can a reader with the assumed preparation infer at that point? | Compare two short orders if the difference matters. Include expressive aims such as suspense when they are part of the use. |
| Hidden relations | Does the sequence omit or obscure a relation the task needs? | Identify the omission. For a revision, restore the relation or provide a return to a source that supplies it. |
| Misreading | Which feature of this sequence could support a mistaken inference? | Where a correction is warranted, choose a sentence, marker or change of order that identifies the needed relation. |
Compare the inferences available at the chosen point with those available at the end. A later disclosure can give grounds to revise an earlier interpretation. A whole story can also support several readings. Use NSTD.9 if those interpretations need developing or comparison. For a claim about what a particular reader understood, or when they understood it, use NSTD.6 with evidence from the relevant reading and point in time. An anticipated response is sufficient for planning its examination.
A lesson can introduce an example, recount the discovery that made a distinction interesting and then supply its proof. A live account can follow observed events in time, while a later recap examines causes. A story can show effects before revealing their cause. Make the transition recognizable when the reader’s task depends on which relation the order expresses.
For a constraint-governed unfolding structure (CGUS), identify the path the account presents and preserve its applicable constraints. Show a branch, return, exit or stop when the reader needs it to explain what happened or determine what could happen. A demonstration of one path need not prescribe that sequence for future work.
The following difficulties can arise in a passage or appear in a reader’s response. Check the proposed explanation against the passage and the circumstances of the reading.
| Difficulty | Possible explanation | What to examine or change |
|---|---|---|
| A reader takes the first-mentioned cause to be strongest. | Placement makes one cause salient. | Check the evidence for relative causal strength. If presentation invites the overreading, explain what the order shows or revise it. |
| Learners can retell the lesson but miss a formal exercise. | A story may have omitted a prerequisite or blurred example order and proof dependency. | Examine the task, the attempted reasoning and the available support. Restore the mathematical relation or the return to the proof when that is the missing contribution. |
| Stakeholders interpret the explanation as a sequence of decisions or work. | The passage may make an explanatory order look historical or prescriptive. | Identify the order the account intends. For an actual decision or implementation sequence, use the record of what happened. Use the plan for what was intended. |
| A reveal is well received, but a character lacked the means for an earlier action. | Delayed disclosure may conceal a gap in the events. | Check the selected canon or premises for the means at the time of the action. Revise the events if they lack it, or decide when to disclose existing support. |
| A generated story has plausible steps but drops a required source relation. | Generated sequence obscures its source constraint. | Compare the candidate with that relation; repair its plan or realization through NSTD.7. The defect can be evaluated before either is repaired. |
Use NSTD.6 when the question calls for a qualified assessment of this sequence. A draft can already show that a dependency is missing or inaccessible. Report that limit, or repair the passage before using it for a purpose that needs the dependency.
NSTD.2:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.2:5.1 - Worked example: choosing a path through a graph
A knowledge graph can connect concepts, dependencies, counterexamples, evidence and practices. Choose an order that makes the necessary relations available to the intended reader. The following example records such a choice for a homotopy introduction.
NarrativeOrderingRule@HomotopyIntro:
narrativeRenderingRef: HomotopyIntroNarrative@v1
sourceStructureRefs:
- topological space
- path
- deformation under constraints
- invariant
- example and counterexample
- proof-status boundary
orderingRuleKind: didactic prerequisite plus analogy-first cue
orderRationale: an initial image can introduce the deformation question; the formal dependency must remain recoverable
preservedSourceRelations: prerequisite relation; analogy-to-definition return; example-to-counterexample contrast
foregroundedSourceRelations: deformation intuition and invariant question
coarsenedOrLostSourceRelations: full proof order; advanced generality; categorical reformulation
sourceReturnCondition: use the formal statement and proof when deciding a theorem, equivalence or proof claim
additionalClaimReferences: `A.6.3.CSC`, `E.17.EFP`, `A.10`, `NSTD.6` when the corresponding claim is made
The introduction can begin with a picture of paths being deformed, then return to the definition. For example, “Picture one path being deformed into another while their endpoints stay fixed. The definition specifies which deformations are allowed.” The image gives the reader a candidate example. The definition supplies the conditions for a homotopy of paths relative to their endpoints.
NSTD.2:5.2 - Before and after repair: architecture order
Before:
We tried several designs and eventually found the architecture that solved the coordination problem.
“Eventually” puts the attempts in time. “Solved” asserts a successful result. The sentence gives no basis for identifying the coordination problem, the accepted trade-off or the result after implementation.
After:
Two services could each apply the eligibility rule locally, but would then have to keep their copies in step. We chose one eligibility service and accepted an extra call. Clients still need to handle an unavailable service and mismatched rule versions.
The revised account lets a reader compare rule maintenance with the cost and failure modes of a service call. A decision record can establish the grounds for the choice. Whether the deployed arrangement reduced coordination work depends on evidence from its use.
NSTD.2:5.3 - Before and after repair: live commentary
Before:
The midfield is late, so the press has failed, and that is why the match is turning.
The timing of movement and loss of possession may be observable live. The cause of the loss and the projected direction of the match require further support.
After:
The midfield line arrived after the forwards began pressing, leaving space between them. Did the opponent receive the ball in that space, or gain it in an individual challenge? A replay showing the passes, the challenge and the timing of possession might establish either contribution, show how both mattered or leave the cause open.
The account identifies the observed sequence and a specific remaining question about its cause.
NSTD.2:5.4 - Comparing candidate orders
| Observation | Next useful move |
|---|---|
| The sequence is readable but a necessary relation disappears. | Restore that relation or change the order. |
| The order has a name, but a reader reports a different dependency. | Check the passage and what informed the response. If the passage obscures the intended dependency, revise the wording or order. |
| The reader recovers the relations needed for this use. | The result supports the sequence for that reader under the observed conditions. Retain it where adequate. Consider a change if its expected contribution warrants the effort. |
| The route will be reused with changed material or audience preparation. | Check the condition that matters to transfer. Where sufficient evidence is already available, apply it. Where the changed use leaves a consequential question open, compare a representative case. |
Use NSTD.6 when the task requires an evaluation of the order for a particular reader and use.
NSTD.2:5.5 - SoTA-to-action translation
Narratology distinguishes the selected material and story, discourse and presentation. Natural language generation distinguishes content selection, text planning and wording. In this task the distinctions help a writer compare what each version includes with where and how it presents that material. Smooth wording can still place a dependency where its use is unclear.
One teaching order for homotopy moves from spaces and paths to homotopy, the fundamental group, examples and questions about proof. An analogy can introduce a relation before its formal treatment. Identify where to find the definition or proof when the claim requires it. The order chosen for teaching by itself establishes neither historical discovery nor formal logical dependence.
In this constructed case two teams maintain the same validation rule in separate modules. They compare a library with a shared service and choose the service so that a rule change can be deployed once. They accept an extra service call and client handling of version mismatches. These are the decision and its anticipated consequences. The example supplies no runtime measurement.
Two short orders preserve the same source:
- Cost first: “The chosen service adds a call and requires version-mismatch handling. The teams accepted these costs to deploy a shared validation rule once, after comparing a library with a service. The runtime effect is not yet measured.”
- Decision first: “To deploy a shared validation rule once, the teams chose a service over a shared library. They accepted the extra call and version-mismatch handling; the runtime effect is not yet measured.”
For a new maintainer asking why the teams selected the service, the second version foregrounds the reason. For an investigation of the extra call, the first foregrounds the cost. A decision record can supply more detail about the alternatives. To report a realized improvement, use relevant measurements or observations.
A continuation can present scenes for suspense. Establish what the chosen events require in the story, including any necessary means, motive or prior event. The author can disclose those conditions later. If a twist contradicts a fixed premise, revise the event or change a premise the task permits changing. If the basis is uncertain, return to the selected canon.
A scientific account can build tension around a failed attempt, a surprising measurement and a revised hypothesis. If the explanation remains uncertain, keep the unresolved alternative in view. Identify the calculations, proposed mechanisms and experimental observations needed to check the resulting claims.
An architecture explanation can be repaired as follows.
- Initial symptom: “The team first tried A, then B, and finally discovered the right architecture.”
- Identify the inference the sentence invites. It treats the last design in time as the right one.
- Recover the relevant candidates, criteria, rejected alternatives and the decision basis or operating observations that actually exist.
- Present the problem, alternatives and trade-off. Use a separate sequence if the implementation order matters.
- Identify consequential omissions, such as a lower-level exception or an alternative outside the chosen scope.
- Refer to the architecture description, candidate comparison or decision record for the particular structure, trade-off or authorized decision the reader needs.
For a mathematics lesson, the corresponding revision might run as follows.
- Initial symptom: “We introduce homotopy with loops, then groups, then examples, because that is the natural story.”
- Identify what “natural” leaves unexplained. The intended order is for teaching. A reader might mistake it for the logical order of proof.
- Identify the definitions, examples and theorem prerequisites on which the lesson relies. Establish where each proof claim can be checked.
- Choose the teaching order. Make a divergence from formal dependency explicit when the reader needs to know it.
- Say which formal details are deferred and where they can be recovered.
- Use
NSTD.6to assess whether the lesson makes the dependency and proof boundary recoverable or examine a learner’s response for what they actually recovered. Evaluate enjoyment separately when that too is an aim.
Case matrix for ordering work:
| Case | Candidate order | Preserves | Hides or weakens | Required source return |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FPF learning route | Entry difficulty, useful distinction, attempted application, result and continuation. | Pattern-use relationships and learner build-up. | Monolith order, advanced variants and source history. | Source pattern body; supporting definitions when needed. |
| Homotopy explanation | Teaching order, with an analogy before the formal proof. | An entry for learners and the relevant dependencies. | Full proof order, lemmas and advanced generality. | Formal statements and proofs, with the analogy’s limit. |
| Franchise continuation | Causal plot order plus reveal order. | Continuity, motivation, event consequence and return to the chosen canon. | Canon details outside this continuation’s scope. | The selected canon and continuity constraints; a separate permission question only when the proposed use raises one. |
| Live commentary | Live chronological order plus provisional interpretation markers. | Event stream, uncertainty, listener orientation. | Later tactical recap, off-camera sources, official correction. | Official event record, telemetry, recording. |
| Architecture explanation | Decision-memory order or trade-off route. | Problem, candidate, selected trade-off, residual exception. | Implementation order, full structure, rejected-candidate detail. | Architecture description, candidate set, decision record, telemetry. |
Use the matrix to compare available orders, draft a passage or assess an existing sequence. A historical question about why the author chose one order needs evidence of that choice. A textual assessment can establish the structure of the published passage directly.
When two orders matter, preserve their distinct relations. A lesson can introduce prerequisites before recounting historical discovery. A mystery can present effects before their causes. A commentator can follow events in time and later explain a tactical sequence. Use a transition or source return where the intended reader needs to recognize the change of order.
NSTD.2:6 - Bias-Annotation
A chronological, dramatic or slide order that feels natural to its author can hide a different relation in the source. Compare the chosen sequence with what it preserves, emphasizes or omits. Repair the account or provide a source return when the distinction matters. Formal serialization and the publication order of a corpus have their own purposes.
NSTD.2:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD2-1 | The chosen sequence serves the reader’s task; an explanation of its rule is available where the choice matters. |
CC-NSTD2-2 | The relations needed for that use remain recoverable; consequential omissions are shown or have a source return. |
CC-NSTD2-3 | Narrative order is not treated as physical time, proof order, work order, or decision authority without source support. |
CC-NSTD2-4 | Source-return condition is present when lost relations affect action or reliance. |
CC-NSTD2-5 | Use C.34 for architecture-specific preservation claims and A.6.3.CSC for a claimed coarsening. Use C.2.8 through NSTD.6 for reader-relative structural amount, and C.33 for architecture-description adequacy. Ordinary source comparison needs no such additional claim. |
NSTD.2:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Natural-order assumption | An obvious order for the author hides a dependency from the reader. | Recover the missing relation and change or explain the sequence. |
| Confusing tension with a prerequisite | A disclosure order is taken to determine what the events require. | Identify the prerequisite and choose where to reveal it. Provide a source return when the relation needs one. |
| Using slide order as evidence of source architecture | A teaching sequence is taken to establish how the source is organized. | Use the source to establish its structure and NSTD.8 when a teaching route or its support needs attention. |
NSTD.2:9 - Consequences
A well-chosen sequence can make a difficult subject easier to follow while preserving the relations needed for the reader’s purpose. Compare it with the source closely enough to identify consequential losses.
NSTD.2:10 - Rationale
Both serialization and narrativization can choose an order for material whose relations have another structure. A narrative can additionally use a point of view, a revelation or an expressive pause. Locate any relation the chosen order obscures and preserve a route back to it when its loss could change the intended reading.
NSTD.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Schmid’s Narratology: An Introduction distinguishes happenings, story, narrative and presentation. Chihaia’s survey of narratology introductions shows differences of tradition and audience. These are historical conceptual anchors. Gatt and Krahmer’s NLG survey distinguishes content selection from text structuring and realization. Cardona Rivera, Jhala, Porteous and Young’s The Story So Far on Narrative Planning examines plan-based construction and communication of stories. This pattern synthesizes those distinctions into an ordering method; it does not require a formal plan for every account.
These sources contribute distinct operations to the comparison.
- From Schmid, distinguish selection, composition and linearization. Well-chosen material may still be ordered badly, so compare
NSTD.2ordering separately fromNSTD.1selection. - From Chihaia, interpret terms such as plot, discourse or fabula within the tradition using them. Explain the ordering consequence when different traditions use a term differently.
- From natural language generation, distinguish content choice, ordering and expression. If a reader misses a needed relation, inspect the supplied content as well as its order and wording.
- From narrative planning, distinguish the order of events from their presentation. Mark a divergence when it could mislead the reader about causality or dependency.
- For an architecture explanation, compare the account with the relevant structures and views. Use
C.30.ASV,C.33orC.34only for the architecture question each defines.
For a short account of the incident in the Readme, try two versions. One can report the change at 14:00, failures at 14:02, rollback at 14:05 and recovery at 14:07. The other can use the same chronology and add that the log leaves open what caused the failures and whether the rollback produced the recovery. Choose the detail the reader needs to reconstruct the sequence or assess a causal claim.
Section 4 adapts the distinctions between content, structure and wording in natural language generation, and between events and their presentation in narrative planning. For an ordinary passage, a direct comparison of the relevant relations may suffice. For suspense or aesthetic rhythm, consider an order that serves that aim while preserving the relations the work needs. Reconsider the choice when the task changes, an observed difficulty concerns the order, or another equally economical arrangement would make the needed relations clearer.
NSTD.2:12 - Relations
Use A.6.3.NAR for the source-to-narrative construction, A.6.3.CSC for a consequential simplification, and NSTD.6 with C.2.8 for correct recovery of selected structure from architecture or other sources. Use C.33 for architecture-description adequacy and C.34 for architectural preservation. E.17 and E.17.EFP concern publication and explaining a source. If a proposed account overcommits, use A.16.2 to reopen it, and A.6.P for an ambiguous relation. Use G.11 when changed source, use or evidence puts an earlier assessment in question. The Architecture and Narrative Work Bridge covers ordering of views, candidates, decisions and evidence from realized structures. The Semiotic And Language-Precision Bridge and NSTD.Reference:11 help resolve consequential ambiguity in wording about simplification, relations and quality.
NSTD.2:End
NSTD.3 - Repair Missing or Unsupported Narrative Connections (Coherence and Event Models)
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: the connections a reader needs to reconstruct events, mechanisms or dependencies from a narrative.
NSTD.3:1 - Problem frame
Use this method when you need to assess or explain a connection in a narrative. A reader may be able to retell the events yet leave open what changed, how a mechanism worked, why a design choice mattered or how a proof step followed.
Choose a passage, state the connection its wording suggests and compare that connection with the source or fictional premises. If you are revising it, supply the missing step, correct an unsupported claim or make the unresolved question clear.
To explain a past reading, examine what the reader said or did with the passage and what other information or help they used. An analysis of the text can establish what it made possible to infer under stated assumptions.
The comparison shows which connections the passage supports and which still depend on an unstated premise, a different source or a further observation.
NSTD.3:2 - Problem
An event sequence can make a narrative easy to follow. A design dependency, mathematical definition or relation between a finding and its evidence can matter even when nothing happens in sequence. Turning such a relation into an episode can obscure what follows from it.
NSTD.3:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Events and other structures | A reader may follow the episodes and still miss the dependency on which the explanation turns. |
| Causal wording and its grounds | A physical cause, a reason for acting, a proof step and a fictional motive require different grounds. “Because” can introduce any of them. |
| Mechanism and uncertainty | A clear account of the proposed mechanism can still give the impression that an untested or disputed step is settled. |
| Reconstruction and engagement | Ask what the reader should be able to reconstruct when that ability matters to the intended use. |
NSTD.3:4 - Solution
Identify what changed, what depends on what, what explains an action or which condition limits a conclusion. For a single passage, compare it directly with the source or premises. A note like this can preserve grounds that several passages or collaborators will need.
NarrativeEventMechanismSupport@Context:
narrativeRenderingRef:
sourceStructureKind:
requiredReaderReconstruction:
eventOrMechanismModel:
participants?:
dependencyOrConstraintRefs?:
causalClaimBasis?:
uncertaintyOrUnknownRefs?:
reconstructionTaskRefs?:
sourceReturnCondition:
Compare the intended connection with what the passage expresses or permits a reader to infer. Supply an omitted step if the source establishes it. When the source leaves the relation open, state what cannot be determined and identify any alternatives the material supports. An action may be clear while two motives remain possible or its motive is wholly unknown. Use NSTD.9 to examine a disputed reading. If a fictional scene or an explicitly hypothetical real-world scenario needs a new event or constraint, use NSTD.10 to construct it under the chosen premises.
The following questions support an assessment or revision. Keep the answers that another part of the work needs.
- State the connection at issue and the source or premise on which it depends. Identify any uncertainty that bears on it.
- Identify the kind of connection. An event order, mathematical dependency, physical cause and fictional motivation answer different questions. Establish the grounds appropriate to the one claimed.
- Identify what a reader needs here, such as a state change, an explanation, a prediction or the point where an analogy stops.
- Compare the passage with that task. What supports the intended reading? Does a word or omission suggest a different relation?
- When a change is needed, supply a missing step, correct the kind or strength of the claim or identify the relevant uncertainty. State an established conclusion at the strength its grounds support. Return to the subject source when a stronger answer is needed.
Examine how a connector works in its sentence before choosing a repair.
| Wording | Question about this passage | Repair when needed |
|---|---|---|
| “then” or “after” | Does the source establish this sequence, or is this only the chosen presentation order? | State the supported sequence or explain the ordering choice. |
| “because” | Does it introduce a cause, a reason, a proof dependency or a fictional motive? | Supply or qualify that relation. Use C.28 only when its causal-use question is at issue. |
| “therefore” | Which premises and inference make the conclusion follow? | Restore the missing premise or step, or state the remaining uncertainty. |
| “had to” | Which condition makes the action necessary, and under which alternatives? | Name that condition or replace necessity with the supported choice. |
| “wanted” or “decided” | Whose motive or decision is asserted, and is it factual, fictional or interpretive? | Clarify the participant and grounds. Use NSTD.4 when viewpoint or attribution causes the ambiguity. |
| “shows that” | What does the observation, argument or example establish? | Match the conclusion to its grounds. Use A.10 when the connection to the evidence needs recovery or must be reproducible. |
| A proof may be presented as a sequence of questions and inferences, and an architecture choice as a comparison of trade-offs. If you invent a scene of discovery to illustrate a proof, distinguish the imagined events from the premises and inferences that establish the result. |
Make the required reconstruction concrete. For example, ask a reader to do one of the following.
- Name the proposed mechanism and the relation still unresolved.
- In a live account, identify an observation, an inference and a prediction.
- Point to the formal statement where the mathematical analogy stops.
- Explain the trade-off accepted in a design choice and the exception it left open.
If the required reconstruction cannot yet be stated, clarify what the reader needs to do with the passage. Entertainment or initial orientation can be sufficient aims. A use that depends on a mechanism or inference needs a recoverable account of that relation.
NSTD.3:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.3:5.1 - Worked example: event support
A science narrative says that a failed experiment forced a theory to change. First find out what failed. Did the instrument give an unusable reading, or did a qualified measurement disagree with a prediction? In the second case, determine which assumptions the discrepancy puts in question and whether the evidence distinguishes any replacements.
NarrativeEventSupportRecord@ExperimentTension:
narrativeRenderingRef: ScienceStory@v1
eventOrMechanismClaim: a qualified measurement disagreed with the range predicted from the proposed mechanism and its auxiliary assumptions
sourceStructureRef: measurement record, model expectation, uncertainty interval, alternative explanations
relationStrength: observed discrepancy under the stated assumptions, with its explanation unresolved
reconstructionTarget: distinguish the discrepancy, its possible explanations and the contribution of any later evidence
overclaimRisk: stating that the discrepancy forced one particular theoretical change
sourceReturnCondition: return to the measurement and model assumptions when a stronger conclusion is needed
Before:
The experiment failed, so the old theory collapsed.
After:
The measured value lay outside the predicted range under the stated assumptions. The discrepancy bears on the mechanism model and the assumptions used in measurement. The observed difference alone leaves the proposed replacements unresolved.
The passage makes the discrepancy and unresolved alternatives available to the reader. To distinguish the explanations, look for an existing result that would differ under them. A further experiment is one option when it could obtain such a result and the question warrants it.
NSTD.3:5.2 - Worked example: franchise plot support
In a proposed continuation, a character betrays an ally “because the plot needs a darker turn”. This gives the author’s purpose. To explain the character’s choice, look for a motive supported by the selected canon and the circumstances of the scene.
NarrativeEventSupportRecord@CharacterTurn:
eventOrMechanismClaim: character changes allegiance under named pressure
sourceStructureRef: selected canon constraint, prior motivation, current dilemma, consequence chain
relationStrength: a proposed motive consistent with the selected fictional premises
reconstructionTarget: reader can state motive, pressure, action, consequence, and canon-return condition
overclaimRisk: author need or theme is treated as character cause
sourceReturnCondition: consult the selected canon and the character’s available choices when a claim about the motive depends on them
If the story needs an intelligible motive, supply the pressure, choice or event that makes the betrayal intelligible, or revise the turn. An existing passage can support two plausible motives. Deliberate absurdity or an unexplained turn may also serve the intended work.
NSTD.3:5.3 - Comparing relation support
| Observation | Next useful move |
|---|---|
| Events are easy to retell but the needed relation is supplied only by a suggestive connector. | Find and express the missing basis or change the claim. |
| The relation is named but its conditions remain unclear. | State the condition that changes the reader’s inference. |
| The reader reconstructs the relation and its relevant limits. | Use that finding for the observed conditions. Pursue a further uncertainty if the question requires it. |
| A change of viewpoint or order may conceal the relation. | Compare the passages and report any loss that matters to the intended reading. If a revision is requested, restore the connection or use a version that preserves it. |
Use NSTD.6 when the work needs a qualified assessment of reception or quality. The comparison can also answer a narrower question about the passage itself.
NSTD.3:5.4 - Connecting to the relevant subject method
“Because” may introduce a physical cause, a reason for acting or a mathematical dependence. Identify the particular relation. Consult its FPF or subject method when the source leaves a material question about that relation open.
Suppose a proposed module split removes one hand-off between teams for routine requests and routes exceptions through a shared interface. The design establishes this change of dependency. A prediction of lower coordination cost also depends on the frequency and cost of exceptions. Suitable experience with the implemented design can establish the time actually spent and, with an appropriate comparison, whether the change reduced it.
To write that a result forced a theoretical revision, establish which alternatives the measurement and other evidence excluded under the assumptions in use. The result may instead expose a discrepancy, reduce support for a hypothesis or suggest a mechanism to examine. Any of these can be the conclusion of the account.
In live commentary, identify the late midfield movement and the loss of possession. A replay of how the opposing side gained possession might distinguish a tactical gap, a missed challenge or a contribution from both. Report the limit when the evidence leaves the explanation open.
For a homotopy explanation, connect the image of deforming a loop to its permitted deformations. Identify the formal definition or argument that supports any claimed invariant, and what the learner should be able to recover from the image.
Use the source to decide how to revise a disputed sentence.
| Initial sentence | Source-support question | Replacement selected by the answer |
|---|---|---|
| “The failed experiment revealed the true mechanism.” | Does the source identify the mechanism, rule out a prediction, or merely report a discrepancy? | If it reports only a discrepancy, state the measurement and prediction that disagree and leave the mechanism unresolved. If it establishes the mechanism, retain that conclusion and its supporting scope. |
| “The module split solved coordination.” | Does the source show a changed dependency, predict a cost effect or observe one? | For the proposed design above: “The split removes one required hand-off and routes exceptional requests through a shared interface. Its effect on coordination time has not yet been measured.” A measured reduction would warrant the corresponding observed claim. |
| “The character had no choice.” | Which alternatives do the fictional premises actually exclude? | If the scene establishes that both exits are locked and no other escape is available, say “With both exits locked, the character remained in the room.” If an alternative remains possible, describe the choice or pressure rather than inventing necessity. |
| “The proof idea is that loops remember holes.” | Which formal restriction or invariant does the image represent? | If the supplied definition requires a loop to remain in the punctured plane, explain that a deformation cannot pass through the missing point. Return to the argument for any claimed invariant; the image alone establishes no theorem. |
| “The team was outplayed because the press failed.” | What sequence is observed and what supports the tactical explanation? | With only the late midfield movement and subsequent loss of possession established, report both events and identify the tentative explanation. Use a stronger conclusion if later analysis distinguishes its contribution. |
Suppose the source defines f(x) = 2x and the task gives x = 3. Then f(3) = 6 follows by substitution. If the source records only the pair (3, 6), that observation establishes the pair and leaves the rule open. The same numbers support a deductive conclusion in the first case and a limited observation in the second.
If the factual repair has reduced engagement that matters to the task, use NSTD.5 to develop the presentation around the supported relation.
These notes illustrate three different uses.
NarrativeEventMechanismSupport@ArchitectureTradeoff:
sourceStructureKind: dependency and trade-off in a proposed software architecture
requiredReaderReconstruction: which required hand-off the proposed design removes, where exceptional requests go, and why an observed time saving remains unknown
eventOrMechanismModel: ordinary requests no longer cross the removed hand-off; exceptional requests still require shared-interface coordination
dependencyOrConstraintRefs: before-and-after dependency diagram; rule selecting exceptional requests; shared-interface responsibility
supportingBasis: the design shows the removed hand-off and the exception route. Their frequency and cost matter to the prediction of time saved
uncertaintyOrUnknownRefs: realized coordination time unmeasured; other candidate designs outside this sketch
reconstructionTaskRefs: reader distinguishes the design change, remaining exception work and unmeasured cost effect
sourceReturnCondition: consult the dependency comparison for the design claim and observations for an actual cost claim
NarrativeEventMechanismSupport@HomotopyAnalogy:
sourceStructureKind: proof-like and definition-like dependency
requiredReaderReconstruction: distinguish intuitive deformation image from formal equivalence relation
eventOrMechanismModel: path deformation story used as analogy for invariant tracking
dependencyOrConstraintRefs: formal definitions; examples; counterexamples; theorem prerequisites
basisForLearningEffect: a claim that the analogy helped learners would need evidence that distinguishes its contribution
uncertaintyOrUnknownRefs: analogy may fail outside named examples
reconstructionTaskRefs: identify where the image stops and which formal premise or argument is needed
sourceReturnCondition: formal source statement for proof or exercise use
NarrativeEventMechanismSupport@LiveCommentary:
sourceStructureKind: live event stream with provisional interpretations
requiredReaderReconstruction: observed event vs inference vs prediction vs official correction
eventOrMechanismModel: state updates and tactical hypothesis under uncertainty
participatingHolonOrRoleRefs: teams, players, officials, broadcast or event source roles when needed
uncertaintyOrUnknownRefs: events outside the camera view and decisions still under official review
reconstructionTaskRefs: listener can say what was observed and what was inferred
sourceReturnCondition: official record, recording, statistics, or telemetry
For each use, retain the information needed to explain, compare or repair the connection.
NSTD.3:6 - Bias-Annotation
A vivid episode can make a suggested cause or motive feel established. Compare the relation implied by the passage with the observation, argument or fictional premise that could support it. Separate what the text permits from what a particular reader actually reconstructed. Return to the subject source where the relation itself remains in question.
NSTD.3:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD3-1 | The passage represents the relevant source relations without silently turning a dependency, constraint or proof step into a physical event. |
CC-NSTD3-2 | The assessment identifies what the passage makes recoverable under the assumed knowledge, or what remains uncertain. To report what a particular reader understood, use a response or action that reveals their interpretation of the connection at issue. |
CC-NSTD3-3 | Cause, dependency, necessity and motive are attributed on grounds suited to each claim. Use further subject work when an answer still needed depends on it. |
CC-NSTD3-4 | An unknown, disputed or deferred relation remains visible when it affects the reader’s conclusion or action. |
CC-NSTD3-5 | Learning or consequential use has a suitable way to check or recover the needed connection. A separate test or source note is selected for its value to that use. |
NSTD.3:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Fluent but unsupported explanation | A passage invites an explanation that its source does not support. | Supply the missing connection, qualify it or return to the unresolved source question. |
| Causal overstatement | An account attributes an effect on the strength of event order alone. | State the observed order and the support for any further causal inference. Use C.28 if the particular causal claim needs examination. |
| Event forcing | A graph, proof dependency or architecture view is retold as an invented sequence of events. | Identify the source relation. If its presentation order needs changing, use NSTD.2 to compare alternatives. |
NSTD.3:9 - Consequences
The comparison can show why a reader would infer too much from a fluent passage and what its source actually supports. Correcting the passage may require recovering the source relation or changing a dramatic simplification.
NSTD.3:10 - Rationale
Readers often use event models and causal expectations to follow a narrative. What a passage invites them to infer and what the subject evidence establishes can differ, including in an account of a mechanism, an architecture or a proof.
NSTD.3:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Nguyen’s A Review of Mechanistic Models of Event Comprehension (2024) compares accounts of prediction, hierarchy, updating and causal representation in comprehension. Hoffmann’s The Tensions of Scientific Storytelling (2014) illustrates how scientific accounts organize mechanisms and unresolved tensions. Gatt and Krahmer’s NLG survey (2018) distinguishes content selection and realization. This pattern’s synthesis is to compare the connection the passage suggests with the relation its source or premises support.
The sources contribute different operations.
- Use event-comprehension models to identify event boundaries, dependencies or predictions that matter to a reading task. Evidence about the particular reading can then establish what a reader recovered.
- Scientific storytelling can make an unresolved tension intelligible. Distinguish the established observation from the explanations still possible.
- In natural language generation, compare the selected content as well as its expression. A smoother connective will leave an omitted premise missing.
- For evidence, inference or cause, inspect the complete claim before choosing how to substantiate it.
- In an architecture account, distinguish an accepted trade-off, residual exception handling and what operation measurements establish about the realized design.
A local wording change such as “preceded” in place of “caused” can be sufficient when the source establishes that order. If a source identifies the cause, the change would discard information. In the incident log the dates support the chronology, while the cause remains open. Checking the source decides whether the small edit preserves the claim.
The source comparison in §4 and the examples in §5 adapt distinctions from event modeling and content planning. Scientific storytelling also shows how to make an open research question part of an account. Return to the passage if new evidence changes the source relation, the intended task changes or an observed reading reveals a different interpretation that matters to that use.
NSTD.3:12 - Relations
Use A.6.3.NAR and NSTD.2 for narrative form and order. Use C.28 for a causal claim needing examination, A.10 when the route from a source to a claim is unclear or must be reproducible, and B.3 when reliance on the resulting claim needs qualification. NSTD.6 can use C.2.8 for structural recoverability and C.33 for the adequacy of an architecture description. Use C.34 when a claim concerns preservation or correspondence of an architectural structure, and G.11 when a changed source or result may affect the maintained account. Use the Architecture and Narrative Work Bridge for an architectural dependency, the Source Use and Refresh Map for a source claim, and NSTD.Reference:11 for a technical term’s meaning and direct source. Qualify the proposed mechanism on its own grounds.
NSTD.3:End
NSTD.4 - Choose Narrative Voice and Focalization while Keeping Agency Claims Grounded
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: constructing and sustaining a narrative voice and viewpoint for an intended reader, while grounding the knowledge, experience and agency attributed through them.
NSTD.4:1 - Problem frame
Use this method to continue an author’s voice, construct a new narrator, or adapt a way of speaking to a changed subject, genre or language. It also helps when viewpoint or personification affects what a passage makes available to infer about knowledge, action or responsibility, or when you need to interpret a reader’s response.
Identify the speaker, intended reader and the relationship the passage should establish. To continue an existing voice, compare the draft with relevant expression from that author. If the voice already works and the question concerns hidden information or attribution, go to §4.6.
“Make it lively” may elicit a catchphrase while losing the author’s way of developing a thought. A warmer rewrite might invent a memory, obscure a hard distinction or attribute a decision to whichever object is most prominent. Check the manner of speaking as well as the claims it expresses.
The result can be a passage written for its occasion, a direction another writer can apply to the next passage, or a finding about the voice or attribution in existing work.
Keep a voice that already suits the passage. An isolated grammatical fault or unsupported claim can be repaired directly. A profile becomes worthwhile when it helps someone sustain or compare expressive choices across passages.
NSTD.4:2 - Problem
A voice emerges from connected choices about what the speaker notices, how a thought starts and develops, how the reader is addressed and how confidence or hesitation is expressed. A catchphrase can survive after the relationship to the reader has changed. Use the actual passage to connect the chosen relationship with its expression.
The narrator’s position governs what can be told from that viewpoint. An editor can preserve a way of speaking using the author’s material. A claim to an actual memory needs grounds in that person’s experience. A fictional narrator can sound certain about an event the story gives the reader reason to doubt. Identify the grounds for any consequential attribution of knowledge, experience or agency.
NSTD.4:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Recognizable voice and changed occasion | A continuing author can speak differently in an essay, instruction and scene; mechanical repetition can defeat the new use. |
| Expressiveness and intellectual substance | Rhythm, humour or intimacy can carry an idea, but can also replace its necessary distinction or difficulty. |
| Example and generalization | A passage gives observable choices; one memorable oddity need not characterize the author’s other work. |
| Viewpoint and agency | Following an object through a scene can make a relation easier to see while leaving open who acted. |
| Narrative function and working participant | A protagonist centers the story; a real performer, assignment or responsibility requires a separate claim. |
| Personification and responsibility | A memorable figure can introduce a trade-off. A decision or assignment of responsibility needs its own identified participants and grounds. |
NSTD.4:4 - Solution
To construct a voice, choose the speaking relationship and write a passage that carries the needed thought. Use relevant examples for a continuing voice, or try a treatment for a new narrator. Compare how the resulting passage handles manner, meaning and viewpoint. If you are assessing past work, use its actual wording and any evidence needed for the claim about its use. A single suitable passage can answer the writing task.
NSTD.4:4.1 - Establish the speaker, relationship and comparison basis
Identify the speaker, reader and relationship that matter. An experienced colleague inviting another colleague to inspect a finding, a remote chronicler withholding judgement and a frightened witness addressing a sceptic establish different positions. Choose the distance, shared knowledge and invitation or direction appropriate to the account. A claim about real expertise or authority requires grounds beyond that choice.
Distinguish the basis of the requested voice:
- To continue an existing author’s voice, use authentic passages suitable to this occasion or edits the author has accepted as models. Keep enough context to hear the thought develop and identify its addressee. A generated trial can show an editorial choice. Attribute preference to the author when there is evidence of that preference.
- For an imitation or stylization, identify the model and the features to adapt. State whose experience an episode represents when a reader might take the stylization for the original person’s account.
- For a new narrator, select a speaking relationship, access to information and purpose. Try the needed material in that voice. If the choice remains open, compare another treatment of the same material and use the differences that serve the scene.
Select examples for the present occasion. A joke in an interview may give little guidance for a condolence note, and a technical paragraph may tell you little about dialogue. Add material if it could resolve a consequential uncertainty, such as whether an unusual turn belongs to the author, the fictional speaker or one particular occasion.
If suitable material from the intended author is unavailable, identify what can be recovered and offer a provisional treatment if the task is to produce a draft. Seek additional material or the author’s choice when the work needs a claim of fit or acceptance that the available evidence cannot support. An already established editorial choice can guide later passages.
NSTD.4:4.2 - Recover expressive choices from what the passage does
Read an example as connected expression. Notice how it brings the reader into a question, develops a distinction, changes pace and closes a thought. Describe each useful property through wording that realizes it. A collegial passage might offer a shared problem for inspection. A restrained narrator might give the decisive detail and leave the judgement to the reader.
Choose properties that can guide the passage, such as address, rhythm, imagery, humour, qualification or the balance of scene and commentary. A short sentence can express discovery, embarrassment, impatience or a direction to act. A technical term can preserve a needed distinction. Identify the contribution before copying the feature.
Distinguish what appears in this passage, what recurs across relevant examples and what the editor is choosing now. A single accepted passage can be sufficient as the model for this use. A claim about a broader tendency needs evidence across the occasions it claims to cover. Keep working notes when someone will use them again.
A writer might use the direction “Begin with a concrete discrepancy, let the reader inspect it, then state the limited conclusion.” It specifies how to develop the next thought.
NSTD.4:4.3 - Compose a natural fragment without losing its thought
Write a connected unit such as an exchange, scene or passage. Include its joins to the previous and following thought where they affect its work. The chosen relationship may call for a different order, sentence connection or placement of example and explanation.
Retain the distinctions and intellectual demands appropriate to the reader. Give them the difficulty that makes the next move worth taking. A surprise, image or sharp observation can carry a relation that a flatter summary would lose. Use it when that contribution matters.
Ground attributed recollections, observations, uncertainty and judgements. Mark a hypothetical or constructed account when its reader might take it as experience. In fiction, the premises can give a character a memory or feeling. In a factual account, first person can express the author’s own reasoning or documented experience. Use “we” when its intended participants and their relation are clear.
Identify whose information the voice uses. A retrospective narrator may know what a participant did not know at the time. A close witness may have missed an event. Keep that difference or revise the viewpoint under §4.6. Use NSTD.9 if interpretation remains in question, or NSTD.10 to construct a needed fictional or hypothetical event under the stated premises.
NSTD.4:4.4 - Carry the voice into a changed subject, genre or language
Ask what the new occasion changes in the relationship and work. A familiar reader may now need an instruction under time pressure; an essay’s reflective detour may become inappropriate in a decision note. Choose which properties remain useful and which must change, with their contribution to the new passage as the reason. Continuing a voice can preserve a way of approaching uncertainty while changing address, rhythm or the place of humour.
Try the treatment on material that exposes the changed demand. For a new subject, establish the domain relations that the passage must convey. A familiar sample can guide expression. For a new genre, compare the passage with both its speaking model and its present neighbors. Ask whether it performs the work this genre requires.
For another language, identify how its address forms, idiom, rhythm and conventions can express the chosen relationship. Compare passages in the receiving language and preserve technical distinctions. Use competent language judgement already available, or seek it if the editor cannot settle a consequential claim about the result. A particular pronoun, level of informality or use of irony belongs to the chosen audience and occasion.
NSTD.4:4.5 - Compare the passage and repair the actual loss
Read the changed passage beside its model or chosen trial and in its new surroundings. Compare how each develops the thought and puts the speaker in relation to the reader. For a voice meant to be spoken, reading aloud can reveal a broken join or a sentence hard to deliver. To establish what a listener actually understood or recognized, use a response or action that shows the particular interpretation or recognition at issue.
Choose the comparison that supports the conclusion you need.
| Question | Useful comparison | What the result supports |
|---|---|---|
| Does the manner realize the selected voice and relationship? | Compare the relevant expression in model and draft, or the new passage with the chosen speaking relationship. Identify what is retained, changed or lost. | An editorial judgement of fit. To report the author’s acceptance or another reader’s recognition, identify evidence of that response. |
| Does the passage preserve the needed meaning and speaker position? | Compare claims, distinctions, experience, uncertainty and viewpoint with the source or chosen premises. | A finding about correspondence for the material compared. |
| What can the intended reader do with the passage? | Examine the inference or action made available under the assumed starting knowledge. For a historical claim, examine a response or action that shows the relevant reading and what help was used if it affects the conclusion. | A design judgement or an observed result under its conditions. Use NSTD.6 for a qualified evaluation and NSTD.8 or applicable learning methods for a learning question. |
If revision is requested, change what caused the loss. Correct an unsupported recollection, a condescending form of address, a missing transition or a summary that erased an important distinction. If the example was unsuitable for the new genre, choose a better model.
Read the repaired passage with the joins it affects. Use F.19 for meaning and recoverable action in technical prose and NSTD.5 when the effect of an expressive device is at issue. For tool-assisted composition under NSTD.7, give the tool the relevant models, choices and constraints and examine its actual output.
NSTD.4:4.6 - Keep viewpoint, agency and attribution grounded
Compare what the viewpoint reveals with the relations the reader needs. Two participants may see the same departure as escape and abandonment. Use NSTD.9 to examine the support for either interpretation. If a fictional viewpoint requires a discovery not yet provided for the character, use NSTD.10 to build that event or select a viewpoint with different access. Add a second view or a short clarification when it supplies missing information the task requires. Use a note like the one below if collaborators or a later comparison will need the grounds.
NarrativeViewpointAgencyDiscipline@Context:
narrativeRenderingRef:
viewpointOrVoice:
focalizedObjectRef:
revealedSourceStructureRefs:
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs:
narrativeFunctionTerms:
personificationOrAgencyWording:
relevantSourcesAndAuthorityIfNeeded:
blockedAgencyOverread:
repairActionIfNeeded:
Use the distinctions that affect the claim.
- A narrative function, such as narrator, protagonist or actant, explains a contribution to the account. “Role” often has this ordinary meaning in a discussion of stories.
- For a real participant, identify the person, organization or technical system that played the relevant part. If a precise classification matters,
A.2defines the local system-role kind forU.Systemindividuals. UseA.2.1for the obtainingU.SystemRoleAssignment. - For a precise agency claim, use
A.13to identify the System, applicable local kind and actual assignment. For a claimed dated Work occurrence, apply the independentA.15.1conditions. Use ordinary contributor language when the passage makes no such claim. - A capability or responsibility claim needs its own grounds. Use
A.2.2for capability, the applicable organizational assignment for responsibility, andD.1throughD.5when value, harm or affected-party conflicts matter. - An agency measurement or profile uses the selected characteristic and scale through
A.19.ECS,C.16andA.13when that additional claim is needed.
Consider the following questions where the viewpoint could change the reader’s understanding or action.
| Pass | What to inspect | Repair if failed |
|---|---|---|
| What becomes visible? | Which events or relations does the viewpoint show or allow a reader to infer from specified starting knowledge? | Add the needed fact, a way to recover it or another viewpoint. |
| What attribution follows? | Does prominence in the account imply an unsupported action, capability or responsibility? | Retain the narrative function and establish or correct the separate attribution. |
| Would a literal reading mislead here? | Is there a plausible reading that changes reliance or action? | Clarify that relation or participant. Keep an unambiguous metaphor. |
| Whose consequence is missing? | Does the viewpoint conceal a relevant effect, disagreement or uncertainty? | Add the affected perspective or qualify the use. Consult D.1–D.5 when a value or harm conflict needs resolution. |
The following terms answer different narrative questions. Stronger factual claims require additional grounds.
| Narrative function | Useful for | Not enough for |
|---|---|---|
| Protagonist | Centering attention or action path. | Responsibility, role assignment, moral standing, or capability. |
| Actant | Describing a participant’s function in a plot or transformation. | A real System’s classification, assignment, capability or responsibility. |
| Voice | Controlling stance, distance, confidence, or witness posture. | Evidence strength, source authority, or ethical permission. |
| Focalization | Selecting the information shown and the position from which it is available. | Completeness, neutrality or the truth of the underlying factual account. |
| Personification | Teaching or memory aid for abstract structures. | Actual agency, decision authority, or intent. |
Keep ordinary metonymy if the action and participant are clear. “The paper proves the lemma” can refer to the proof it contains. If “the architecture wants fewer dependencies” is used to justify a design decision or assign responsibility, identify the structural criterion, the choice and whoever had the relevant authority.
A viewpoint can be retained while clarifying the relation it obscures. Identify the relevant fact or participant and how a reader can recover it.
NSTD.4:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.4:5.1 - Worked slice: viewpoint without false agency
“The database wants consistency and the service wants speed” can introduce a trade-off. A reader diagnosing response time needs the actual order of transaction and replication operations and the conditions under which a wait delays the response.
NarrativeViewpointRecord@ArchitecturePersonification:
narrativeRenderingRef: ArchitectureExplanation@v1
viewpointOrVoiceKind: didactic personification
focalizedSourceStructureRef: consistency and latency trade-off across selected architecture structures
narrativeFunction: introduce the consistency and response-time trade-off through personification
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs: commit condition, critical path, decision record and observed timings
agencyOrResponsibilityRisk: component metaphor may be read as actor agency or authority
literalizationRepair: state the commit condition and when the wait delays the response. Identify change authority if a change is proposed
sourceReturnCondition: use the architecture description for the arrangement, the governing decision for authority and timing evidence for a claim about actual delay
Before:
The database refuses to let the service move fast.
After:
This configuration requires acknowledgement from a replica before the database confirms a commit. The requirement protects the stipulated consistency condition. Waiting for acknowledgement increases the service’s response time when that wait extends the critical path to the response. An overlapping, longer operation can hide the delay. For an observed request, consult its timing evidence. For a proposed change, check the configuration decision and who may change it.
NSTD.4:5.2 - Worked slice: narrator and reader roles
An imagined user can describe a possible consequence of a future design. Identify the passage as a scenario. An actual user report or consultation requires evidence from the user or an appropriate record.
NarrativeViewpointRecord@FutureUserScenario:
viewpointOrVoiceKind: prospective scenario voice
focalizedSourceStructureRef: expected use situation and system interaction
narrativeFunction: expose usability and risk questions before design is final
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs: actual user evidence, policy claim, safety claim
agencyOrResponsibilityRisk: imagined voice is treated as real stakeholder authority
literalizationRepair: mark the proposed experience as a scenario. Use suitable user evidence for a claim about actual experience
sourceReturnCondition: examine the scenario assumptions or available user evidence when the relevant claim changes
NSTD.4:5.3 - Choosing a viewpoint repair
Keep wording that already makes the relevant action clear. If a viewpoint hides a needed relation, add that relation, change perspective or name the responsible participant. Mark a scenario or metaphor when the reader could otherwise rely on it as an observation. Replace the device if its effect depends on concealing a fact needed for the intended use.
Compare a literal account or another viewpoint when the comparison helps. For the database, can a reader identify the commit condition and determine when it delays a response? For the imagined user, can the reader tell what was proposed and what was observed? An editor can assess the information the passages provide. A relevant response can show how a particular reader interpreted it. Use NSTD.6 if a qualified quality judgement is required.
NSTD.4:5.4 - FPF owner teaching
Viewpoint selects and highlights structure for a use. An architect’s view, a narrator’s voice and a protagonist’s function can help recover different aspects of the same case. When a real agency, assignment, capability or responsibility claim matters, recover that claim separately under its applicable definition.
“The architecture wants to reduce coupling” may express a criterion favouring fewer dependencies at an accepted cost. For a claim about the choice, identify who decided under the relevant authority and what they chose. Under A.2.1 an assignment relates its holder System to the assigned local role kind within its stated scope. The decision record can establish which option was selected.
In a franchise continuation, a protagonist centers the telling. The fictional premises govern which actions and motives are plausible. “The Force guided the decision” may supply the intended story-world explanation or leave the character’s choice unclear. Ask which relation the scene needs.
In a homotopy explanation, a loop that “remembers” a hole can direct attention to a constraint on deformation. Where a learner needs the mathematical conclusion, supply the formal restriction and the argument it supports.
Live commentary can follow one player, a coach or a tactical unit while leaving off-ball actions or a pending ruling outside view. Use the relevant record or qualify blame and capability when the unseen action would change that attribution.
Read figurative expressions in their context.
| Risky phrase | Safe if read as | Repair if literal reading would be false |
|---|---|---|
| “The architecture wants…” | Shorthand for a selected quality pressure. | State the structural criterion or trade-off; name the decision-maker if the choice or responsibility is at issue. |
| “The paper proves…” | The paper contains the claimed proof. | If proof status is disputed or conditional, identify the argument and its unresolved step or premise. |
| “The model knows…” | A shorthand whose relevant behavioral meaning is clear. | State the claimed behavior, available information or tested capability when the wording would change reliance. |
| “The protagonist represents the system…” | Reader-facing focalization. | State which source structures the protagonist highlights and hides. |
| “The market punished…” | A description of an aggregate outcome. | Describe the observed change and distinguish an established mechanism from a conjecture when the explanation affects reliance. |
Keep a needed clarification close to the disputed phrase. “Under the chosen trade-off, fewer dependencies are preferable” can state the design criterion directly.
Change viewpoint when another position can reveal a required relation. A novice’s account may omit the maintainer’s cost of coupling. Following an attacker may hide an off-ball defender or an unresolved ruling. An imagined user can describe a possible experience while the responsible organization supplies the constraints and authority.
These examples use the optional viewpoint note.
NarrativeViewpointAgencyDiscipline@ArchitecturePersonification:
viewpointOrVoice: teacher voice using personification
focalizedObjectRef: selected architecture candidate
revealedSourceStructureRefs: coupling pressure; cohesion target; interface exception
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs: architect role assignment; decision record; telemetry
narrativeFunctionTerms: "architecture wants" as memory aid
personificationOrAgencyWording: architecture described as wanting fewer dependencies
relevantSourcesAndAuthorityIfNeeded: decision about coupling, cohesion and the interface exception. Use suitable design or operating evidence for a claimed effect and the responsible decision holder for a proposed change
attributionAtRisk: responsibility for the decision to reduce coupling
repairAction: state the structural criterion and identify the decision holder if responsibility is at issue
NarrativeViewpointAgencyDiscipline@FictionalProtagonistProbe:
viewpointOrVoice: close protagonist viewpoint for private storycraft testing
focalizedObjectRef: protagonist function in continuation route
revealedSourceStructureRefs: character agency constraint; premise; causal plot support
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs: alternative viewpoints; broader canon conflicts; publication rights
narrativeFunctionTerms: protagonist; actant; motivation
relevantSourcesAndAuthorityIfNeeded: selected canon and premises for the character’s choices, and an applicable licence or rights holder for a proposed publication
blockedAgencyOverread: protagonist centrality does not create moral permission or canon authority
repairAction: establish the character’s possible action under the premises. For proposed publication, use the applicable licence or obtain a determination if permission remains unresolved
NarrativeViewpointAgencyDiscipline@LiveCommentaryView:
viewpointOrVoice: commentator follows attacking side under time pressure
focalizedObjectRef: attacking player or unit
revealedSourceStructureRefs: possession, pressure, chance creation
hiddenOrWeakenedSourceStructureRefs: defensive shape, off-ball movement, official review
narrativeFunctionTerms: "forced", "wanted", "could not"
relevantSourcesAndAuthorityIfNeeded: relevant event record and evidence for the attribution. Consult the responsible source for an official ruling or ethics guidance for a consequential harm question
blockedAgencyOverread: live focalization is not settled blame or capability assessment
repairAction: mark provisional interpretation and later source-return route
Where a figurative phrase leaves consequential agency unclear, identify the acting participant, the decision or the limits of the metaphor. Preserve verbs that accurately describe real actions. Keep a separate record when a later use needs it.
NSTD.4:5.5 - Worked case: continue a voice, then change the genre
Mira, her selected passages and the drafts below are constructed for this example. The editor’s question is how to carry a speaking relationship between two genres. The sensor data are given.
Mira wants an editor to continue a reflective essay for technically capable readers. She selects these two passages as models:
The result looked settled until I opened the notebook. Three runs, all in the same warm room. Useful evidence—and a rather small world for such a confident claim.
I like a difficult detail to earn its place. Show me the detail, and then show me what it changes.
The selected passages present a discrepancy before judging it, follow a concrete detail with a shorter reflective turn and invite the reader to examine its consequence. The editor uses these choices for this continuation. Mira recalls opening the notebook in the first model passage. An unrelated memory would need its own basis.
The new report describes three tests at 20 °C, each within 1 °C absolute error. It supplies no results below 5 °C. The proposed cold store operates below 5 °C and requires the same error limit. The essay has introduced the purchase and will now discuss what evidence would support it.
An initial treatment tries to make the voice warmer:
I remember shivering in that cold store while the sensor lied to me. Surely we all know that three comfortable tests do not tell the whole story.
The editor rejects the invented memory and the appeal to a shared judgement before the reader can inspect the conditions. The next passage follows the selected models from a concrete detail to a limited conclusion.
The report gives a small, tidy success. Three tests at 20 °C, each within the 1 °C limit. Our proposed cold store runs below 5 °C. The report is silent about that range. A colder room is doing rather a lot of work in this purchase decision. Before recommending the sensor for use in the cold store, we need evidence that it meets the same limit in the cold.
Between the purchase proposal and the next paragraph, the passage gives a reason to seek cold-range evidence. The lightly ironic sentence about the colder room belongs to this essay. The final “we” can include the writer and reader in examining a recommendation. Purchase authority belongs to the holder designated for that decision.
In this constructed case the editor judges that the draft preserves the chosen progression and restrained irony. It states the single test temperature and the limit of the available report without inventing a cold-range failure. It also gives a proposed next step. To attribute acceptance to Mira or recognition to a reader, use evidence of that response. A claim of learning needs evidence of the resulting capability and its conditions.
Now Mira needs a formal recommendation to a purchasing committee. The intended voice still treats the reader as capable and makes the decisive limitation inspectable, but the committee needs the recommendation immediately. The editor retains that relationship, moves the decision first and drops the reflective joke:
Defer selection until adequate evidence establishes that the sensor meets the 1 °C error limit in the cold store’s operating range. The three reported tests met the limit at 20 °C. This report supplies no results below 5 °C.
This changed occasion alters order, rhythm and address while retaining the evidence-to-judgement relation. Blindly retaining the joke or first-person recollection would have mistaken a local realization for the whole voice. If Mira instead required a deliberately personal public statement, that different choice would reopen the treatment, not the supplied temperature facts.
In both versions, choose the intended relationship, use the expressions relevant to that occasion and compare manner, meaning and use. For a new narrator, the writer can instead select a relationship and try it directly, as in the next case.
NSTD.4:5.6 - Unlike entry: make a new fictional narrator
A writer has no prior voice to imitate. The scene premise is that a novice night guard finds an unexpected key; the writer wants guarded curiosity, with the narrator reluctant to admit fear. Two trials use the same event:
An unexpected key was discovered at 02:10. Its origin remained unknown.
I turned the key under the lamp. What did it open? Then I pushed it farther away. There was no reason for that, of course.
The first trial chooses a distant reporting voice. In the second, examining the key and asking what it opens express curiosity. Pushing it away and denying a reason suggest unease. The writer chooses that combination while preserving the guard’s ignorance of the key’s origin and purpose. A later scene can disclose the origin while the guard still lacks access. Maintain that difference in the account. A particular reader may know it earlier or miss the disclosure.
Turning the key and pushing it away are new fictional events introduced by the second trial. NSTD.10 can develop them against the scene’s premises. Unlike Mira’s essay, this task calls for an invented speaker. The speaking relationship and the continuity of the resulting events still have to work in the actual passage.
NSTD.4:6 - Bias-Annotation
A vivid protagonist or personification can draw attention away from the grounds of an attribution. Compare the narrative function with the actual action, capability or responsibility being claimed, and repair only the consequential mismatch.
A memorable habit can be overgeneralized into an author’s whole voice; a fluent rewrite can also smooth away an awkwardness that carried hesitation, humour or a useful distinction. Compare the relevant source expression and its contribution before normalizing it. Treat an inferred tendency as revisable, and do not mistake a familiar genre convention for a universal reader preference.
NSTD.4:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD4-1 | Viewpoint, voice, focalized object, or protagonist choice is named when load-bearing. |
CC-NSTD4-2 | The assessment identifies the relations made available or concealed by the viewpoint under the assumed knowledge. Claims about a particular reading use evidence of the interpretation at issue. |
CC-NSTD4-3 | Narrative function, real participant, local system-role kind, obtaining assignment, capability and responsibility are distinguished wherever the claim depends on them. |
CC-NSTD4-4 | Precise agency and Work claims use their current defining conditions; ordinary contribution wording does not require an invented assignment or Work record. |
CC-NSTD4-5 | A figurative phrase that invites a consequential misattribution is clarified. Ordinary unambiguous metonymy can remain. |
CC-NSTD4-6 | When a voice is being constructed or preserved, the intended speaker relationship and basis are usable: authentic or accepted examples, an identified stylization, or a chosen new treatment. A label alone does not settle the expression. |
CC-NSTD4-7 | The connected fragment realizes the relevant choices while retaining the needed thought, intellectual level and warranted speaker position. |
CC-NSTD4-8 | A consequential change of subject, genre or language receives its own treatment; retained and altered properties have a reason in the new use. |
CC-NSTD4-9 | Voice fit, fidelity to source or premises and actual reader performance have grounds suited to each claim. After a change, reconsider the relations that depended on it. |
NSTD.4:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Protagonist as responsible agent | Narrative centrality is used to attribute moral or operational responsibility. | Identify the protagonist’s function in the telling. Use A.13, A.2.1 and the relevant ethics guidance when the corresponding real agency, assignment or responsibility is at issue. |
| Hidden participant | “The specification decided” obscures who made a consequential decision. | Identify who chose and the applicable authority. Keep ordinary metonymy when the choice and its holder are already clear. |
| Viewpoint hides an affected party | A compelling account omits a consequence that matters to someone affected. | Recover the relevant perspective or source and correct the account if needed. Use D.1–D.5 when a value or harm conflict requires resolution. |
| Voice by label | “Warm,” “expert” or a person’s name leaves the actual manner undefined. | Use relevant expression or a selected trial to show how the speaker develops a thought with this reader. |
| Mannerism as preservation | A joke or catchphrase survives while the difficult idea or speaking relationship disappears. | Restore the needed thought and choose the expression for its contribution here. |
| Invented personal authority | First person turns a constructed scene or editorial inference into apparent experience. | Recover the actual basis or state the construction; preserve legitimate first-person expression. |
| Voice approval as general assurance | Acceptance of a manner is treated as evidence of meaning, accuracy or learning. | Make the separate comparison needed for the claimed result. |
NSTD.4:9 - Consequences
A writer can continue or change a voice with grounds for the choices that matter on the new occasion. An assessment may instead identify how an existing passage handled viewpoint and attribution. A profile or study of reader response is worth its added cost when the task requires what that further work can establish.
NSTD.4:10 - Rationale
Voice and focalization change how a reader encounters events, knowledge and consequences. Relating expressive choices to a speaking relationship explains why some can carry into a new passage while others must change. Comparing connected expression makes that choice inspectable without reducing a voice to a fixed list of words or sentence lengths.
The chosen expression invites inferences about who knows, experiences or acts. One viewpoint can suffice for a scene. An account may need another when the first hides a relation the reader must recover. Compare fit of manner, support for the expressed claims and reader response under the conditions each conclusion requires. The construction is an authoring synthesis. Its success rate across languages, authors or readers would require evidence across those uses.
NSTD.4:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Schmid’s Narratology: An Introduction and Chihaia’s survey of introductions locate voice and focalization in their narratological traditions. In Chen and Xu’s perspective and focalization study (2026), third-person versions of negatively valenced texts took longer to read in two of the measured regions of text. The study found no significant perspective effect on reading times in the internal-focalization condition. Some fNIRS channels differed across conditions. These observations concern those tasks. Nguyen-Trung and Nguyen’s NITA (2026) assigns interpretation to the qualitative researcher. The distinction between narrative function and real agency here draws on FPF.
For the database case, the short personification may serve an expressive purpose. For latency diagnosis, add the commit prerequisite and determine whether its wait extends the request’s critical path. A timed trace may already supply that answer for the request investigated.
Use narratology for the distinction between voice and focalization, and studies of reading for the responses observed under their conditions. NITA assigns a particular interpretive role to a human qualitative researcher. For a real attribution of role, action or authority, apply the relevant FPF distinction.
Kumar et al.’s Whose story is it? (2025, §§3–4) ties proposed author tendencies to story excerpts and uses them to tailor generation instructions. An editor can use the connection between a proposed tendency and a passage showing it. The study’s story-generation comparisons do not settle whether a particular new draft preserves its author’s voice in another language or genre.
Two 2026 preprints examine related questions. Zhang, Bu and Dhillon’s Who Owns the Text? distinguishes a coaching persona from personalization to a writer’s style. The short tasks and combined design limit claims about each element’s individual effect. Van Nuenen’s Voice Under Revision reports aggregate stylistic shifts in English personal narratives even with preservation instructions. Its measured features can locate changes to inspect. Reader recognition requires evidence of how a reader responded to a particular passage.
For a short continuation, an apt example can preserve a way of speaking that a summary would lose. Working observations can help several contributors, a change of genre or a recurring difficulty. A maintained profile can be worthwhile for repeated work, though it takes time and can overgeneralize the sample. Compare the actual new passage with its material and purpose in all three cases. Section 4 brings continuing voices, stylization and new narrators into one authoring method. The cited studies test particular writing and reading conditions.
NSTD.4:12 - Relations
Use NSTD.1 when the intended reader or material needs clarification. NSTD.5 can develop an expressive device, NSTD.7 can supply a tool-assisted composition for comparison and NSTD.6 qualifies a question about quality or reception. F.19 helps recover consequential meaning and action in technical prose. Use NSTD.9 for unresolved interpretation and NSTD.10 for a needed fictional or explicitly hypothetical construction.
Use A.6.3.NAR for narrative form. For real roles, agency, capability or their measurement, use the conditions in §4.6 for A.2, A.2.1, A.13, A.2.2, A.19.ECS and C.16. Use D.1–D.5 for a consequential value or harm conflict, A.10 when an evidence route must be recovered or made reproducible, B.3 when a claim’s reliability matters and G.11 when a changed basis affects a maintained account. Reconsider the passage when its speaker, model, content, genre, language, use or relevant source changes. The Architecture and Narrative Work Bridge addresses an actual architecture view, the Semiotic and Language-Precision Bridge a sign or language choice that affects interpretation, and NSTD.Reference:11 the relevant term and its defining practice.
NSTD.4:End
NSTD.5 - Choose Narrative Engagement Devices for the Intended Experience or Use
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: choosing, assessing or revising narrative devices that direct attention, sustain interest or make a relation memorable for an intended use.
NSTD.5:1 - Problem frame
Use this method when attention, curiosity, identification, suspense or another reader experience matters to the work. It can also help identify why an account encourages misplaced confidence or directs attention away from a required distinction.
Identify the intended effect, then examine a device in an existing passage or try it in the passage being composed. Compare what it adds, changes or removes. An available simpler treatment can help make the difference clear. For a choice or revision, weigh the contribution against its cost and preserve the relations the reader needs.
A reader may leave before the useful part, remember the wrong feature or take a vivid example for stronger evidence than it is. Each observation points to a different question about the passage.
The result can be a device chosen for its expressive purpose, an account of what the text makes salient, or a finding about the response of readers under known conditions.
NSTD.5:2 - Problem
A story can organize attention and memory around a relation the reader needs. The same device can hide a qualification, reduce a genuine conflict to one viewpoint or lend a conjecture the apparent force of an observation. Decide which effect matters and what would establish it for this use.
NSTD.5:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Attention vs source fidelity | Engagement can help readers reach source structure or distract from it. |
| Motivation and informed choice | A device can help a reader pursue an aim or conceal information needed to choose it. |
| Memory and confidence | A reader can remember a story and still misjudge how well its claim is supported. |
| Different readers | The same device can direct attention in different ways depending on what readers already know and what they are trying to do. |
NSTD.5:4 - Solution
Start with the intended use and the passage. An existing reader response can establish a past result. A close comparison can show how a proposed device changes what the passage supplies. Keep a note like this when someone will use the comparison across revisions or audiences.
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@Context:
narrativeRenderingRef:
intendedEngagementEffect:
protectedSourceStructureRefs:
languageStateFacetProfileRef?:
coarseningOrPrecisionQuestion?:
affectedReaderOrGroupRefs?:
persuasionBoundary:
nonAdmissibleUse:
affectedPartyQuestion?:
additionalClaimGrounds?:
proposedChangeIfNeeded:
Choose the device for the intended use. Preserve source relations promised by an explanation and premises that govern a fictional or hypothetical account. If a literary or simplified expression makes a consequential inference ambiguous, clarify the relation. Use C.2.LS, A.6.3.CSC, E.17.EFP or E.10 for the corresponding language, coarsening, explanation or precision question. Pursue evidence, assurance or ethics work when the claim or planned influence requires it.
For a design or an assessment, use the parts of this comparison that answer the question.
- Identify the intended effect, such as attention, curiosity, emotional salience, identification, suspense, memory or willingness to continue.
- Identify the relations, qualifications or choices the reader still needs to recover.
- Identify the device at work or try one suited to the task. An analogy can introduce an abstract relation, an open question can invite attention, and repetition can keep a distinction available.
- For a comparison of devices, identify what each treatment adds, changes or removes in order, salience, wording or repetition. Use an available relevant alternative where it helps. For an actual response, establish what the reader reported or did. Examine prior knowledge and other conditions when they bear on a claim about change, independent understanding or the device’s contribution.
- Examine what a reader can infer under the intended conditions. Does the passage express an uncertainty as settled, let an analogy stand in for a definition or omit a consequential alternative?
- Report the finding. If an editorial choice is needed, keep, change or remove the device according to its contribution and cost. A sufficient simpler passage can be retained. Use
NSTD.6for a qualified quality evaluation andNSTD.8for a learning question.
Where voice matters, use NSTD.4’s speaking relationship and its selected examples or new treatment. A joke, intimate address or repeated question can change who seems to speak and how that speaker treats the reader. Compare the passage with its surroundings and the required voice. A device developed for an essay may need changing for an instruction or a decision notice.
Select the further question by the reader’s use.
| Reader effect | Practical comparison | Further work when it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Continue reading | Does the location and pacing of the passage let readers reach the needed part? For actual continuation, examine how far they read. | Change the opening, pacing or viewpoint if a revision is called for and contributes to that aim. |
| Remember a relation | What does a reader reconstruct after the relevant interval, with the stated support? | Use NSTD.6 for a qualified recovery assessment or NSTD.8 to design learning. |
| Care about a problem | Does the device clarify the stakes and available choices? | Examine a relevant affected-party or manipulation concern through D.1–D.5. |
| Believe a claim | Are belief and confidence appropriate to its grounds? | Inspect the source; use A.10 when the source-to-use account is implicit or must remain replayable, and B.3 for an actual named assurance claim. |
| Decide or act | Does the account preserve the conditions and alternatives needed for that choice? | Use the method for the actual decision if a decision is required. Its holder needs the relevant authority. |
| When readers leave early, their responses or access conditions can help locate the difficulty. A different opening, example, rhythm or viewpoint may help. When they become overconfident, check whether the account omits a condition, presents a hypothesis as settled or overlooks another source of the belief. Change the passage if its contribution to the problem is established. |
Artistic language can carry atmosphere, felt experience or expression. A memorial may chiefly need that quality. A technical explanation may depend on a condition its metaphor obscures. Examine language-state facets when they help settle the relevant difficulty.
Suspense may depend on an outcome that remains possible within the story, or on when the reader is given information about an outcome already fixed. Use NSTD.10 to construct a needed fictional or hypothetical alternative and NSTD.9 to assess competing readings. A withheld answer, a genuinely unsettled question and a missing premise offer different grounds for curiosity. A reader who knows the answer in advance may respond differently.
NSTD.5:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.5:5.1 - Worked example: a failure story that teaches a usable distinction
In a fictional teaching case, a team follows the same checklist after its workload changes. The story can make the missing condition visible. Whether a learner identifies the mismatch and whether FPF improves real projects are different questions.
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@FPFFailureStory:
narrativeRenderingRef: FPFLearningRoute@v1
engagementDevice: failed-use contrast with tension and repair
protectedSourceStructureRefs:
- pattern conditions
- forces
- neighboring exits
- evaluation and improvement route
intendedEffect: keep attention and make misuse recognizable
persuasionOrHarmRisk: reader treats story as proof of FPF superiority or as blame of a real group
sourceFidelityRisk: checklist failure hides the actual source relation being taught
precisionBackoff: identify the fictional example and point to the pattern's conditions of use
evaluationReturn: use a relevant response to assess reconstruction of the changed condition. A report of agreement addresses a different question
Before:
This disaster proves why teams must use FPF.
After:
In this fictional case, the team reused a checklist that assumed a stable workload after demand had changed. Before repeating the old action, compare its assumptions with the present workload. The case illustrates the mismatch. Whether FPF improves actual projects requires evidence from their use.
NSTD.5:5.2 - Worked example: an engaging homotopy image with its limiting condition
A homotopy lesson asks the learner to imagine a loop around a missing point. A loop that winds once around the missing point cannot shrink to a point by a continuous deformation that stays in the punctured plane. If the missing point is restored, the same loop can shrink in the plane. The contrast gives “slipping around a hole” its relevant boundary. Use a response to assess whether a particular learner recovered it.
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@HomotopyLoopImage:
engagementDevice: vivid analogy
protectedSourceStructureRefs: deformation under constraints, invariant, formal definition, proof-status boundary
intendedEffect: sustain attention through abstraction
persuasionOrHarmRisk: low, unless used to make a false certainty claim
sourceFidelityRisk: analogy replaces condition-bound definition
precisionBackoff: state where analogy stops and return to formal statement
evaluationReturn: check which deformations the learner marked as permitted or blocked if their understanding is the question
NSTD.5:5.3 - Engagement device selection matrix
| Device | Possible contribution | Risk | Repair when the risk occurs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tension | Can sustain attention while an explanation remains uncertain. | The passage suggests that one disputed explanation is settled. | Show the existing result and the question it leaves open. |
| Failure story | Can make the consequence of a missed condition vivid. | An anecdote becomes the sole ground for blame or a general claim. | Identify a constructed case or establish what actually happened. Restore the condition that makes it relevant. |
| Analogy | Can make a selected abstract relation easier to follow. | It replaces the definition or argument needed by the use. | State the condition at which the analogy stops and make the required formal relation available. |
| Character viewpoint | Can draw attention to a participant or relation. | Prominence invites an unsupported attribution of action or responsibility. | Clarify the consequential attribution, using NSTD.4 when its viewpoint analysis is needed. |
| Surprise reveal | Can support curiosity or memory by changing when information becomes available. | A late disclosure withholds a condition the reader needs earlier, or the account omits it altogether. | Recover a genuinely missing source relation through NSTD.1 or reconsider its place through NSTD.2. If the needed relation and order are already clear, use the scene directly. |
| Humor or style | Can make a passage easier to approach or remember. | Loses a distinction needed for the later use. | Restore that distinction; use C.2.LS, A.6.3.CSC or E.10 only for the unresolved language, coarsening or precision question. |
NSTD.5:5.4 - Comparing engagement choices
Compare the intended effect with the information the reader needs. An editorial walkthrough can establish what the versions express under stated assumptions. A response may show how one reader understood or experienced a version. If a selection is required, compare the alternatives on the intended use, their expressive aims and costs. To attribute a difference in reception to this device, consider other differences between versions and readers. Use NSTD.6 when the judgement needs formal qualification.
NSTD.5:5.5 - Keeping the reader’s use in view
Identify which reader and activity matter. Interest in an unresolved problem can help a reader explore it while leaving the grounds for belief and choice visible.
A plain version of the workload case is “When demand changes, check whether the workload assumptions still hold before reusing the checklist.” The story adds a team caught in that mismatch. Compare whether each version gives the reader the changed assumption and the next relevant check. An expert can identify those differences in the text. Observed attention, memory or a claim that the story caused an improvement need evidence bearing on that outcome. A small expressive gain may justify the longer version, and a sufficient plain explanation can stand.
A science communicator can use tension around a measured result with several live explanations. Preserve the measurement, its scope and the open alternatives. If readers use the account in a policy argument, establish which inference the scientific evidence supports. An actual policy decision has additional conditions and a decision holder.
A homotopy lesson can invite learners to imagine stretching a loop. For a task that depends on the permitted deformations, include the relevant domain and restrictions. If the passage supplies them and a response still treats every deformation as allowed, establish what contributed to that reading before revising the source content or the illustration.
A franchise continuation can use suspense, raised stakes or identification for their expressive effects. Where the brief requires continuity with established events or character choices, preserve those conditions in the device. A new artistic aim can justify a different comparison.
In live commentary, excitement can keep attention on an unfolding play. Identify the observed event, the score, any tactical inference and what awaits an official ruling. The unresolved outcome can itself supply the suspense.
The following examples show how a device can help or obstruct a particular use.
| Device | Good use | Failure mode | Repair |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hook | Raises a question the account helps the reader answer or explore. | Promises a particular answer the material never supplies. | Change the promise or supply the missing contribution. |
| Tension | Keeps an unresolved relation worth following. | Presents a disputed explanation as a settled outcome. | Retain the live alternative and its grounds. |
| Identification | Helps readers experience a viewpoint. | Sympathy hides another affected participant or relevant alternative. | Restore the missing viewpoint or alternative where the intended decision needs it. |
| Analogy | Makes abstract structure graspable. | Replaces definition or proof boundary. | State where analogy stops and source returns. |
| Repetition | Keeps an easily lost relation available. | Repeats a slogan that obscures the relation. | Repeat the meaningful distinction; add a reconstruction attempt when learning calls for it. |
| Compression | Can make a passage usable in the available time. | Removes a distinction the reader needs later. | Restore that distinction or restrict the stated use. Use A.6.3.CSC when the allowed coarsening itself needs analysis. |
| Literary style | Supports pacing, atmosphere or a felt experience. | Its appeal is used to vouch for a factual claim or for quality under another criterion. | Identify the intended expressive result and the basis for any stronger claim. Use language-state or quality guidance where that question remains open. |
Compare the actual passages and the use. A dry treatment may lose attention before a needed relation, and a vivid one may conceal its limiting condition. If either difficulty matters, change the feature that contributes to it.
Working examples for a continuing revision or team comparison follow.
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@FPFLearningRoute:
intendedEngagementEffect: motivation and memory for pattern-use reconstruction
protectedSourceStructureRefs: EntityOfConcern; forces; solution; relations; source-return condition
languageStateFacetProfileRef: plain teaching narrative with repeated anchors
affectedReaderOrGroupRefs: new FPF authors and reviewers
persuasionBoundary: may motivate study; may not prove FPF authority or tell readers to bypass checks
nonAdmissibleUse: evidence of FPF correctness; replacement for pattern bodies
proposedChangeIfNeeded: add a task or source cue for a missing connection, or revise the motivational claim
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@HomotopyAnalogy:
intendedEngagementEffect: curiosity and retention for abstract structure
protectedSourceStructureRefs: definitions; examples; proof-status boundary; formal return
languageStateFacetProfileRef: analogy plus formal boundary markers
persuasionBoundary: analogy may invite exploration, not replace proof
nonAdmissibleUse: theorem proof, formal definition, or exam solution without source return
proposedChangeIfNeeded: restore the relevant formal condition, counterexample or source before adding a further metaphor
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@FranchiseContinuationProbe:
intendedEngagementEffect: suspense, identification, and stakes for private storycraft critique
protectedSourceStructureRefs: canon constraint; continuity; character agency; causal plot support
affectedReaderOrGroupRefs: private reviewers; no public audience permission implied
persuasionBoundary: emotional satisfaction does not override source-pack or rights boundary
nonAdmissibleUse: publication, canon authority, or rights claim
proposedChangeIfNeeded: restore any continuity, agency or causal connection required by the private storycraft task
NarrativeEngagementBoundary@LiveCommentary:
intendedEngagementEffect: attention under unfolding uncertainty
protectedSourceStructureRefs: observed event; provisional inference; score state; official return
affectedReaderOrGroupRefs: listeners and any named parties if blame or harm framing appears
persuasionBoundary: suspense and emotion do not settle blame, prediction, or official fact
nonAdmissibleUse: final evidence, disciplinary judgment, or settled tactical analysis
proposedChangeIfNeeded: identify the uncertainty or official source, or qualify the attribution of blame
NSTD.5:6 - Bias-Annotation
Interest, confidence and sympathy can matter to a narrative’s purpose. To support a factual claim, explain its subject grounds. For a real decision or permission, identify the relevant authority and conditions. When persuasion conceals a material alternative or consequence for a reader or another affected party, examine that loss in the passage and its use.
NSTD.5:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD5-1 | The editor identifies which reader experience or expression the device is intended to support. An observed effect is grounded in the corresponding reception. |
CC-NSTD5-2 | Relations and conditions needed for that use remain recoverable. |
CC-NSTD5-3 | Persuasion, policy, work, evidence, ethics, and assurance use boundaries are explicit when live. |
CC-NSTD5-4 | Affected readers, listeners, or groups are named when harm or manipulation risk is live. |
CC-NSTD5-5 | Judge engagement by its role in the stated use. Where the task requires recovery of a source relation, assess whether that relation is available and use an appropriate response for a claim about actual understanding. |
CC-NSTD5-6 | For an editorial choice, compare the device’s contribution and cost with the passage without it or an available relevant alternative. For a causal claim, use a comparison that distinguishes its effect. A report of what a reader noticed or experienced can use evidence of that response. Examine an ambiguity further when it matters to the conclusion. |
NSTD.5:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Fluency as truth | A smooth account invites reliance beyond its grounds. | State what the subject evidence supports. Use NSTD.6 for a needed recovery assessment and A.10 when the route from source to claim is implicit or must remain reproducible. |
| Identification replacing a condition for action | Sympathy with a protagonist is taken as sufficient grounds for a choice whose relevant condition or alternative is missing. | Restore the needed condition or alternative. Examine a further policy, work or affected-party question only when the actual proposed action raises it. |
| Literary appeal treated as overall adequacy | Memorable wording is preferred even when it loses a distinction needed for the task. | Compare the passage on the intended expressive and subject requirements. Use NSTD.6 for a needed qualified judgement or A.6.3.CSC to assess a deliberate coarsening. |
| Engagement taken as proof of understanding | A reader reports liking the passage. The work also requires comprehension of a relation. | Use a suitable response if understanding needs to be established. If the passage omits required material or misstates the link, repair the affected contribution through NSTD.1–NSTD.3. |
NSTD.5:9 - Consequences
Comparing a device with a relevant alternative can identify a contribution worth retaining or a qualification its wording obscures. The cost ranges from rereading one passage to obtaining new evidence about reception where the question warrants it.
NSTD.5:10 - Rationale
Design engages the reader through particular choices of content and expression. The same image can communicate a criterion in one account and obscure it in another. The intended use determines which comparison matters.
NSTD.5:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Green and Brock’s transportation study (2000) connects immersion with story-consistent beliefs. Dahlstrom and Ho’s science-communication analysis (2012) examines purpose, accuracy and whether narrative is suitable. These are historical anchors. Mengelkamp, Golke and Appel’s reading-goal experiments (2025) found condition-dependent comprehension benefits, while overestimation remained across conditions. Georgiou et al.’s narrative-memory study (2025) distinguishes recall, recognition and summary. These findings motivate separate attention, recovery and confidence questions; they do not establish one universally superior engagement device.
Use these source contributions for the questions they address.
- Transportation research raises the question of whether immersion contributes to a reader’s confidence in a claim. Compare the belief with its substantive grounds.
- Science-communication ethics makes the intended influence, required accuracy and choice of narrative explicit where they affect public reasoning.
- Reading-goal research motivates identifying the learning aim and assessing the resulting comprehension. Confidence in one’s own understanding is a further outcome.
- Memory research distinguishes retained gist from recalled detail. Select the aspect needed by the intended learning or later use.
- Use FPF language-state and coarsening methods when a compressed or literary treatment changes which distinctions a reader can recover. Judge quality on the declared use.
A judgement about curiosity, recall or confidence can answer the particular reception question. Use the evidence and criteria needed for any further claim about understanding or informed choice.
NSTD.5:12 - Relations
Use A.6.3.NAR, NSTD.1 and NSTD.3 for narrative form, selected material and its connections. NSTD.6 and C.16.Q help qualify the intended quality claim. Use C.2.LS, A.6.3.CSC, E.17.EFP, E.10 or A.6.P for the particular expression, coarsening, explanation or precision issue. For a consequential value or harm conflict use D.1–D.5. For an evidence route or assurance claim use A.10 or B.3 when needed. E.17 concerns publication for its audience, and G.11 a changed source affecting the maintained result. The Semiotic and Language-Precision Bridge addresses sign and expression choices, NSTD.Reference:11 locates definitions, and the Source Use and Refresh Map helps trace a consequential source claim.
NSTD.5:End
NSTD.6 - Declared-Use Narrative Rendering Quality Evaluation
Status: Stable
Type: DPF evaluation pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern:
NarrativeRenderingQualityEvaluationCharacteristicSpace@Context, the characteristics, scales and evidence used to evaluate a narrative rendering for a specified use.
NSTD.6:1 - Problem frame
Use this pattern to assess a version of a narrative for a particular reader or listener and use. An editor can inspect an existing handout or an unaccepted draft. Decide whether the question concerns the present product, its fidelity to a specified source, or what the author did to produce or repair it.
The evaluated object, NarrativeRenderingVersion@Context, is an identifiable version of a narrative account as expressed for a reader. A script, a slide sequence or a generated draft may contain one. Identify the account within a collection or teaching programme. An unknown source or a defect can itself be an evaluation finding. Assess the authority of the collection, the reliability of its generator or the quality of the entire programme under the criteria for that object.
Identify the version, its reader and the work the account should support. Select the relations and characteristics needed for that work. Check that the criteria distinguish an adequate account from a deficient one and refer a question about another object to the appropriate evaluation.
A technical narrative can be easy to read and still turn precedence into cause or omit the condition under which a reader must consult the source.
A repeatable evaluation identifies the grounds for each judgement. Use it in E.23 when the task includes improving the narrative.
Select the characteristics below for the use in question. They cover source selection, structural recovery, order, time and roles, source return and engagement. Examine evidence, assurance, ethics, publication authority or historical work when the corresponding claim is at stake.
NSTD.6:2 - Problem
A fluent narrative can misstate a relation. An accurate one can leave learners unable to follow it. To judge a version for its use, specify the object, characteristics, scales, evidence, treatment of missing information and thresholds. Show what supports each value, what an exceptional result would establish and what could repair a consequential deficiency.
NSTD.6:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Fluency and structural recovery | A reader can follow the prose while missing a relation needed for the task. |
| Engagement and informed use | A compelling story can conceal an uncertainty that changes the reader’s choice. |
| Local use and a reusable scale | A short rubric may serve one project. To compare judgements across cases, evaluators need common value meanings and stated conditions. |
| Measurement vs evaluation | Some values may be measured through C.16; many are ordinal content evaluations. |
| Improvement and proxy measures | Improving a measured indicator can damage a quality the indicator omits. Track the consequential effects on those qualities as well. |
NSTD.6:4 - Solution
Use an existing evaluation result if it answers the question for this narrative version, reader and use. If a suitable evaluation specification is available, apply it to the version. Develop or adapt a specification for any remaining question about which characteristics to judge and what evidence counts.
For explanatory technical prose, apply F.19 to the connected text. Recover its governing message, compare it with the selected source and test the contribution of each optional contrast, caveat or extra proposition for this reader and genre. Use F.19:4.4 for a proposed warning and F.19:4.5 for the reading evidence the conclusion needs. This wording judgement contributes to LanguageStatePrecisionAndCoarseningFit.
Decide what counts as a supported answer. Compare a factual account with evidence and a literary reading with the text and serious alternatives. For a deliberately open story, the reader may need to explain why several interpretations fit. For a fictional construction or a hypothetical real scenario, inspect the premises and their consequences. If the question concerns audience experience, examine evidence of that response. Use NSTD.9 for an interpretation still needed and NSTD.10 to construct missing events. Comparing two expressions can establish fidelity. Whether the source was adequate, the new account was worth producing or the audience responded as intended requires grounds for that claim.
Use NarrativeRenderingEpiplexity to assess how much selected structure a reader can correctly extract. It specializes FPF C.2.8 ExtractableStructuralInformation. Identify the receiving narrative episteme (the account conveyed), the particular expression conveying it and the reader or observer. Specify the source structure, correctness criterion, usable prior knowledge, operations, help, access and budget. A rendering reference can identify both account and expression when it is unambiguous. Record the conditions under the basis, scale and evidence fields below.
If naming the additional and missing relations answers the question, report them. For a count, define the units, then count the correctly recovered selected semantic relations. A fraction n/N needs a fixed nonempty selected set. For each unit preserve the participants, predicate, polarity, modality and conditions that change use. Count a relation once however often it is repeated or depicted. Keep its identity with the count. Two readers may each recover four of five relations while only one recovers the condition for stopping. Give any ordinal or nonnegative weight its structural meaning. Score utility separately. Use the formal mapping in C.2.8 for a bit estimate.
State whether the basis is a conditional walkthrough, an observed reading or a formal estimate with a specified mapping. A first response under known conditions shows the recovery observed in that trial and can inform an estimate of extractability. Establish a maximum, impossibility or reliability across a class only with evidence covering that claim. For a computational amount, specify the method and model. Retain the first response, help used and source returns. A familiar relation can still be recoverable from the expression. If an expert supplies a correction from prior knowledge, attribute that correction to its source. Decide whether correctness means recovering the source’s claim or recovering a warranted relation in the subject.
To isolate the effect of expression, hold the expressed claims and the other relevant conditions constant. A substantive change can identify another episteme under C.2.1. Report any changed access, preparation or help with the comparison it qualifies. Report performance after a perturbation or transfer under the new conditions. Use C.11.CRC and C.11 to compare effort and usefulness when relevant. A sufficient existing rendering can stay in use.
NarrativeRenderingQualityEvaluationCharacteristicSpace@Context:
evaluatedObjectKindRef: NarrativeRenderingVersion@Context
declaredUseScope:
objectKindFitRule:
discriminatingCaseSet:
characteristicSlotSet:
epiplexityBasisRule:
scaleBindingSet:
valueMeaningSet:
evidenceBasisRule:
missingnessAndLoweringRule:
resultRowShape:
floorAndExceptionalMeaning:
protectedTradeoffSet:
stopOrReopenCondition:
neighboringGoverningPatternRefs:
Identify the object before assigning a value.
| Object-kind case | Handling |
|---|---|
| Narrative account, whether candidate or accepted | Evaluate every characteristic whose failure would defeat the intended use. |
| Narrative rendering below a required floor | Report the supported value, the loss for this use and the smallest repair that could address it, if one is available. |
| The question concerns another object | Evaluate that object under its own criteria, such as reliability across a generator’s operating range or authenticity of a source archive. |
| The object proves to be another kind after the evaluation has begun | State the mismatch and stop assigning values to this object under the narrative criteria. |
Use these default meanings for the ordinal content-quality characteristics. Assign NarrativeRenderingEpiplexity its own structural amount and use condition as specified above.
| Value | Meaning |
|---|---|
0 | No usable basis for this quality judgement, or evaluation stopped before a quality value could be used. Give the cause. |
1 | Object is a narrative rendering but unusable for the declared use. |
2 | Suitable for orientation. Consult the source before relying on this account. |
3 | Locally usable with named limitations and repair obligations. |
4 | Good for declared use with bounded losses and source return. |
5 | Strong for the declared use. A reader can retrace the current source relation, the result under a meaningful change and the consequential boundary cases. When the use includes a historical claim, the evidence also makes the relevant construction or repair traceable. |
For teaching or other reliance-bearing use, the default is that every selected relation necessary for that use must be recoverable with the stated support and evidence. Specify those relations at the grain the task needs. A required distinction and its stop condition may suffice. Judge the amount recovered and the use condition separately. Unrelated relations cannot make up for a missing necessary one.
The other characteristics essential to the use have a default floor of 4 on their own scales, including OrderingRecoverability and SourceReturnReadiness when essential. If the selected source is a constraint-governed unfolding structure, DemonstrativeSliceRecoverability must reach 4. A local, low-risk orientation use may set these quality floors to 3 if it explicitly excludes the downstream uses the result cannot support. Select the structure before evaluating a narrower use. Removing a difficult relation after seeing the answer defines a different comparison.
Result-row shape:
NarrativeRenderingQualityResultRow@Context:
narrativeRenderingVersionRef:
declaredUseScopeRef:
characteristicId:
characteristicName:
scaleRef:
value:
evidenceBasisRefs:
missingnessClass:
loweringReason:
repairAction:
professionalOrAuthorityRefs?:
reopenCondition:
For repeated improvement, collect the relevant judgements in a result for the version and use being compared.
NarrativeRenderingQualityEvaluationResult@Context:
evaluatedNarrativeRenderingVersionRef:
declaredUseScopeRef:
evaluationCharacteristicSpaceRef: NarrativeRenderingQualityEvaluationCharacteristicSpace@Context
evaluationPurpose:
evidenceBasisRefs:
resultRows:
protectedTradeoffSet:
belowFloorRows:
candidateImprovementProposalRows?:
nonUseBoundary?:
stopOrReopenCondition:
When repeated improvement is wanted, use E.23 with NSTD.6 as the evaluation of the narrative. Use E.22 first if the quality question still needs framing.
NarrativeRenderingImprovementLoopInput@Context:
e22QuestionFrameRef?:
objectUnderImprovementRef: NarrativeRenderingVersion@Context
objectVersionBeforeRef:
objectUnderImprovementEvaluationRef: NSTD.6
improvementAim:
protectedTradeoffSet:
costAndRiskAccount:
allowedChangeSlice:
narrativeRenderingVersion | NSTD.1-intake | NSTD.2-ordering |
NSTD.3-event-model | NSTD.4-viewpoint | NSTD.5-engagement |
NSTD.7-generation-and-inspection | NSTD.8-learning-route |
NSTD.9-interpretation | NSTD.10-story-construction |
evaluationCharacteristicSpace
returnedFindingOrProposalRows:
expectedReEvaluationResultForm: NarrativeRenderingQualityEvaluationResult@Context
neighboringGoverningPatternRefs:
stopContinueSwitchOrHoldCondition:
To judge improvement, evaluate the changed version through NSTD.6 or a declared stronger evaluation. Compare it with an applicable baseline. Claim the gain that comparison establishes under the protected conditions. Specify what the change should improve and which qualities it must protect, including for a style edit, another generation attempt or added drama. If the change affects the source set or its currency, admission of generated material, the teaching or publication medium, an ethics, evidence or assurance claim, or the evaluation criteria, identify the applicable method. Include that work in the change being assessed or commission it separately. Use B.4 for a claim about evolution under repeated use. Under G.11, reconsider affected results when the source, reader observations, teaching evidence, generation practice or FPF edition changes enough to alter reliance. Reuse sufficient unaffected results.
Before assigning values, recover the source and use basis for the question being answered.
For current-product quality, derive the necessary structure from the work readers need to do, their prerequisites and qualified subject sources. Use the account to refine that selection and inspect what it conveys, hides or loses. Point to the relevant source and rendering passages. Recover the ordering rationale, conditions for source return and any consequential event, mechanism, viewpoint, agency, engagement or learning-route relations, using NSTD.1 through NSTD.5 and NSTD.8 as needed. Report this reconstruction as a present assessment with its uncertainties. Missing subject grounds, inaccessible returns and unsupported relations affect that assessment under their own criteria.
For a promised transformation, compare the named source and result against the preservation or change promised. For a claim about how the work was performed, use records or other evidence of the relevant actions. Trace the actual selection, order, mechanism, viewpoint, engagement and learning-route choices that the claim needs under NSTD.1 through NSTD.5 and NSTD.8. State which actions the evidence establishes. If the history remains unknown, give that limit to the work relying on it.
Evaluate a candidate before acceptance when its quality is in question. The result may support acceptance, repair or rejection. Use C.35 for generated or discovered content intended to inform architecture work. Before reusing a narrative as evidence, establish the relevant subject grounds. Use A.10 when the source-to-use account is implicit or must remain reproducible. For assurance, authority to publish or an effect on human learning, obtain evidence or authorization appropriate to that claim.
Carry out the parts of the evaluation that answer the question.
- Identify the version and the particular account in its text, slides or other expression. Direct a question about the whole course, source collection or generator to the evaluation for that object.
- Select evidence for the claim. Inspect the subject and rendering for present quality, compare the named source and result for promised fidelity, or establish the claimed work from evidence of its performance.
- Identify the work this reader or listener needs the account for and the conditions under which the judgement holds. State limits that affect reliance on the result.
- Evaluate every characteristic whose failure would defeat the declared use or make it unsafe. Select additional characteristics only when their result matters to the question.
- When a value falls below its floor, identify the loss. Give the smallest repair that would address it, or specify what is still needed to find one.
- Before claiming an improvement, re-evaluate the affected characteristics if the version or selected source basis changes.
Missingness and lowering rules:
| Missing or defect condition | Lowering rule |
|---|---|
| Selected structures cannot be identified from the task and subject sources | Leave the structural amount unassigned. Use NSTD.1 to complete source selection, NSTD.9 if the needed interpretation is missing or disputed, or NSTD.10 if the proposed events still need construction. State any separate mismatch in the evaluated object. |
| The reader, correctness criterion or another consequential condition of comparison is unknown | Leave the amount unassigned for that scope. Return any narrower finding that the available evidence supports and examine independently answerable questions. |
| Ordering rule absent | OrderingRecoverability no higher than 2. |
| A missing distinction of time, viewpoint, participant or mediation changes the reading for this use | Set TemporalPostureAndRoleFit no higher than 2. Use NSTD.1 or NSTD.4 to resolve that ambiguity. Apply the limit when the distinction matters to the interpretation. |
| A source-selection rationale or reader-use hypothesis needed for the evaluation cannot be recovered | Set SourceStructureSelectionFit no higher than 2 for that use and return the selection question to NSTD.1. Lower TemporalPostureAndRoleFit if its time or participant distinctions are also missing. Leave structural amount unassigned if its own selection, correctness or observer basis is unavailable. Check what can be recovered from all the pertinent material. |
| Source-return condition absent | SourceReturnReadiness no higher than 2. |
| The selected source branches, loops or allows early exits under constraints, and the account shows only a sequence | Set DemonstrativeSliceRecoverability no higher than 2. Use NSTD.1, NSTD.2 and A.22.CGUS or the applicable local method to recover the wider constraint-governed structure and what this route leaves out. |
| Simplification, literary wording or drama obscures a source relation, distinction of precision or limit of a coarser account needed for this use | Set LanguageStatePrecisionAndCoarseningFit no higher than 2. Repair the specific loss when its meaning is known. Use C.2.LS, A.6.3.CSC, E.17.EFP, E.10, A.6.P or C.16.Q for a remaining question of language state, coarsening, explanation or precision, then reassess the affected characteristic. |
| Only an intended effect or seed is available, without an identifiable narrative account | No narrative version is yet available for this evaluation. Develop the cue through A.16.1, NSTD.1 or NSTD.2, or evaluate the cue for its own use. |
| Persuasion conceals an uncertainty, risk or alternative material to the reader’s choice | Set EngagementBoundedness no higher than 3. Restore the relevant condition or alternative through NSTD.5. Use the applicable D.1–D.5 contribution if a consequential value or harm question remains for an affected party. |
| A generated narrative is still a candidate | Evaluate it for the stated use. Record the basis and limits. Use NSTD.7 when the generation method needs repair and C.35 when the content is meant to inform architecture work. |
| A claim about evidence or assurance lacks grounds | State which claim is unsupported and recover its criterion. Use A.10 for a source-to-use account that is implicit or must be reproducible and B.3 for a specified assurance claim. Judge each quality under its own criterion. Leave an unsupported structural amount unassigned. |
| The present product can be assessed, but its construction or repair history is unknown | Use the available product evidence for current quality. Report the historical limit to whoever relies on that claim and apply the relevant source, use and admission criteria to their own questions. |
A defined trial in which the reader recovers none of the selected relations supports observed recovery 0 for that trial. An empty selected set has no recovery fraction. Identify the object before assigning an amount. A walkthrough can support a conditional estimate. Use an existing reading when it answers an empirical question, or consider a new trial when the obtainable evidence would justify its cost for the task.
Default narrative rendering quality characteristics:
| Characteristic | Evaluation question | Low-value repair action |
|---|---|---|
SourceStructureSelectionFit | What does the reader need from the source? What grounds support the selection and any assumption about reader interest? | Use NSTD.1 to reconstruct or revise a deficient selection before changing the style, drama or generation instruction. |
NarrativeRenderingEpiplexity | Which selected relations can this observer correctly extract from the account through this expression under the specified conditions? When comparing alternatives, which relations differ? | Use C.2.8 for structural amount. Return a selection gap to NSTD.1. Repair a missing or false relation, its expression or a needed source return through the method for that problem. Reassess recovery if the repair changes what can be extracted. Use C.33 for an additional question about architecture-description adequacy. |
OrderingRecoverability | Can the reader recover the rationale for this order and the relevant relations the sequence leaves out? | Use NSTD.2 to state the ordering rule and which relations it preserves or hides. |
DemonstrativeSliceRecoverability | When a constraint-governed unfolding structure is selected, can the reader recover the wider structure, the demonstrative slice, and the hidden branches, loops, alternatives, direct exits, or stop conditions? | Reopen NSTD.1 and NSTD.2; name the selected CGUS or local block, the demonstrative slice, preserved constraints, lost structure, and return to A.22.CGUS or the local governing pattern. |
TemporalPostureAndRoleFit | Can the reader distinguish the relevant time, mediation, participants and viewpoints? | Use NSTD.1 or NSTD.4 to clarify observation, live reporting, proposal or fiction and who is speaking or acting. Obtain work-role, performer/assignment or architecture-admission evidence when the corresponding claim needs it. |
EventMechanismSupport | Can the reader reconstruct events, mechanisms, dependencies, or state changes when required? | Reopen NSTD.3; add mechanism support or lower causal language. |
ViewpointAgencyDiscipline | Does the viewpoint convey the source relation and accurately attribute action, capability, responsibility and permission? | Use NSTD.4 to distinguish the protagonist or actant from whoever acted, held a role or a permission, or bore the relevant responsibility. Examine the ethical question when it arises. |
EngagementBoundedness | Does engagement serve the intended effect while preserving source relations and the conditions needed for the reader’s choice? | Reopen NSTD.5; restore the missing condition, revise the device or keep a sufficient simpler account. |
LanguageStatePrecisionAndCoarseningFit | Does the chosen language state make the needed relations, precision and coarsening limits recoverable for this use? In explanatory technical prose, what does each optional rhetorical branch contribute to the intended reader? | Apply the connected F.19 reading to explanatory technical prose, retaining the distinctions that change its use. For a remaining question, use C.2.LS for a threshold-bearing language-state profile, A.6.3.CSC for narrowed-use coarsening, E.17.EFP for explanation-facing retelling, A.16.1/A.16.2 for cue or backoff, and E.10, A.6.P or C.16.Q for precision restoration. |
EthicsEvidenceAssuranceRouting | For a consequential claim about value, harm, evidence, assurance or policy, are the grounds and limits available for this use? | Identify the unresolved issue and use the pertinent D.1–D.5, A.10, B.3 or professional contribution. |
MediumAndPublicationFit | Does the carrier fit the reader and use without changing the claim? | Route publication or audience-unit questions to E.17, E.17.AUD, or NSTD.8. |
SourceReturnReadiness | Does the narrative tell readers when and where to return to the source basis or relevant method? | Add the missing return condition or destination, or narrow the supported use. |
LearningRouteReconstructionFit | What can the learner reconstruct under the intended support, and when must they return to a source? | Use NSTD.8 to address an inadequate source contribution, support or next task. In a design, assess what the exercise affords. In a claim about a learner, use their response. |
Use the ordinal meanings above and the adjacent-value examples below for LearningRouteReconstructionFit in teaching applications.
NSTD.6:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.6:5.1 - Value bank: full result rows
Each row evaluates an identifiable account for a particular use. Earlier acceptance is unnecessary, and a change in use can change the judgement.
| Case | Characteristic | Value | Evidence basis | Low-value repair |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FPF seminar handout | NarrativeRenderingEpiplexity | Qualitative illustration. The numerical amount is unknown. | The case assumes that learners can recover the EntityOfConcern, forces, solution and relevant exits. Their names alone specify neither equal units nor a denominator or an observed trial. | Retain this limited finding. If transfer matters, use evidence of a learner choosing an appropriate pattern in a different situation and report it under those conditions. |
| FPF seminar handout | SourceReturnReadiness | 4 | Each slogan in the constructed handout links to the relevant pattern. Before applying one in a new situation the exercise directs the reader to that pattern’s conditions. This shows when and where to return. A 5 also needs evidence under a meaningful change and at a consequential boundary. | Reconsider this value if a change in task, preparation or access affects the return, or if a reader cannot find or use it. Repair a confirmed failure even if the source text is unchanged. |
| FPF seminar handout | EngagementBoundedness | 4 | This clearly fictional failure story invites readers to compare workloads and gives them the relevant conditions. The value is a judgement about the design. | If increased attention is claimed, use an appropriate observed comparison. Restore any condition the persuasive use conceals. |
| Incomplete version of a homotopy lesson | LanguageStatePrecisionAndCoarseningFit | 3 | The vivid analogy leaves readers to infer which continuous deformations are allowed and when to consult the formal account. | Name the restriction on crossing the missing point and ask when it matters to contraction. |
| Homotopy explanation | OrderingRecoverability | 4 | The explanation names its teaching order and tells readers where to recover the dependencies of the proof. | To substantiate 5, examine a changed problem in which the reader maps the story order to the proof dependencies. |
| Franchise continuation probe | SourceReturnReadiness | 4 | An illustrative repair of the Readme’s key case puts this return in the draft: “If a scene assumes access before Wednesday, consult the supplied premise that the character first obtains the key on Wednesday.” The condition and destination are explicit. | If the premise or proposed access changes, reopen that continuity comparison. Check an appropriate changed case when robustness across cases matters. Reconsider new use conditions if they affect the return. |
| Live commentary | EventMechanismSupport | 3 | The commentator distinguishes observation from provisional interpretation. The listener receives only a general suggestion to consult later telemetry. | Identify the official record, replay or statistic and when it could resolve the particular claim. |
| Generated graph-to-text narrative | EventMechanismSupport | 2 | The draft states “A caused B”, while the source graph establishes only that A preceded B. | Return to NSTD.3 or NSTD.7: remove the unsupported cause or obtain the needed causal account. |
NSTD.6:5.2 - An existing product and an unknown manufacturing history
An editor receives an onboarding handout with a qualified subject basis and source links. The record of its creation is missing. The editor identifies the relations needed for onboarding from the task and the subject sources, follows them through the present explanation and exercises, and tests a meaningful changed case. Inspection can establish a missing return or false relation. A strong boundary test can support a high present-product value. What the author did remains a historical question.
To assess fidelity to a particular seminar, the editor compares that seminar with the handout. To establish that the author reviewed or corrected it, the editor needs evidence of the action. A successful reader response bears on the reader’s performance. A generated draft can likewise receive a current-product evaluation before an acceptance decision or any historical investigation.
NSTD.6:5.3 - Before and after evaluation repair
Before evaluation statement:
The narrative is strong because readers liked it and remembered the main point.
The judgement asserts liking and recall of the main point. It leaves open the evidence for those claims, which source relations the readers recovered, what the relations support and which uses the result permits.
After evaluation statement:
For onboarding, assume learners can reconstruct the ordinary route for using the pattern. A numerical amount still needs a defined set of relations, conditions and evidence. Source-return readiness is
3in this version. Readers can use the handout for the familiar case and know when to return to the source, but two slogans omit the references needed to locate the applicable conditions in a new case. Engagement boundedness is4because the constructed story invites comparison of workloads and preserves the conditions needed for that choice. If the task includes repair, add usable directions to those two sources first.
For an improvement under E.23, add those two references and compare whether readers can now locate the applicable conditions under the intended support. Revisit structural recovery if changed access or wording can affect it. Reuse a previous amount only with its selection, scale, conditions and evidence. A quality label of 4 provides no numerator or denominator.
NSTD.6:5.4 - Adjacent-value calibration
Fix five relations in an account of reusing a review after a change in display. The claims, the question and the qualification window must each be the same. If a required argument is unavailable, stop the new check and return to the source. This stop preserves unrelated review results. The example adapts C.37.CF. Count the condition, stop and return as one compound unit at this grain. Hold the reader, case facts, material, operations, help and budget constant. The three rows illustrate progressively larger constructed sets within this selection. For another selection, keep its own denominator and the identities of the relations.
| Correctly recovered units | Selected set size | Meaning at the fixed conditions |
|---|---|---|
3 | 5 | 3/5: the three reuse conditions are correctly recovered. |
4 | 5 | 4/5: those same conditions plus the required-argument stop and return are correctly recovered. |
5 | 5 | 5/5: those four units plus preservation of unrelated results are correctly recovered. |
The other characteristics use their own ordinal quality meanings:
| Characteristic | 3 means | 4 means | 5 means |
|---|---|---|---|
OrderingRecoverability | Order is named, but wrong reconstruction remains likely. | The intended order and relations needed for use are recoverable; consequential losses are clear. | Conflicting order layers are handled and tested. |
EventMechanismSupport | Events are coherent, but support strength is partly inferred from wording. | Relation strength and reconstruction target are explicit. | A wording or viewpoint change does not change recovered support strength. |
ViewpointAgencyDiscipline | Viewpoint is useful, but agency or responsibility repair is incomplete. | Viewpoint function and the source of a consequential attribution are recoverable. | Reader can remove or swap viewpoint without losing source structure. |
EngagementBoundedness | Interest exists, but a needed source relation or condition for informed choice is missing. | Interest supports the declared use while preserving the needed relations and conditions. | A more engaging variant improves attention without lowering source recovery, with the comparison supported under the stated conditions. |
SourceStructureSelectionFit | Selected content partly serves the purpose, but a needed relation is omitted. | Selected relations support the intended use and meaningful omissions are recoverable. | A relevant changed case confirms the selection’s stated reach and limits. |
LearningRouteReconstructionFit | Learners retell the route and recover some source relations, but miss a relation needed for reliably applying it at a change of conditions. | Learners reconstruct the essential relations and identify when to return to the source. | Learners apply the route in a new case and identify the appropriate neighbouring method or responsible party. |
NSTD.6:5.5 - Use an evaluation to improve a narrative
When repeated improvement is needed, use the narrative evaluation to identify the version, the intended change and the basis for comparing results. The following fields illustrate the input.
NarrativeRenderingImprovementLoopInput@Context:
objectVersionRef: narrative rendering version, including a candidate
evaluationResultRefs: selected `NSTD.6` rows
improvementAim: raise one declared value without lowering protected trade-offs
allowedChangedSlice: wording, source-return link, ordering marker, viewpoint repair, engagement device, generated source plan, or learning task
protectedTradeoffSet: source fidelity, grounds for consequential claims, engagement, cost and reader burden
expectedReEvaluationForm: reassess the affected NSTD.6 characteristics and any changed claim governed elsewhere
Regeneration can produce a candidate improvement when the versions, change, protected qualities and basis for reassessment remain identifiable. Another repair might add a source link and a task about the limit of an analogy. Compare the changed result under the selected evaluation in E.23. Increased engagement by itself establishes only the change in engagement, when that effect has been observed.
NSTD.6:5.6 - Evaluate a seminar handout or an architecture story
Use C.2.8 for structural amount in any narrative within its scope. NSTD.6 specifies the narrative, expression, observer and use conditions. Use C.33 when the question concerns the adequacy of an architecture description. Also assess source selection, access to the source, effort or usefulness if these affect the question.
In the seminar handout, a practitioner moves from the problem frame through forces and solution to checks. It names the source sections, explains the order, gives the learner a reconstruction task and specifies when to return to the source. Suppose the necessary relations are recoverable with the stated support. The other selected quality values may reach 4 or 5 under their own criteria. To quantify structural amount, use the structural scale.
A fluent architecture story explains that the chosen architecture felt coherent. It omits the rejected candidates, architectural characteristics and a route back to the sources. That defeats the use requiring those comparisons. Assign a structural amount only when the selection and conditions are established. High engagement can coexist with below-floor OrderingRecoverability or SourceReturnReadiness.
Reliability of a generator on unseen topics requires evidence about the generator across its stated range. A single generated narrative can still be inspected for a visible continuity error. If its source is unknown, leave fidelity and structural amount unassigned where their required basis is missing.
NSTD.6:6 - Bias-Annotation
A reader’s enjoyment, an expert’s approval, a fluency benchmark and performance on a test each establish different things. For this narrative, state the characteristics the use requires, their scales, thresholds, evidence, treatment of missing information and implications of a deficiency. Distinguish the characteristic being judged from the procedure used to evaluate it. Evidence, assurance and authority to admit, act or publish have their own criteria.
NSTD.6:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD6-1 | Evaluated object kind, declared use, and object-kind fit rule are explicit. |
CC-NSTD6-2 | When developing or qualifying a specification, demonstrate that its criteria discriminate at least three cases: adequate use, a below-floor narrative and an object of another kind. Apply a qualified specification directly when it covers the present use. |
CC-NSTD6-3 | Each characteristic has a declared qualitative comparison or a bound scale. Structural-amount values preserve their tuple, selection, conditions, granularity and evidence kind; generic quality labels do not substitute. |
CC-NSTD6-4 | Value meanings, evidence basis, missingness rules, floor, exceptional meaning, and stop or reopen condition are declared. |
CC-NSTD6-5 | Each row states the value or why it is unassigned and its evidence. For a deficiency, name the reason, any proposed repair and the conditions for reconsideration. Identify a responsible professional or decision holder when their contribution or authority matters. |
CC-NSTD6-6 | Claims about measurement, evaluation, evidence, assurance, admission, decisions, publication or pattern quality have the grounds and, where applicable, the authority their use requires. |
CC-NSTD6-7 | If repeated improvement is claimed, the E.22 or E.23 input names object version, NSTD.6 as evaluation, improvement aim, protected trade-offs, allowed change slice, cost and risk account, and expected re-evaluation form. |
CC-NSTD6-8 | An improvement claim identifies a gain over an applicable baseline under the protected conditions. Evaluate the changed version or affected part through NSTD.6 or a specified stronger evaluation on a comparable basis. |
CC-NSTD6-9 | Assess current quality from the product and its subject/use basis, fidelity from the source and resulting versions, and historical construction or repair from evidence of those actions. Address any admission claim under its own conditions. |
NSTD.6:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Fluency benchmark value as quality | Smoothness replaces structure recovery. | Inspect the selected relations and evidence. Return a missing basis or repair a demonstrated loss through NSTD.1 through NSTD.3; fluency alone establishes neither a high nor a low amount. |
| Style repair as precision repair | A nicer wording pass is treated as sufficient while relation kind, quality sense, language-state threshold, or coarsening loss remains hidden. | Lower LanguageStatePrecisionAndCoarseningFit for the unresolved defect. Clarify it directly when its meaning is determined, or use the relevant precision, coarsening, explanation or language-state pattern for the remaining question. Re-evaluate the repaired rendering before claiming improvement. |
| Prompt loop as improvement | The worker keeps regenerating more engaging drafts without a named object version, allowed change slice, protected trade-offs, or re-evaluation. | Open E.22 when needed, route the repair to E.23, and re-evaluate the changed version through NSTD.6; otherwise retain it as a candidate without claiming improvement. |
| Overextending a quality result | A wider evidence, assurance or admission claim lacks its own grounds. | Use the quality result within its established scope. Use A.10 when a source-to-use account is implicit or must be reproducible, B.3 for a specified assurance claim and the applicable admission rule for a decision. |
| Evaluating a different object | A judgement about one narrative is used to rate its generator, source archive or whole course. | Select the evaluation for that object. A script or generated draft can still be assessed as a narrative when it expresses one. |
| Reconstructed history as evidence | A plausible route inferred from a good product is reported as the author’s actual construction or repair. | Retain the current-product result and mark the historical claim unestablished until its own evidence is obtained. |
| Treating an evaluation procedure as a characteristic | A script used to obtain a value is put in the place of the property being judged. | Specify the characteristic through A.19.ECS. Identify the automated measurement or evaluation procedure, the conditions in which it operates and the result it supplies. |
NSTD.6:9 - Consequences
A reader can use the result to judge the version for the declared task. When improvement is wanted, the values, floors and observed losses identify changes that E.23 can compare. Establishing the grounds for reliance can require more time or access than a preliminary reading.
NSTD.6:10 - Rationale
Following A.19.ECS, identify the object and use, then select characteristics whose values distinguish adequate from deficient use. An improvement claim can be only as informative as the evaluation on which it depends.
NSTD.6:11 - SoTA-Echoing
FPF A.19.ECS and C.16 distinguish evaluation and measurement. C.2.8 supplies reader-relative structural amount and defines the conditions for its formal epiplexity estimate. C.33 addresses architecture-description adequacy. Effort, learning and usefulness can vary independently of amount. Use the language-state, coarsening or explanation method for the particular repair needed.
Castricato et al.’s model-theoretic account relates the information a narrator makes available to an evolving reader model. In Mengelkamp et al.’s reading-goal experiments, comprehension effects differed by condition and readers overestimated their performance. In Georgiou et al.’s narrative-memory study, recall after scrambled presentation could follow the original story order. Recall, recognition and reconstruction therefore warrant distinct questions. Use evidence of a reader’s task to assess what they recovered. The ordinal meanings above are this framework’s criteria.
Consider a reader judging a causal explanation. A fluent account can turn precedence into cause, so compare its causal relation with the source. If the question concerns what a reader understood, use their answer or an appropriate task when the available evidence warrants that work. For an expressive account, select the characteristics its purpose actually requires.
Ma et al.’s story-generation survey identifies continuing challenges in coherence, consistency, diversity, control and evaluation. Rahman et al.’s G-KMS uses structural, semantic and engine-execution checks for its RPG. Choose a check for the claim at issue. Inspect the draft for a visible continuity defect. Use appropriate evidence from a reader when the claim concerns their experience.
NSTD.6:12 - Relations
Uses A.19.ECS, A.17, A.18, C.2.8, C.16, C.16.Q, C.2.LS, A.16.1, A.16.2, A.6.3.CSC, E.17.EFP, E.10, A.6.P, C.33, E.22, E.23, B.4, A.10, B.3, E.17, C.35 and G.11. For an improvement comparison under E.23, identify the version, change, protected qualities, cost, risk and reassessment. Use B.4 for evolution under repeated use and G.11 when changed grounds affect reliance. Reconsider the affected judgement when its object, use, source, characteristics, language or precision conditions, cue, backoff, coarsening, explanation, structural basis, scale, threshold, evidence or proposed repair changes materially. The Architecture and Narrative Work Bridge relates structural recovery under C.2.8 to the separate architecture-adequacy question under C.33. The Semiotic and Language-Precision Bridge covers language, expression and precision, and the Source Use and Refresh Map covers support and currency. Consult NSTD.Reference:11 for the meanings and sources of the characteristic names.
NSTD.6:End
NSTD.7 - Automated Narrativization and Story Planning
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: planning, generating and inspecting a narrative produced with a tool, so that its content and form serve the intended use.
NSTD.7:1 - Problem frame
Use this method to generate, inspect or repair a narrative with an LLM, an NLG system, graph-to-text or data-to-text generation, story planning, a schema or search. An existing tool-produced account can itself be the object of evaluation.
Identify the material, the relations the narrative should preserve and the reader’s task. When generating a draft, supply those conditions to the tool. Compare the available draft with the material for omissions, inventions and misleading connections. A finding can answer an inspection request or inform a decision about use or repair.
Fluent or schema-valid output can introduce a cause the source never established, drop a condition or break continuity.
A focused comparison can locate such a loss and guide a correction while retaining the speed of automated drafting.
NSTD.7:2 - Problem
Automated systems can produce fluent narratives that lose a source relation or violate a story constraint. A plan helps control generation, while inspection tests the actual result. Either can reveal a need to revise the other.
NSTD.7:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Fast drafting vs source comparison | Generation is fast; finding a consequential omission or invention still requires comparison with the needed content. |
| Schema constraints and fidelity | Correct field structure establishes format compliance. Inspect the values and relations to establish fidelity. |
| Fluency and correspondence | A smooth transition can turn succession into an unsupported explanation. |
| Automation and responsibility | A consequential use may require an authorized decision. Identify who holds that authority and, when relevant, who implemented the decision. |
NSTD.7:4 - Solution
For a new account, identify the content and order the use needs, generate the draft and inspect it. A few instructions or marked source relations may suffice for the plan. For an existing narrative, start with the account and the grounds needed for the question. Inspection can give a sufficient finding, support use of the candidate or show what needs repair. Keep a note such as the one below when a collaborator, experiment or continuing workflow needs to recover the choices.
GeneratedNarrativeUseNote@Context:
sourceMaterialRef:
generatedDraftRef:
intendedReaderAndUse:
requiredRelationsOrConstraints:
generationMethodRef?:
contentPlanRef?:
discourseOrEventPlanRef?:
schemaConstraintRefs?:
sourceComparison:
evaluationRef?:
findingUseDecisionOrRepair:
consequentialUseDecisionMaker?:
architectureSynthesisAssessmentRef?:
additionalClaimGrounds?:
revisitCondition?:
Use the contribution that settles the remaining question.
| Question | Applicable content |
|---|---|
| Source selection and an evidence claim | Use NSTD.1 for ordinary source selection, or G.2 to collect and synthesize the relevant SoTA traditions. Support an evidence claim from its subject sources. Use A.10 if the source-to-use relation is implicit or must remain reproducible. |
| Generated content is to inform architecture work | C.35 evaluates the generated contribution for that use. |
| Source-to-narrative relation | A.6.3.NAR and this DPF |
| Reader recovery of selected structure | C.2.8 through NSTD.6; C.33 separately when architecture-description adequacy is the question. |
| Correspondence between structures | Compare the pertinent source and result directly. Use C.34 to evaluate an architecture-specific preservation claim. |
| Generation procedure | Establish which method was specified or used, from its description, source material or evidence of execution as the claim requires. |
| Narrative quality for a reader and use | Use NSTD.6 and its applicable A.19.ECS evaluation or C.16 measurement basis. |
| Repeated quality improvement | E.22 when the quality question is not framed, then E.23 using NSTD.6 result rows and re-evaluation |
| Evidence | Use the subject criterion and relevant sources. Use A.10 for a source-to-use relation that is implicit or must be reproducible. |
| Assurance | B.3 |
| Ethics, harm, bias, affected parties | D.1 through D.5 |
| Responsibility for a consequential use | Identify the applicable assignment or decision authority. If reporting a particular act, establish who did it and on what basis the attribution holds. |
For new generation, planning and drafting can be interleaved. Inspection may reveal that the content or order needs to change. A short task can combine planning in one prompt and comparison in one reading. Use separate stages or records when the tool, experiment or later work needs them.
| Operation | What to do | Typical failure |
|---|---|---|
| Source selection | Select the material and relations or constraints needed for the reader’s use. Keep unresolved source claims visible. | A prompt assumption is reported as an established fact. |
| Content planning | Choose what to include, omit and foreground. Revise the selection when comparison reveals a gap. | The generator silently drops a condition needed for the reader’s action. |
| Discourse or sequence planning | Use NSTD.2 to choose the order, when to disclose events and what the expression then allows a reader with the specified prior knowledge to infer. | A plausible sequence changes chronology, support for a cause, proof dependence or continuity. |
| Realization | Generate wording and viewpoint for the use. For a required voice, use NSTD.4 to choose examples or a trial treatment and compare connected passages. | Smooth prose can introduce a connection or replace the chosen voice with a different manner. |
| Inspection and evaluation | Compare the draft with its sources and constraints; use NSTD.6 for the relevant quality questions. | A defect remains invisible because only fluency or schema validity was checked. |
| Finding, use or repair | Report what inspection established. For a proposed consequential use, apply its criteria and authority. For a repair, compare the changed version with the earlier one before claiming improvement. | Regeneration alone leaves it open whether the original defect was resolved. |
For a required voice, use NSTD.4 to identify the speaker’s relation to the reader, suitable source passages or a treatment to try, the expressive choices and content to preserve, and what the speaker knows under the real or fictional conditions. Include adjoining text when the transition matters. An ordinary prompt can carry this information. Keep a separate profile when later work needs it. If the model receives only a compressed description, identify consequential features that description leaves open.
Compare a connected passage with the selected treatment through NSTD.4:4.5. A request to preserve a voice establishes the instruction. The written output can reveal a lost distinction, invented memory, inappropriate address or broken transition. For an assessment, report the finding. For a repair, revise that passage and inspect its connections with adjacent text. Retain an adequate result. Revisit the choices affected by a changed genre or source example. Use a human or automated comparison where it can supply the particular judgement required.
For schema-governed generation, check which required fields are present, then whether their values satisfy the substantive constraints. A schema may specify scenes, characters, locations, source references, branches or engine inputs. Save constraints that later maintenance needs. Use NSTD.6 for narrative quality, the subject evidence for a factual claim and C.34 for architecture-specific structural preservation.
For LLM-assisted analysis, compare the proposed themes with the excerpts, question and serious alternative readings. Use NSTD.9 when the interpretation remains unresolved. Establish who proposed, challenged and interpreted the theme when its attribution matters. In NITA, the human researcher interprets the evidence and explains the result and its limits.
For fiction or an explicitly hypothetical real scenario, distinguish choosing events from expressing them. Use NSTD.10 if events, consequences or changes in what participants know or want still need construction. Give the generator the established premises, available choices and consequential relations. Compare its proposals with these. A new discovery or motive can lead the author to retain the premises and revise the event, or deliberately change a premise. A short scene may convey its plan. Use a graph or separate plan where it helps maintain dependencies. A plan whose relevant premises or claims are suitable can supply later narrative work.
Choose a further probe when its attainable result can answer a material question about the method, narrative or intended use at a worthwhile cost. Use an adequate existing result when available.
- Source perturbation. Change a constraint that requires a difference in the answer and compare the resulting outputs. If the pertinent relation stays wrong or fails to change, examine how the generator used the source. A successful comparison establishes what happened for the tested change and conditions.
- Structure recovery. Use a reader’s response to the selected task, with access and help specified. To test what can be recovered under conditions excluding the prompt, keep the prompt out of that attempt. Retain the first response and identify what help was used. If a relation is missing, examine whether content, order, access or other conditions explain the loss.
- Responsibility. For a consequential organizational use, establish the authority to decide, correct or withdraw it. A generated note can convey an existing authorization when its issuer and terms support that use. Verify the actual grant if the wording is the only apparent basis.
NSTD.7:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.7:5.1 - Generated-narrative pipeline: graph-to-text case
An AI agent produces a fluent explanation from a concept graph. Its author compares the draft’s dependencies and examples with the graph and identifies any consequential loss. If correction is needed, the author repairs the account. The optional note below allows that comparison to be repeated.
GeneratedNarrativeUseNote@GraphToTextTeaching:
sourceMaterialRef: concept graph with dependency, example, counterexample and evidence links
requiredRelationsOrConstraints: prerequisite chain, contrast pairs, evidence-return points
generationMethodRef: LLM-assisted graph-to-text workflow
contentPlanRef: selected nodes and relations
discourseOrEventPlanRef: didactic dependency order with a contrast reveal
generatedDraftRef: prose candidate
sourceComparison: required relations compared with their sentences
evaluationRef: relevant NSTD.6 questions and findings
findingUseDecisionOrRepair: repair a missing prerequisite before using the dependent inference
revisitCondition: a source graph, generator or reader finding changes in a way that affects the relied-on result
The following steps construct and check the teaching account.
- Select the nodes, relations and returns the learner needs.
- Choose the order with
NSTD.2and generate a short draft that makes the chosen relations available. - Compare the draft with the graph. If it says “B occurs because A” but the graph supports only “A precedes B”, replace the causal claim or obtain the missing causal account.
- Use
NSTD.6to assess the resulting version for the intended reading, whether it is already in use or still a candidate. - Keep the adequate result. For repeated improvement, use
E.23with the version, changed part, protected characteristics and comparison basis.
NSTD.7:5.2 - Probe suite for generated narrative
| Probe | Question | Pass condition | Failure repair |
|---|---|---|---|
| Source perturbation | Does changing a constraint that matters to the content change the relevant relation in the output? | The sentence, order marker or source return conveys the relation required under the new condition. | Compare the selected source and plan, then locate where the output lost the change. |
| Structure recovery | Which selected relations can this reader reconstruct from the account under the stated conditions? | The reader correctly recovers the required relations and recognizes the omissions that matter to use. | Locate the loss. Clarify the content, add a usable return, address access or narrow the supported use as appropriate. |
| Responsibility | Who can decide the consequential use, and who may correct or withdraw it? | The relevant assignments or authorizations can be established. | Resolve the missing authority when that use requires it. Use evidence or assurance methods when those claims are at issue. |
| Schema use | Does the result satisfy the constraints that matter to its use? | Required fields and their semantic constraints are satisfied. | Repair the generator or result; use executable validation when it can test those constraints. |
| Improvement evidence | Is the new variant better under the relevant NSTD.6 characteristics? | Re-evaluation supports the claimed change without losing protected results. A sufficient one-off comparison can finish here. | Keep an unsupported variant as a candidate. Use E.22 if the question needs framing, or E.23 for repeated improvement. |
NSTD.7:5.3 - Before and after repair: generated seminar outline
Before:
The generated outline sounds coherent and covers all important ideas, so it can be used as a DPF learning route.
The claim of adequate coverage lacks a comparison with the source relations needed for the learner’s task.
After:
The outline selects
EntityOfConcern, forces, solution, neighbouring-pattern exits and the improvement loop, ordered by their teaching prerequisites. Compare those relations with the source. UseNSTD.8andNSTD.6for the intended reconstruction task. A worked design estimate can support a provisional lesson. To report what learners recovered, use suitable evidence of their reading with the assistance available. UseC.35if the result is intended to inform architecture work.
NSTD.7:5.4 - Generated-storycraft boundary
For a franchise continuation, compare the generated scene with the selected canon, premises and character motives. A surprising event can fit them. For a contradiction, report it, repair the event if asked, or change a premise where the project permits that choice. A source perturbation can help investigate a recurring problem with the generator. Consider the permissions relevant to private critique or publication. NSTD.6 can evaluate the candidate for either use.
NSTD.7:5.5 - Calibration for generated narrative
| Illustrative condition | Consequence for use |
|---|---|
| Fluent output contradicts a required source relation. | Identify the conflict. For the proposed use, repair it or restrict the use to what remains valid. |
| The source relations are expressed and a consequential reading remains ambiguous. | Report the ambiguity. For a claim about a particular reading, use the available response or a suitable new probe. Clarify the wording if the intended use requires it. |
| Inspection supports the intended use at acceptable cost. | Return or use the account under the established conditions. |
| A method improvement is claimed. | Compare versions under the same relevant conditions, including protected characteristics. Repeated or heterogeneous probes support only the generality they actually test. |
NSTD.7:5.6 - Inspect a generated explanation, recap, game or analysis
Content planning, realization and inspection answer different questions. Inspect which claims the generated expression conveys. Use C.2.8 for the selected structure a particular reader can correctly recover. Use subject grounds for evidence, A.10 for an implicit source-to-use account or one that must remain reproducible, and B.3 for a specified assurance claim. Use C.35 when the generated material is intended to inform architecture work. Reconsider the affected comparison when its source or the generator’s behaviour changes in a consequential way.
An LLM drafts an explanation of FPF pattern use from notes. Compare its selected relations, ordering and source returns with the notes and the applicable patterns. Use NSTD.6 to assess the draft. If the necessary subject or reader basis is missing, leave the structural amount unassigned and report any defect that inspection does establish. To establish how it was produced, use pertinent records, version history or another qualified account of the work. If those grounds are missing, report the historical limit.
A graph-to-text system produces a match recap. The event graph, timestamps, uncertainty markers and official results can establish the documented sequence and when to refresh it. If the recap attributes a goal to a cause absent from the graph, identify the gap. Report the sequence and what remains open, or obtain evidence of the cause when the question needs it.
A game system generates a branching scene. The schema specifies its objective, location, actors, traits, constraints and available actions. Check required fields for format, the scene for continuity and the intended action for reachability in the engine when it must run. To report a player’s experience, use relevant observations. Evaluate any ethical concern under the conditions it raises.
In a NITA study, an LLM proposes themes from interview notes. The human researcher considers their own standpoint, reads excerpts, tests proposed themes against alternatives and decides what the report supports at the individual-case, cross-case or dataset level in question. Their interpretation and its limits are the result used in the report.
Use these examples to distinguish evaluation from acceptance:
| Generated account | Current evaluation or use decision | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| A fluent summary with an unknown source. | Assess visible narrative defects; leave source fidelity unresolved. | The source relation cannot yet be compared. |
| A graph-to-text candidate with event IDs and a stated order. | Identify the sequence the text presents. If the source is available, compare it with the graph to establish what was preserved or lost. | The draft can be inspected before acceptance. Without adequate source evidence, leave fidelity open. |
| A schema-valid RPG scene contradicting a selected continuity constraint. | Unsuitable for that source-faithful use until repaired. | Field validity does not establish continuity. |
| An FPF seminar outline with source references and reconstruction tasks. | Evaluate its teaching route through NSTD.8 and NSTD.6. | Product quality and actual learning-effect claims use different evidence. |
| A homotopy metaphor with an unstated analogy limit. | Identify the omitted formal condition. Clarify it if the account must support proof-related use. | An intuitive reading and a mathematical proof require different grounds. |
For an improvement claim, retain the versions or spans compared, the relevant NSTD.6 results, protected qualities and material costs or risks. Keep the changed prompt or method when it bears on the comparison, a continuing workflow or a claim about how the repair was performed. A single correction can be settled by comparing the changed passage with its source. Greater fluency can coincide with less recoverable structure, a lost source return or a mistaken attribution of agency.
The source and intended use affect which plan and comparison will help.
| Source type | Content to select | Order or story plan | Mistake that changes the use | What to evaluate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Knowledge graph or event graph | Select nodes, edges, event ids, uncertainty, and omissions. | Choose traversal, grouping, and return links. | Treating graph coverage as semantic truth. | Epiplexity, ordering recoverability, relation strength. |
| Architecture source pack | Select structures, candidate trade-offs, decisions, telemetry, and residual exceptions. | Use decision-memory or trade-off route. | Treating generated explanation as architecture decision or assurance. | Structural-information capture, correspondence, source return. |
| Fictional canon or source material | Select the relevant premises, character agency, continuity constraints and conditions of use. | Choose a plot and an order of disclosure suited to the story. | Assuming permission to publish from permission for private critique. | Continuity, character agency, support for the selected events and the scope of rights. |
| Teaching source spine | Select concepts, dependencies, examples, counterexamples, tasks. | Use didactic prerequisite route with repeated anchors. | Treating generated outline as source framework. | Reconstruction tasks, learning-route quality, source-return readiness. |
| Interviews used in NITA | Select excerpts, tentative themes, alternative interpretations and the researcher’s standpoint. | Develop the report with traceable excerpts. | Attributing an LLM proposal to the researcher as an accepted interpretation. | The human researcher’s interpretation, the source relations and the ethical conditions. |
When applying a generation method to a new type of material, check whether the available source covers that use. For a graph-to-text claim, a particular method or study may supply grounds a general NLG survey leaves open. An engine may require executable or playability checks absent from text-generation research. If the question remains open, seek the missing evidence or state the scope the present sources support.
NSTD.7:6 - Bias-Annotation
Inspect the relation that matters to the reader. A visible continuity error can be established directly from the candidate and canon even when its production history is unavailable. A fluent passage may still assert an unsupported cause. Choose additional checks for the particular claim and its consequences.
NSTD.7:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD7-1 | The generated account is compared with the source relations or constraints needed for its intended use. |
CC-NSTD7-2 | Candidate evaluation can inform use, repair or rejection. C.35 is selected only for a result entering architecture work. |
CC-NSTD7-3 | Source plan, plot or event plan, schema constraints, and generation method are named when relied on. |
CC-NSTD7-4 | Fluency, coherence, controllability, schema validity and planning have criteria appropriate to those properties. Claims about evidence, authorization or admission have their own grounds. |
CC-NSTD7-5 | When a use requires responsibility or permission, establish the applicable assignment or authorization and its terms. |
CC-NSTD7-6 | An improvement claim identifies the compared versions or changed part and is supported by NSTD.6 re-evaluation, with relevant costs, risks and protected qualities considered. An already-scoped one-off comparison can be sufficient; E.22 frames an unresolved improvement question and E.23 supports repeated improvement. |
NSTD.7:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Fluency as fidelity | A necessary source relation was omitted or changed. | Compare the source and output. Report the loss or repair it for the intended use. Use NSTD.6 when quality for that use is in question. |
| Schema compliance as source fidelity | The story satisfies a schema but changes a required source relation or constraint. | Compare and repair the changed relation directly; use NSTD.6 for narrative quality. C.34 applies to architecture-specific preservation, C.2.8 to reader-relative structural amount, and C.33 to architecture-description adequacy. |
| Treating a statement of permission as a grant | Wording in a draft is used to authorize consequential action. | Establish the issuer, scope and terms of the decision the wording purports to convey. |
| Regeneration as improvement | Another fluent variant is treated as an improvement without a supported comparison. | Compare the candidate and previous version through NSTD.6, keeping needed relations and costs in view. Use E.22 for an unresolved comparison question and E.23 when repeated improvement is wanted. |
NSTD.7:9 - Consequences
Automated drafting can save time while retaining a manageable comparison with the source. The work needed to inspect or repair an account depends on which loss would matter to its use. A small adequate account can be returned directly.
NSTD.7:10 - Rationale
A plan specifies intended content and order. Comparing the resulting narrative with that plan establishes where they agree or differ. To explain the plan’s contribution to generation, examine evidence of how the tool or author used it. Inspection can settle its own question or inform acceptance or further drafting.
NSTD.7:11 - SoTA-Echoing
NSTD.7:11.1 - Operational comparison against domain vocabulary
Narratology distinguishes story, discourse and presentation. Generation methods distinguish content selection, ordering and realization. Use these distinctions to locate an omission, misleading sequence, unsupported relation or consequential wording choice. A tool can combine the operations internally. Inspect the resulting account and use evidence of execution when the question concerns how the tool produced it.
Keep a domain term when it helps identify or repair the operation. If an ambiguity affects the claim or use, resolve it directly or use the FPF method for the remaining question.
Gatt and Krahmer’s NLG survey (2018) distinguishes planning from realization. Alabdulkarim, Li and Peng’s story-generation survey (2021) examines control, commonsense, characters and evaluation. Cardona Rivera, Jhala, Porteous and Young’s narrative-planning review (2024) covers plan-based methods. Kumaran, Rowe, Mott and Lester’s SceneCraft (2023) generates interactive scenes from instructions. Rahman, Yu and Cho’s G-KMS (2026) tests structured generation, repair and execution in a compact Unity RPG. Ma et al.’s survey (2026) identifies problems in coherence, character consistency, diversity, plot control and evaluation. Nguyen-Trung and Nguyen’s NITA (2026) gives the human researcher responsibility for interpretive judgement in its qualitative-analysis method.
Use these contributions for the question they address.
- Distinguish content planning, discourse planning and realization. For final prose, inspect its source relations and order. Recover the plan when it helps explain, repair or reproduce the result. To report what happened during generation, seek evidence of that work.
- Select the characteristics the proposed use needs, such as coherence, controllability or diversity, and examine the output under those criteria.
- Use a plot or event plan to guide generation. Compare the resulting story with its goals and constraints to see how far the plan was realized.
- For a scene that must execute, check parsing, state reachability and the semantic constraints that matter in the engine.
- For technical playability, use a suitable execution test, exhaustive check of the applicable state model or existing play evidence to establish the reachable actions in question. For how a player experienced the scene, use evidence of the player’s response.
- In NITA, the human qualitative researcher interprets the tool’s tentative themes in relation to excerpts, the question and alternatives. Preserve that contribution when using NITA.
Use the comparison to decide whether the particular narrative serves the requested purpose. Keep unresolved claims within their evidenced limits.
NSTD.7:12 - Relations
Uses G.2, C.35, A.6.3.NAR, C.2.8, C.33, C.34, NSTD.6, A.19.ECS, C.16, E.22, E.23, A.10, B.3, D.1 through D.5 and G.11. C.2.8 gives the common structural amount, C.33 architecture-description adequacy, C.34 architecture-specific preservation and C.35 the use of generated material in architecture work. Use G.2 to synthesize SoTA across traditions. For an improvement comparison under E.22 or E.23, identify the versions, change and relevant NSTD.6 results. Reconsider a finding when changed material, generator, method, schema, use, evidence or research affects what it supports. See the Source Use And Refresh Map for generation and source claims, NSTD.Reference:11 for the meaning of plan, constraint, admission, correspondence and responsibility, and the Semiotic And Language-Precision Bridge for a change of language state, coarsening, cue or evaluative wording.
NSTD.7:End
NSTD.8 - Design a Narrative Learning Route for Reconstruction and Use
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: a narrative learning route and the source relations learners need to reconstruct and use.
NSTD.8:1 - Problem frame
Use this method to design or assess a narrative learning route for a complex subject. Start from what learners will need to reconstruct or do. A source publication may already serve a lookup or professional decision directly.
Begin at one consequential transition. What question is open, what material has the learner encountered and what will the next task require? Inspect the support available there. A missing prerequisite can be visible in the material. To find out how someone used it, examine a suitable earlier attempt or arrange one if the question warrants it.
Choose the learning order from the learner’s next action and intended later use. The source organization can support lookup, a first explanation, or a comparison of what several cases share. When later work requires choosing among similar cases, a route that names the topic for every task can leave that choice unpractised. Keep the source organization available and select the comparisons, mixed tasks, or later returns that the learning purpose requires.
A learner may remember the examples and lose the relations needed to use them. In a technical lesson these can include the architecture, the conditions of a proof, when to select a method, where to verify a claim or how to improve a result.
A usable route makes the material available where a learner needs it to explain a relation or perform the next task.
NSTD.8:2 - Problem
A learning narrative uses sequence, examples, repetition, analogy and motivation to help the learner reconstruct and use source ideas. Those choices can also conceal a prerequisite or make an illustrative route appear to be the only way to perform a method.
A topic heading can tell learners which method to use. Success inside that block leaves open whether they could choose among methods without the heading. Select cases that reveal the relevant similarities or differences, and supply enough material for learners to work with them. Arrange the order of exercises and the reasoning within each exercise for the actions they support.
NSTD.8:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Learning order and source order | A sequence for teaching can differ from a publication’s organization, a proof’s dependencies or the architecture being explained. |
| Reference and learning use | Keep source modules accessible for lookup. Use their grouping for teaching when it supports the learner’s next action. |
| Shared basis vs distinguishing cases | A block can make a common relation visible across instances; a close comparison or mixed task can expose differences between similar alternatives. The learner’s missing operation determines which arrangement is useful. |
| Coverage and later retrieval | Encountering every topic once leaves open what learners can retrieve at the time of later use. |
| Engagement and reconstruction | A learner may enjoy an analogy and still miss the relation it illustrates. Ask what they can reconstruct when that is the learning goal. |
| Local teaching and authority | A lesson trial can show what particular learners did. Authority for a subject claim comes from its relevant source or practice. |
NSTD.8:4 - Solution
Design the transition the learner needs and connect it to its next use. If learners must interpret unfamiliar material, teach them how to develop and compare interpretations through NSTD.9. To assess their independent choice, give them a question that leaves the choice to them. For creating a story, use NSTD.10 and let learners work through a changed premise. A narrative lesson on a proof or technical method takes its operations and criteria from that subject.
A course team may want a note connecting several lessons, comparing versions or keeping their source relations traceable. Use the fields its work needs.
LearningNarrativeRoute@Context:
learnerUse:
sourceRelationsNeeded:
unfoldingStructureRefs?:
demonstrativeSliceRefs?:
sourceArchitectureRef?:
organizationOfLearningEpisodes:
reasoningAndOrderWithinEpisodes:
interleavingPlanRefs?:
spacingOrRetrievalScheduleRefs?:
recurringExamplesOrPrompts?:
whereToReturnToTheSource:
learnerReconstructionTaskRefs:
applicationTaskRefs?:
intendedUseOfInterestOrMotivation?:
routeEvaluationIfNeeded?:
improvementLoopInputRef?:
learningPublicationCarrierRefs:
choicesSuppliedByTopicLabels?:
limitsOnWhatTheResultsShow:
refreshCondition:
A maintained course may have separate lessons, slides, exercises and recordings. Link them to the source ideas and learner tasks they serve. The size and publication form depend on the teaching work.
When teaching a constraint-governed unfolding structure, make the wider possibilities recoverable alongside the demonstrated path. Teach an omitted alternative or stop condition at the point where it changes the learner’s action. A route note can link the wider structure and the taught slice when that helps maintenance.
These questions can guide planning or the examination of an existing route. Return to the affected question when an attempt supplies new information.
| Design question | Useful result | Failure it addresses |
|---|---|---|
| Which source ideas will the learner need? | The relations and operations needed for later reconstruction or application. | A memorable example with no usable connection to the subject. |
| Does the source organization suit learning here? | A reasoned choice of learning order, with the source organization still accessible. | Copying a reference topic map without considering the learning task. |
| What must be available before the next task? | A sequence or usable return that supplies the prerequisite at that point. | Requiring an operation before its necessary relation is available. |
| Which comparison or choice does the learner need? | Select cases with enough material to see the shared relation or distinguishing condition. HCD.10:4.5 helps choose an order for human practice when that choice matters. | The relevant difference is unavailable, or the heading makes the choice for the learner. |
| Must learners retrieve the idea after a delay? | Compare an earlier demonstration with work after the relevant interval, under the help permitted then. Account for intervening practice that matters to a claim of retention. | Immediate recognition alone leaves later retrieval open. |
| How does an aid connect to the current question and next use? | A meaningful term, diagram, question or case with its relation recoverable. | Remembering the aid but not what to do with it. |
| What must the learner recover or perform? | A task whose response can show the relevant distinction or operation. | A report of satisfaction alone leaves capability open. |
| What result would change the route? | Use an applicable NSTD.6 assessment to retain a sufficient version or choose a worthwhile repair. | A change is credited with improvement before its effect on the relevant quality is established. |
Start from the intended task and the preparation learners can use. When people must notice a common relation or distinguish similar alternatives, HCD.10:4.5 helps choose whether to retain a block, place cases side by side or mix further cases for practice in choosing. Make the deciding relations accessible in the narrative. When the basic operation itself needs explanation or supported practice, use the subject method and §4.1.
Arrange an episode around one action or connected attempt. A two-sentence comparison can expose the difference between two alternatives. Applying a method to a system may need several pages and cases. Keep the information needed for the action accessible together.
Order the episodes and the reasoning within them. A reader should be able to recover the question the next claim addresses, the premise it needs or how the next case changes the account. Alternate within an episode when the comparison calls for it. A mixed sequence of tasks can contain a sustained explanation for each.
An author can open a question, develop it through intervening cases and return to it later. Let the learner find the earlier question again. Make its needed relation accessible before a task requires it. Section 4.1 helps distinguish a preparatory attempt from a missing connection or support.
When people need later access to what they learned, use HCD.10:4.4 to choose a suitable interval. Decide separately what they must retrieve and what support they may use. Keep the cases of a needed comparison jointly accessible during that task, even when practice resumes after a delay. To judge actual use, examine the learner’s response under those conditions (§4.1 and NSTD.6).
NSTD.8:4.1 - Check attachment and support at the next use
Connect the teaching material to the question at hand and to the use that follows. What can a learner do with this example, diagram or exercise, and where will that matter? A question, caption, worked example, short transition or later return may supply the connection. Check the endpoints of a repeated term or a diagram arrow when its meaning is unclear.
Examine what is available by the time of the next task. Identify what this audience can already use, what the route has introduced, which questions remain open and which prerequisites the task needs now. An overview or a link can supply a missing relation if it makes that relation usable at this point. Inspect the material for a design judgement. Use a learner’s attempt when the question concerns what that learner actually did.
Choose the continuation that fits the transition.
- The connection is missing. Show how the block or aid bears on the current question and the next use. Correct a misleading diagram edge or a link to the wrong passage.
- The task needs support that is absent. Check the expected prerequisite and permitted help. Supply the relevant contrast, map, worked operation, recap or accessible representation, or introduce it earlier. Preserve the subject relation the learner must use.
- The initial attempt prepares subsequent instruction. A bounded problem can bring out alternatives before the explanation. Keep those attempts available and use the subsequent teaching to compare and resolve them. A later response can establish what the learner then did. To determine how the preparation contributed, use evidence that distinguishes its contribution, such as an applicable comparison.
A supported initial case can help a learner form the distinction. When later work requires independent selection, include a case whose cue leaves that choice open. Select grouping, interleaving, spacing and retrieval for the particular action and time of later use.
To assess first recognition, preserve the response before supplying the deciding cue. State which help was permitted, what the learner used, what the source supplied and what prior expertise matters to the claim. A teacher-supported correction can satisfy a task that allows that help. An expert’s successful reconstruction and a novice’s difficulty may both be accurately reported. If the novice’s difficulty matters to a repair, use evidence that addresses it.
In NSTD.6, NarrativeRenderingEpiplexity applies C.2.8’s ExtractableStructuralInformation to a narrative account, its expression and an observer. Ask which selected relations this observer could correctly recover under the stated conditions. Once those relations support the task, adding others can increase effort without improving use. A walkthrough can locate a missing relation or available help. For a claim about experienced human effort, identify the person, segment, timing and means of measurement. Learning, retention and transfer have their own evidence.
After a change, recheck the affected connection and what the learner needs at the next task. Retain material that already works with the intended support. For a proposed improvement, E.23 compares the useful result, the costs and the qualities to protect. A shorter explanation or an extra diagram earns its place through what it changes for this use.
Select a task that can reveal the outcome in question.
| Task depth | Example task | What it tests |
|---|---|---|
| Recognition | “Which method addresses this difficulty, and what tells you so?” | Which conditions of use the learner recognized, given the cues available. |
| Reconstruction | “Rebuild the route from the source, forces and solution to the point where you would use another method.” | Which source relations the learner reconstructed. |
| Transfer | “Apply the same reasoning to a different domain case.” | What the learner can apply under the changed conditions. A claim about transfer from earlier learning also needs its earlier basis. |
| Boundary | “When would you use another method, and which one?” | Whether the learner can select a useful alternative. |
| Repair | “Given this NSTD.6 assessment, choose the smallest change that would remedy the loss.” | Whether the learner can use the assessment to select a sufficient repair. |
Keep a story, rhythm, example or analogy when it serves the learning task. If a learner remembers it and misses the relation, check how the device, prior knowledge and available support bear on that difficulty before changing the material.
A short attempt or an earlier account of a learner’s difficulty may answer a local question. For a comparison across runs, preserve the versions, learners, task, assistance and result needed to interpret it. Seek further observations when they could change a conclusion enough to justify obtaining them. To claim that the route evolved through repeated operation, use B.4.
For improvement across runs, use a suitable NSTD.6 assessment of the affected version. E.22 helps define the intended benefit, minimum acceptable result, qualities to protect or evidence needed when any remains unclear. Use E.23 to select and compare a worthwhile change to the content, order, tasks, material, engagement or evaluation. Use G.11 when changed sources, learner observations, teaching results, generated practice or a new FPF edition could alter the route’s basis. B.4 addresses a claim that the route evolved as a whole through repeated operation.
NSTD.8:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.8:5.1 - Worked learning route: FPF onboarding
A seminar, tutorial or exercise sequence could use the design below. Each teaching move prepares an identifiable learner action.
LearningNarrativeRoute@FPFOnboarding:
learnerUse: select and apply one FPF pattern under the conditions of a new case
sourceArchitectureRef: the pattern language, its organization of source patterns, and the collected FPF publication
sourceSpineRefs:
- `EntityOfConcern`
- problem frame
- forces
- solution as condition-bound move
- conformance and checking
- neighboring exits
- quality and improvement loop
unfoldingStructureRefs: A.22.CGUS when the route teaches unfolding from source to next use
demonstrativeSliceRefs: first pattern-use route through one selected project case
learningRouteArchitectureRule: revisit one pattern through several cases, keeping its source organization available
learningStepOrder:
- failed ordinary use
- recover object of concern
- read forces
- choose solution move
- check the limit of this use and select a neighbouring method when needed
- use the assessment to repair one inadequate result
interleavingPlanRefs:
- return to `EntityOfConcern` after forces, solution, and quality checks
- mix cases requiring a choice among the newly introduced and earlier methods
- revisit source-return boundary in examples from at least two domains
spacingOrRetrievalScheduleRefs:
- short delayed retrieval at the start of the next session
- choose among neighbouring methods after intervening material
- final transfer task with no block label
reconstructionTasks:
- name the source pattern section behind each story beat
- choose the governing pattern for a new case
- state one source-return condition
useOfEngagement: the failed-use story introduces the problem. A claim about an actual failure needs its own basis.
evaluationRouteRef: `NSTD.6` learning-route rows
improvementLoopInputRef: `E.23` when a comparison identifies a worthwhile improvement
Here an initially unsuccessful attempt can prepare the discussion. Use the attempted alternatives to show which object the next move concerns and why the other choice would leave this question open. Before asking learners to choose between neighbouring methods, check whether they can access the methods and their distinguishing condition. If a contrast is missing, supply it or make the relevant source accessible. Once it is available, a mixed case can leave the choice to the learner.
For example, NSTD.2 changes presentation order while preserving the needed relations. NSTD.3 examines a connection asserted by an account. Give learners the Readme incident log and the sentence “the change caused the failure.” Ask whether placing the two events in chronological order would settle the sentence, and what the repair would need to establish.
Suppose a learner answers, “Put the change before the failure, so the cause is clear.” The answer gets the dates in order and infers cause from their order. If the necessary distinction was unavailable, explain it and work through the two claims. If the attempt was part of the preparation, use the answer in the ensuing instruction. If both methods were already accessible, return to what the log establishes. A later mixed case can test whether the learner recognizes a new connection claim without a supplied choice.
Connect a later diagram or recap to the next task. A wrong figure link can often be corrected locally. Inspect the new link to establish where it leads. To assess what learners can now recover, use evidence of their work with the revised material and the intended help. The answer above is part of the design example.
For a seminar, add timing, facilitation notes and complete exercises suited to the participants and the intended next use.
NSTD.8:5.2 - Worked learning route: repair topic-blocked practice
An engineering team wants a course in narrative methods for engineering explanations. Participants will select and use these methods when explaining designs, incidents and project decisions. Their first outline groups practice by topic:
Lesson 1: all source-structure intake.
Lesson 2: all ordering rules.
Lesson 3: all viewpoint and agency.
Lesson 4: all engagement.
Lesson 5: all evaluation.
The headings identify the kind of problem in each block. This can support first practice. In an unfamiliar incident the learner may have to choose whether to check the source, reorder the account, change viewpoint, revise an expressive device, examine how it was generated or test a claimed connection. The blocked exercises alone leave that selection open.
The team could retain the topic map and teach the choice through the following sequence.
LearningNarrativeRoute@NarrativeMethodsForEngineering:
learnerUse: engineer selects and applies narrative methods to explain different project situations
sourceArchitectureRef: NSTD topic map and source pattern bodies
sourceSpineRefs:
- selected source structure
- ordering rule
- viewpoint and agency split
- engagement boundary
- narrative rendering quality row
- where to verify a claim and which practice can answer an open question
learningRouteArchitectureRule: spaced interleaving around recurring project cases
learningStepOrder:
- one motivating project failure
- source-selection repair
- different project failure requiring ordering repair
- return to first failure and add viewpoint risk
- choose the relevant method in a mixed exercise
- delayed retrieval of source-return boundaries
- final transfer to an unseen case
interleavingPlanRefs:
- once an earlier method is familiar, mix it with a current method when learners need to distinguish them
- adjacent failure modes are compared side by side
- examples rotate across FPF seminar, architecture explanation, homotopy explanation, generated carrier, and live commentary
spacingOrRetrievalScheduleRefs:
- after the first session, open a later session with an unlabelled retrieval task on an earlier case
- recall the object of concern, needed source and appropriate method at increasing delays
- repair an earlier inadequate result after new material intervenes
limitOfPractice: a topic-labelled exercise supplies the method name. Independent selection needs a task that leaves it open.
evaluationRouteRef: `NSTD.6` rows for transfer, source return, and learner reconstruction
The NSTD topic map remains available for lookup. Returning to the methods under different cues lets an engineer practise distinguishing source, order and viewpoint problems. To teach engineering design itself, use the relevant engineering operations and a task that calls for them.
NSTD.8:5.3 - Worked learning route: homotopy explanation
LearningNarrativeRoute@HomotopyIntro:
learnerUse: learner distinguishes intuitive deformation picture from formal definition and proof boundary
sourceSpineRefs:
- topological space
- path
- homotopy relation under constraints
- invariant
- example and counterexample
- proof-status return
learningStepOrder:
- image cue
- show which space the deformation must stay inside
- return to the formal definition of a continuous deformation
- example
- counterexample
- reconstruction task
reconstructionTasks:
- identify the space in which every stage of the deformation must stay and a move that this excludes
- explain why the drawing alone cannot establish that the loop contracts in that space
- justify one claim using the formal definition and a relevant invariant
useOfEngagement: the picture introduces the question. The definition fixes the allowed deformations.
evaluationRouteRef: `NSTD.6` rows for ordering, language-state precision, and source return
For example, draw a loop winding once around a missing point in the plane. Ask whether a continuous deformation inside that space can shrink the loop to a point. Its winding around the missing point prevents this. Fill the point back in and the loop can contract in the full plane. A learner who remembers the drawing can be asked which change in the allowed space changes the answer and why. The formal result supplies the criterion for judging their explanation.
NSTD.8:5.4 - Worked learning route: using this pattern language
One short course uses an FPF seminar, a franchise continuation and a homotopy explanation, then turns to live commentary for a new application. The table shows the instructor which methods each case could teach.
| Step | Case | Methods for the instructor | Question for the learner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | FPF seminar | NSTD.1, NSTD.8 | Which relations from the source will participants need after the seminar? |
| 2 | Franchise continuation | NSTD.1, NSTD.2, NSTD.3, NSTD.7 | What does the existing canon establish, and what can the author propose or invent for the new events? |
| 3 | Homotopy explanation | NSTD.2, NSTD.5, NSTD.6 | Which step needs a definition or proof beyond what the analogy supplies? |
| 4 | Live commentary | NSTD.3, NSTD.6, G.11 | Which claims are supported now, and which would change with a later observation or official correction? |
When learners see the method names, their explanations can show how they use those methods. To assess independent selection and repair in a new situation, give the new case without its method names or an equivalent cue. Ask them to choose, explain the relevant condition and make the repair. Record what help the task allowed and what they used.
NSTD.8:5.6 - Evaluating the learning route
Select the task for the intended outcome. Immediate reconstruction, delayed retrieval, discrimination between cases and application to a new case call for different observations. A present response may complete an account of what a learner reconstructed. For durable independent use, compare an earlier demonstration with appropriately delayed work under the permitted support, accounting for relevant intervening practice. Vary the case when the claim includes use under that change.
Use NSTD.6 to distinguish a judgement about the design from the work of a particular learner. For a reading result, identify the task, observer, material, conditions and help relevant to the claim. Account for prior preparation when it affects the inference.
NSTD.8:5.7 - Connecting route design to publication and improvement
For framework entry use E.11, for the publication form E.17, and for a separately usable audience unit E.17.AUD. NSTD.5 helps choose an expressive device when interest matters. NSTD.6 evaluates the route for its intended use. E.22 and E.23 support a proposed improvement, and G.11 a review after a relevant change. Keep the design detail a one-off explanation or maintained course needs.
An FPF seminar or tutorial can connect the object of concern, precise relations, pattern bodies, DPF authoring, architectural synthesis, evaluation, improvement and return to sources. The teaching order serves the learner. For reconstruction, ask participants to recover one pattern-use route and its basis. Use the framework itself to establish its architecture.
In the homotopy mini-course, ask learners to identify the permitted space and explain the two outcomes in §5.3. A drawing can introduce the problem, and the mathematical comparison can expose a missing condition. Use the learner’s own explanation to judge what they reconstructed under the support given.
An onboarding sequence could also use an FPF seminar, franchise storycraft and live commentary. Ask learners which source relations NSTD.1 helps recover in each case, which further method each problem needs, and why NSTD.6 evaluates a particular rendering and use. When the goal is transfer, add a sufficiently changed case and compare performance under the relevant conditions.
NSTD.7 helps examine generated teaching material against the source and the intended task. Use NSTD.6 for an assessment that admission or another use needs. C.35 addresses use of the generated material in architectural work.
Distinguish versions when comparing repeated teaching or maintaining materials. The following optional note is useful when the comparison needs these details.
LearningNarrativeRouteVersion@Context:
routeRef:
sourceSpineVersionRef:
learnerRoleRef:
learningStepOrderingRule:
carrierRefs:
reconstructionTaskRefs:
evaluationResultRef:
observedConfusionOrTelemetryRefs?:
changedSliceSincePreviousVersion?:
refreshCondition:
For a comparison, identify which materials and order learners encountered and what differed. Compare the affected outcome with a suitable baseline, including any qualities to preserve, before claiming a gain. If no one tracked a slide change, other evidence may establish which version was used. Review the teaching that depends on a materially changed source.
The following example plan connects subject content, the immediate teaching move and a later use. Adapt its timing and returns to the learner’s task.
| Source relation or operation | Immediate teaching move | Later practice when needed |
|---|---|---|
| Pattern entry condition | Practitioner incident, contrasting case or failed-use example. | Return after two other cases and ask which method fits, without naming it. |
| Forces | Tension sequence, stakeholder conflict, or trade-off map. | Compare with a different pattern’s forces in a mixed exercise. |
| Solution move | Demonstration, guided reconstruction or worked example. | Reuse the project case with a problem requiring another kind of repair. |
| Boundary and non-use | A counterexample or a case where another method is needed. | In a later session, ask learners to recall when to stop using this method. |
| Relations | Ask which neighbouring method supplies the outstanding contribution. | Mix cases requiring different choices. |
| Quality and improvement | Diagnose an inadequate result and select a repair. | Revisit it after intervening work and ask learners to revise the affected part. |
The last column gives possible later work when the goal includes delayed retrieval or method selection. A response can establish what a learner did at that time and with that support. For a learning claim, establish a change from earlier capability. To credit the route, also establish how it contributed to that change.
Different courses can use the same design questions.
| Course | Source material | Possible narrative devices | What to examine |
|---|---|---|---|
| FPF onboarding | Pattern entry, object of concern, forces, solution, relations, checks and improvement. | Practitioner problem, contrasting uses, recurring source question. | How the learner chose an applicable method and reconstructed a pattern-use route. |
| Mathematical explanation route | Definitions, examples, theorem prerequisites, proof-status boundaries. | Analogy, diagram story, dependency sequence, counterexample. | Learner marks where analogy stops and returns to formal statement. |
| Architecture explanation route | Candidate structures, characteristics, decisions, trade-offs, telemetry. | Trade-off story, viewpoint over stakeholder role, decision-memory path. | Learner separates architecture description, decision, realized structure, and telemetry. |
| Generated teaching material | The source relations and the intended learner operation. | Generated examples or slides examined through NSTD.7. For architectural work, C.35 also applies. | Compare the material with its sources for fidelity. A learner’s response can show performance on the task. To claim learning, establish a change in capability. To credit this material, establish its contribution to that change. |
| Live debrief route | Event record, provisional interpretation, official correction, source return. | Recap story, tension order, role viewpoint. | Learner distinguishes observation, inference, prediction, and official update. |
A short teaching note can give one needed source relation, an order for explaining it, a reconstruction question and a way back to the source. For a maintained course, identify versions and retain the learner results that a promised comparison needs. Revise the parts for which a change is warranted.
Attendance, applause and satisfaction can tell an organizer about participation or reaction. To establish what learners reconstructed, examine which relation they can explain or apply, which boundary they recognize or how they choose a repair.
NSTD.8:6 - Bias-Annotation
Learners may take a sequence of lessons or an analogy as the structure of the subject. Give them access to the source relations and show why the lesson uses this particular order.
Modular source publications support reference. Reusing the modules as lessons can leave learners with little practice choosing across them. When they need to distinguish cases, include a comparison. When they need to retrieve a relation later, plan its return and the support permitted then.
NSTD.8:7 - Conformance Checklist
| Check | Passing condition |
|---|---|
CC-NSTD8-1 | The design names the intended learner action and the source relations it requires. |
CC-NSTD8-2 | The order serves the learner’s task, and the learner can reach the sources needed for it. |
CC-NSTD8-3 | The reconstruction task lets a learner demonstrate the needed source relation. |
CC-NSTD8-4 | Lessons, exercises and other learning materials make their needed source relations and tasks available at the point of use. |
CC-NSTD8-5 | The comparison supports a claimed improvement on the affected outcome, at acceptable cost and with protected qualities preserved. Use NSTD.6 for the assessment and E.22 or E.23 for the improvement work the case requires. |
CC-NSTD8-6 | Distinguish source organization, episode order and reasoning within episodes. The intended learner action determines what to compare, what should remain accessible together and what help is appropriate. For a spaced return, choose separately when it occurs and what learners must retrieve. |
CC-NSTD8-7 | At a consequential transition, learners can relate available material to the question and next use. Address a missing connection or prerequisite where it is needed. Follow a deliberate preparatory attempt with instruction that uses the attempted alternatives. |
CC-NSTD8-8 | Interpret first and assisted responses under the actual preparation and help. Ground claims about the source, learning and experienced effort in evidence of each. |
NSTD.8:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | What fails | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Lesson order mistaken for the subject’s structure | The explanation presents one sequence or analogy as the architecture or order of proof. | Explain the teaching choice and give a usable return to the subject relation. |
| Reference order chosen without examining the learning task | The topic map is copied into lessons without checking what the learner must subsequently recognize, select or use. | Keep a source-aligned introduction when it supplies the needed support. Add contrasts, mixed selection or delayed retrieval when the intended outcome calls for them. |
| Fluent performance in labelled topic blocks | The label supplies the method choice that later work requires learners to make. | Examine an unlabelled or mixed case for selection. Use a suitable change to assess transfer and a suitable delay to assess retention. |
| Remembered examples mistaken for reconstructed relations | The learner can repeat the anecdote, while their command of the relation remains open. | Examine their work on a reconstruction or application task. Use NSTD.6 when an evaluation is needed. |
| Fluent paragraphs with a missing connection | The example reads smoothly, but the learner cannot relate it to the active question or later use. | Inspect the two passages and what is available at that point. If repair is wanted, restore the relation or the return to it. To judge the revised task in use, examine a suitable attempt. |
| Difficulty judged without its instructional purpose | A difficult transition is removed, or an unsuccessful attempt is credited with teaching the relation. | Supply a missing prerequisite. For a preparatory attempt, use its alternatives in the following instruction and check any claimed learning outcome. |
| A local revision described as evolution | One change to a slide is offered as evidence about the course across repeated operation. | Use NSTD.6 to assess a version, E.23 to compare a proposed improvement and G.11 for an affected change of basis. Use B.4 for a claim of evolution through repeated operation. |
NSTD.8:9 - Consequences
The designer obtains a route connecting source material, available support and intended learner actions. It takes work to build those connections. Evidence of actual responses, retention and transfer costs time when a claim about them is needed.
NSTD.8:10 - Rationale
Explanation, examples, attempts, feedback and later returns serve different learning aims. Keeping the source structure accessible lets the teacher vary their order while learners can still recover the subject on its own grounds.
A modular source corpus can support lookup and a first introduction while still leaving later selection unpractised. When learners must choose among similar methods without a topic label, the learning route needs those contrasts and selection tasks. When later retrieval matters, it needs an appropriate delay and return. The source organization remains available; whether the learning order should follow it depends on the task and the support already available.
NSTD.8:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Mengelkamp and colleagues compared factual and inferential responses under different reading goals. Results for those goals varied across their two experiments, and readers’ estimates could exceed their performance. Georgiou and colleagues found that scrambling narrative clauses affected free recall much more than recognition. Hoffmann illustrates how scientific storytelling can sustain a tension and return to its source. Earlier work on practice supplies distinct grounds. Dunlosky and colleagues rated practice testing and distributed practice highly and discussed interleaving for suitable tasks. Rohrer and Taylor found advantages of spaced or mixed practice on later tests of the mathematics problems they studied. Kang reviewed how repeated encounters can be spaced and combined with testing.
Noetel et al. (2022) reviewed multimedia design, including signalling, correspondence and pacing. Select the feature that addresses the learner’s difficulty. Sinha and Kapur (2021) compared instruction before and after problem solving, with substantial evidence from mathematics and physics. A preparatory task needs subsequent instruction that uses the attempted solutions. Wesenberg et al. (2025) showed in short units that a worked solution can also fit a misleading rule. Check whether an example distinguishes the intended rule. In Krieglstein et al. (2025), the complexity of the first unit influenced the overall effort reported after a sequence of three. Identify the person, segment, timing and instrument when interpreting such a rating.
Apply these findings to the particular teaching aim.
- State the learner’s purpose before choosing the tasks. Curiosity, an examination, professional use and framework authoring can call for different responses.
- Compare a learner’s judgement of understanding with their reconstruction or application when the accuracy of that judgement matters.
- Give learners a way back to a needed source relation across a long narrative. Use a recurring prompt when it helps them recover that relation.
- For later retrieval, consider distributing practice and examine performance after the relevant delay, under the stated support.
- Where a topic label normally supplies the choice, compare similar cases or mix problem types to give learners practice selecting the appropriate method.
- Keep the source organization accessible for lookup. Retain its order when that supports a first introduction. Use a different order when later work requires a contrast, mixed selection or a delayed return.
- Preserve an open scientific question when current evidence leaves it open. The tension can itself be part of the teaching.
- Compare the relevant course versions and outcomes when claiming an improvement. A worthwhile change can improve an already adequate result.
Retain a source-aligned segment that already serves its purpose. A missing connection, an unsupported demand or an unpractised choice gives the designer a specific change to consider.
NSTD.8:12 - Relations
For a human learning route, HCD.10:4.5 helps select grouping or mixing when the comparison and order matter. Keep the material learners need for that comparison accessible at the point of use. HCD.10:4.4 helps select a spaced return, the retrieval to practise and the help permitted there.
For the narrative and its source use A.6.3.NAR, E.6, NSTD.1 and NSTD.2. E.11, E.17 and E.17.AUD support entry and publication. NSTD.5 helps choose a device for interest or motivation. NSTD.6 assesses a particular narrative version for its intended use. Use E.21 when the object to evaluate is an edition of an FPF pattern. E.22 frames an open quality question, and E.23 compares proposed improvements. Use G.11 when a change in sources, learner preparation, task, practice, scheduling, edition or observations alters the basis for use. Use B.4 for evolution through repeated operation. NSTD.Reference:9 addresses source architecture, views and evidence about the realized structure. NSTD.Reference:10 addresses wording, cues, explanation and loss of precision. NSTD.Sources:1 helps trace changed teaching, memory or practice evidence to the parts of the course that depended on it. Use NSTD.Reference:14 when changed observations of learner work could affect the route’s supported use.
NSTD.8:End
NSTD.9 - Construct and Compare Narrative Interpretations
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: the interpretation of connected material for understanding or producing a narrative.
NSTD.9:1 - Problem frame
Use this method when observations, recollections, documents, images or a narrative are available and their significant connections remain in question. You may need to identify what constitutes an episode, how the participants’ perspectives bear on it, what an interpretation assumes, or why several readings remain possible.
Choose a consequential detail, say what you take it to show and identify the grounds for that reading. If a plausible alternative changes what a reader could conclude, compare the two. Revise the grouping, the proposed connection or the confidence it deserves where the evidence calls for it.
Return the supported account, any warranted alternatives or the precise question the material leaves open. A short paragraph can suffice. Use a source whose meaning is already clear directly. NSTD.1 selects material for a reader, NSTD.3 addresses a known connection and NSTD.10 constructs fictional or explicitly hypothetical events. Use an available observation, proof or causal finding when it answers the question. Seek the corresponding subject inquiry when a needed result remains missing.
NSTD.9:2 - Problem
To tell what happened, an interpreter groups occurrences, connects statements, selects a perspective and may supply assumptions. The resulting account can bring out a relation or obscure it. Compare the grouping with the original material. An outline extracted from the completed story already contains its author’s choices.
NSTD.9:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| A connected account and a resistant detail | A proposed whole can make a passage intelligible. A detail it cannot explain may call for different units or a different interpretation. |
| Interpretation and evidence | A connection may be inferred from what someone said or observed. State the inference and the material that supports it when the difference matters. |
| Shared event and different experiences | Two participants can experience one occurrence differently. If they disagree about a fact, examine the evidence for that fact. |
| Resolution and openness | A task may need one interpretation, several supported meanings or a precise account of what remains unknown. |
NSTD.9:4 - Solution
Develop an account from the material and the question. Compare the proposed whole with the details that support or challenge it. Revisit the units or relations whose interpretation still matters.
NSTD.9:4.1 - Establish the question and the available material
State what the question asks you to understand. Examine the relevant passage, observation or recording in enough context to distinguish what is reported from what you infer. If it is an account made on another occasion, ask who addressed whom, when and for what purpose, as far as those facts affect the meaning. A later recollection and a contemporary record can supply different evidence.
Distinguish what the source reports, the judgement a participant expresses and an imagined future. Identify assumptions that the account adds. Use FPF F.0.1 when the local meaning of an expression matters and remains unclear. Seek further material when its attainable contribution to the answer warrants the effort. Otherwise return the account the available evidence supports.
NSTD.9:4.2 - Form the units and connections the question needs
Try a compact account of what changes, persists or becomes significant. For a proposed event, identify the enduring subject, the states compared and the difference. For an episode, explain what connects its changes, such as a shared consequence, a developing relationship or an interrupted attempt. For an atemporal account, preserve the dependency or contrast that actually explains it.
Trace a consequential connection to its grounds. What someone knew has different grounds from what happened. A date can establish order while leaving motive open. Name a contestable assumption that connects a detail to the interpretation. An annotated paragraph, sketch or comparison can carry the result.
Try a different grouping if the first loses a consequential detail. A reported “closure” might concern public access even though activities continue for members. Separating access, activity and control lets the reader examine each claim. Keep the notice or other material available so that the grouping and its assumptions can be challenged.
NSTD.9:4.3 - Compare interpretations at the consequential difference
Compare a plausible alternative when it changes the conclusion or its use. Another participant, a detail the preferred account cannot explain, a different possible cause or a different framing may supply it. Use an adequate reading directly when the alternatives add nothing material.
Read the same material under each account. Which details does it explain, what does it leave out and what assumptions does it need? Ask how the whole affects the reading of each part and whether independent details support the whole. If an account of betrayal supplies the intention behind a delayed reply, the delay cannot independently establish that intention.
For a factual disagreement, compare the claims with relevant observations or subject findings. Seek a missing observation when a stronger answer matters and it can distinguish the claims. For different meanings of a shared occurrence, explain the concerns and grounds of each participant. For a textual interpretation, examine the wording, narrative position, repetition, contrasts and what the account has made available to that point. If the claim concerns what a particular reader knew or understood, use evidence about that reading. Leave factual questions open where the evidence ends.
NSTD.9:4.4 - Decide what to resolve and what to preserve
Select a single reading when its support is sufficient for the question. Retain several when the material supports each and their difference matters. Distinguish a missing fact, several supported readings and a set of proposals with too little evidence to use. The first may call for an observation, the second for a range of interpretations and the third for reporting a limit or reconsidering the proposals.
A literary passage may leave motive open while making the action clear. Identify the cues for any supported reading and the consequences of that reading. When composing an open scene, check that its intended alternatives are genuinely available. When interpreting someone else’s text, attribute that openness to authorial intention only when there is evidence for the attribution.
For a factual account, retain the uncertainty that matters to its use. New evidence can decide what happened while leaving differences in its significance intact. A participant’s account may already answer what they said about their experience or position. Use the relevant D.1–D.5 contribution when the task calls for a judgement of value, harm or consequences for an affected party that remains to be made.
NSTD.9:4.5 - Return the interpretation to its use
Give the resulting account, its important grounds and any material alternatives or limits. That may finish the work. For a further narrative, NSTD.1 selects material for a reader, NSTD.2 and NSTD.4 help choose order and viewpoint, and NSTD.3 examines the connections the passage invites. Return here if the draft exposes a new interpretive question.
If material or purpose changes, identify which unit, connection or assumption depended on the old condition. Reconsider that claim and the uses that rely on it. A new date can alter order, a newly available account can change the meaning of an episode, and a new question about causation may require evidence beyond an orientation account. Retain claims whose grounds still hold.
NSTD.9:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.9:5.1 - A community archive changes what “closure” means
A constructed local-history archive contains three items. A notice says, “The public reading room closes on 1 June.” A 3 June inventory records books moved to the room upstairs. A letter says, “We used to meet there after work; now only members have keys.” A museum writer first drafts, “In June the town lost its library.”
For a visitor asking what changed, the draft merges service, collection, location and access. The notice announces closure of the public room on 1 June. The 3 June inventory records the books upstairs. The former user reports losing a meeting place and says that only members now have keys. Together these support an account of a change in public use alongside retention of the books. They leave the exact date public use actually ceased, the full membership rule and the fate of other library activity open to further evidence if those questions matter.
“Preservation through relocation” concerns the books. “Loss of a shared place” concerns access and social use. The exhibition can present both, using NSTD.1 to select the evidence and NSTD.4 to show the perspectives. To claim that the move increased access, the writer would need evidence of who could use the library under each arrangement. To claim increased use, examine what users actually did.
Suppose a later register establishes that every resident was eligible to obtain a membership key. Correct any inference that some residents were ineligible. A membership requirement could still apply to everyone. The register leaves open who obtained or used a key, how easy it was to do so, and whether people still met there after work. The former user’s account remains evidence of the loss they experienced.
NSTD.9:5.2 - An open departure
Consider this invented passage. “Mara left at dawn. At the station she folded the return ticket into her father’s letter. When the train moved, she stopped rehearsing what she would say at home.” One reading finds a break with an earlier life. Another finds a temporary distance with return still possible. The ticket supports a possible return. The end of rehearsal marks a change in anticipation. Her later choice remains open.
“Permanent escape” adds an outcome. A report of a train journey alone misses Mara’s change in anticipation. The interpretation can finish with the tension and the two textual cues. An author seeking an open ending can use NSTD.2 to order them so that they qualify each other. If a later chapter establishes her return, date that knowledge to its basis while preserving the earlier uncertainty. The library’s membership rule raises a factual question of a different kind.
NSTD.9:6 - Bias-Annotation
Familiar stories of progress, failure, rescue or betrayal can shape which episodes an interpreter notices. Test a consequential excluded perspective or contrary detail against the available account. Give interpretations the weight their evidence warrants and state material limits of access or preparation.
NSTD.9:7 - Conformance Checklist
- The account answers a recognizable question using identifiable material.
- The account explains why the significant units belong together and what supports their connections.
- Reported claims, interpretation and invented possibilities remain distinguishable where the use depends on them.
- A consequential alternative or contrary detail, when present, receives a substantive comparison.
- The result states what is supported and what remains open. Identify a change that would affect the interpretation when its later use requires that condition.
NSTD.9:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | Repair |
|---|---|
| Verify only the outline extracted from the preferred story. | Return to the material and test the consequential grouping or connection. |
| Treat every perspective as equally factual. | Separate differing experiences from claims that need factual discrimination. |
| Supply a hidden motive to make the account coherent. | State its grounds or preserve the unresolved motive. |
| Complete an open text privately and report the result as its interpretation. | Retain the possibilities the text supports. Use NSTD.10 to create a separately identified continuation. |
| Demand a full research protocol for one ordinary reading. | Return a sufficient interpretation directly. Seek inquiry when a stronger claim needs evidence the material cannot supply. |
NSTD.9:9 - Consequences
The reader can revisit the particular unit or relation carrying the meaning. Closer reading may identify a possibility, a source gap or grounds for more than one interpretation. Further inquiry takes time. Pursue it when the attainable answer could improve the account or its use enough to justify that effort.
NSTD.9:10 - Rationale
Selection and presentation rely on an interpretation of the material. Checking that interpretation against the source and serious alternatives can expose unsupported groupings. The archive example separates the fate of a collection, use of a public room and the existence of an institution. Each question then has a possible narrative and its own grounds.
NSTD.9:11 - SoTA-Echoing
When events and their significance are already understood, extract and order the material directly. When the units or their connections remain open, propose a compact interpretation, inspect its assumptions and compare a serious alternative where it matters. Sections 4.2–4.4 allow the comparison to change the units themselves before an outline fixes them.
Schmid’s Narratology: An Introduction (2010), I.1 and V.3, examines state change, contextual significance, selection and presentation in literary narrative. This method adapts those distinctions to its particular material and separates what was stated from an inferred cause. Meretoja’s Implicit Narratives and Narrative Agency (2023) examines how available narrative models can shape which experiences and possibilities become intelligible. Section 4.3 adapts that approach to comparing frames. Evidence about the archive or a different factual case comes from that case.
The notice gives an announced date and the inventory records the books upstairs two days after that date. The undated letter distinguishes a former meeting place from the writer’s present experience. Separating collection, public room and access yields two supported interpretations and identifies limits on stronger factual claims. In Mara’s departure, the train journey and the changed anticipation both matter, and later return remains open. Comparing a consequential interpretation earns its cost in these cases. Sections 1 and 4.5 explain when a simpler account answers the question.
A new source can settle the disputed unit or connection and make direct extraction sufficient. A stronger causal question can call for a subject investigation. A different interpretive method may illuminate a difficult passage with fewer unsupported assumptions at comparable effort. Revisit the choice that the change affects.
NSTD.9:12 - Relations
NSTD.Reference:1.1–1.4 places interpretation in narrative work. NSTD.1 selects content. NSTD.2, NSTD.3 and NSTD.4 use connections and can expose a reason to revise them. NSTD.10 constructs fiction or explicitly hypothetical scenarios. NSTD.6 evaluates a particular narrative, and NSTD.7 applies these distinctions to tool-assisted interpretation. Use FPF F.0.1 for unresolved source-local meaning, F.0.2 for consequential synthesis across source ontologies and B.5.RC for recovery of an already described construction.
NSTD.9:End
NSTD.10 - Develop Story Events and Possibilities from Premises
Status: Stable
Type: DPF pattern body
Primary EntityOfConcern: fictional or explicitly hypothetical events and relationships that an author develops under chosen premises.
NSTD.10:1 - Problem frame
Use this method to develop events or relationships for a story or a hypothetical scenario. Start from a situation, image, premise, character, desired experience or possible ending. In an existing draft, use it when what happens needs to change. If the same events will serve, work on presentation order or expression.
Propose one change that matters in the imagined situation. Identify what could bring it about and what it would make possible or difficult. Retain the premises the work must respect. Where a premise is open to revision, identify what the revision changes.
A scene, arrangement of events or open continuation can be a finished result. Use NSTD.2 for ordering established events, NSTD.3 for a particular missing connection and NSTD.9 for interpreting existing material. For factual reporting, use evidence of the events. For a scenario about a real situation, distinguish observations, assumptions and proposed events. Check the feasibility or authority that actual reliance requires, using existing subject results where sufficient.
NSTD.10:2 - Problem
Premises can be consistent while leaving open what happens or why a participant would act. An author can inadvertently fill the gap with a convenient discovery, an unexplained decision or a resource that appears only when needed. Fixing the whole plot too early can also close off the possibility the writing was meant to discover.
NSTD.10:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Continuity and invention | Established constraints shape which changes are possible. Open choices let the author develop a new story. |
| Authorial direction and participant perspective | The author may want an outcome that no character wants or foresees. |
| Planning and discovery | Working backward can expose prerequisites; exploratory writing can reveal an unforeseen result. |
| Understandability and openness | Give readers grounds to follow what matters in the scene. A motive or later outcome can remain deliberately open. |
NSTD.10:4 - Solution
Develop the possible story and follow its important connections while they can still change. A scene can carry the work. Separate event notes, a timeline or a graph help when they make consequential branches, dependencies or collaboration easier to manage.
NSTD.10:4.1 - Distinguish premises from choices
For fiction, identify established world facts, continuity commitments, genre expectations and any fixed brief. Determine what the author can change. A deliberate departure from a genre convention is a creative choice. A changed canon commitment needs to be stated when it affects claimed continuity. Distinguish a proposed event from a premise already adopted for this story.
Name the creative question. Which relationship might change? What experience could the scene invite? What would happen if an expectation failed? An ending may be fixed, tentative or still open. For an exploratory scene, a starting situation and a question can be enough.
For a scenario in the real world, identify observed conditions, stated assumptions and proposed events. Follow their conditional consequences. State what is known about feasibility, including any part established by existing arrangements. Use available evidence for claims about someone’s likely future choice, while leaving actual execution open. If a necessary real arrangement remains missing and the task calls for supplying it, take that question to the practice responsible for it. The revised scenario can then use its result.
NSTD.10:4.2 - Construct a consequential possibility
Propose a concrete change to the situation, a participant’s understanding or a relationship. For a desired result, work backward to what must happen or become available, then forward to see whether the proposed means can supply it. If a fixed premise prevents the ending, change the means or revise an ending that the brief allows you to change.
For an open result, follow a choice, encounter, interruption, discovery or change in routine. What can each participant notice and do? What changes for someone else, and which questions remain? Keep an unexpected consequence that develops the creative question. A quiet recognition or change of relationship can be the whole scene.
For an intentional action, distinguish why the author includes it from why the character might do it. Consider what the character knows or believes, what matters to them and which alternatives they see. Impulse, mistaken belief and mixed motives can explain actions. Give the scene enough support for its intended reading, including cues to deliberately unresolved motivation.
When a proposal does not work, vary a consequential relation. Change who knows what, the cost of an action, an opportunity, an obligation or a consequence. Compare alternatives as far as the choice calls for. Keep a sufficient first invention.
NSTD.10:4.3 - Follow consequences through the story world
Follow the proposed events in world order, even if readers will encounter a different presentation order. Track the access, resources, timing, location, knowledge or commitments that later events need. If an action consumes a needed resource, establish how the later event could happen. An omitted transition can stay implicit when readers can recover it and its details do not affect the account.
Examine the meaning of the proposed sequence. A rescue might create an obligation, deepen resentment or make trust possible. Develop the chosen relation from these participants and their situation. Find the action or detail through which the scene makes it intelligible. If the intended experience is still missing, reconsider the event or its presentation.
For an interactive story, distinguish the available branches from the particular path a player takes. Follow the consequential branches under their own conditions. A resource spent on one branch is unavailable later on that branch unless it is restored. At a convergence, check that the common continuation is possible from each incoming branch. A.22.CGUS helps describe open, blocked and unresolved continuations when an explicit model is needed. A conditional account may suffice for a two-choice scene.
NSTD.10:4.4 - Develop presentation and revise the construction together
Use NSTD.2 and NSTD.4 to choose the order of disclosure, the cues available for inference and the character whose perspective the scene presents. Use NSTD.5 when an expressive choice should sustain interest. Inspect the scene under the reader’s assumed starting knowledge. What change can be followed? Which reading does the scene support? Would a different event better serve the intended effect? A suitable earlier response can establish what that reader reported. Use NSTD.6 when the task calls for evaluating the version for a particular use.
A later revelation can explain an earlier action if the story makes the explanation possible. A limited viewpoint can leave undisclosed something a character already knows. When the action lacks grounds in this world, alter it, add a compatible earlier event or revise an open premise. Use NSTD.9 to check whether different intended readings have support in the text.
A generated draft can propose possibilities through NSTD.7. Examine their consequences, retain useful invention and revise the plan where the scene supports a better direction. Check consistency against the premises. To claim that a reader found the scene moving, surprising or convincing, use evidence about that reader’s response.
NSTD.10:4.5 - Keep the sufficient result and reopen affected choices
Finish with a usable scene or possibility, the premises it needs and any consequential open choice. NSTD.6 helps assess the presented narrative for its intended use. Claims about an actual audience require evidence of the relevant response under the conditions of reception.
When a premise changes, follow the events and interpretations that depended on it. Earlier disclosure of a secret to a character can make their later ignorance untenable. Changing the desired experience from inevitability to uncertainty may allow the world events to stay as they are while the author changes disclosure to the reader. Revise what the change affects.
NSTD.10:5 - Archetypal Grounding
NSTD.10:5.1 - A desired alliance needs a story
In this fictional brief, cartographer A guards the only safe route through a mountain pass. Traveller B needs the route to reach a missing brother. An earlier unreturned loan gives A reason to distrust B. The author wants them to travel together. The world offers neither magical persuasion nor a second map.
“A suddenly trusts B and gives him the map” leaves the change in trust unexplained. What might make A accept the risk, and why would B accept A’s part in the journey? They might bargain, allowing A to keep the map while B provides transport. Alternatively, B could delay the search to rescue A’s apprentice during a flood, and A could witness that choice. The rescue can supply a reason for a change in their relationship. How A responds is another part of the story to construct.
For a tense alliance, the author chooses the bargain. A retains the map and offers access to the route. B accepts joint travel as preferable to searching without it. The terms explain their cooperation while distrust can persist. A later scene can let their actions under pressure alter the relationship. A rescue scene could instead develop a different basis for their cooperation.
Suppose A must stay in the settlement in person to care for the apprentice. Guided preparation from the settlement remains possible. Joint travel requires a change to that condition. The author can instead revise the ending if the brief permits. If the requirement is to provide care and a substitute is allowed, existing cover or a credible new arrangement can free A to travel. Delaying explicit mention of the loan changes what the scene discloses by that point. A reader who already knows about it can still interpret an earlier cue. The care and transport conditions stay the same.
NSTD.10:5.2 - An exploratory vignette without an ending to achieve
A retired tram driver sets two cups on the kitchen table every morning although he lives alone. The author starts from this image, with the reason and ending open. A neighbour knocks to return a borrowed tool. The driver offers the second cup. A private routine now has the possibility of becoming shared.
The second cup could express habit, hospitality, absence or an expectation the driver cannot articulate. Develop the encounter and retain the interpretations its details support. Adding a deceased spouse would create a new backstory. If openness is the aim, NSTD.9 helps inspect the competing readings. The scene can finish with the offer of the cup.
NSTD.10:5.3 - A reopening scenario exposes a missing arrangement
In a constructed planning case, a museum team considers reopening a ground-floor study room while a lift is being replaced. Collection storage remains upstairs. The proposal says that visitors can request any stored object, which staff will bring to the study table.
Trace one hypothetical visit. A visitor requests an object kept upstairs. Staff locate it, and it must reach the table while the lift is unavailable. The proposal supplies no means of moving every requested object. An existing inventory and an approved plan might already establish that particular objects can be moved downstairs before reopening. Use those grounds for the limited scenario. If a wider promise requires a new arrangement, consult the relevant collection and building expertise. Use C.32.P2S when the question calls for coordinated architectural change.
A revised scenario can follow a visitor choosing from the objects available downstairs under that plan and explain the limit on other requests. To report that the move or visit actually took place, use evidence of that event. An earlier lift opening would change the premise and might expand the available requests. Revisit the visitor sequence that depends on it.
NSTD.10:6 - Bias-Annotation
Planning from a goal suits stories whose important changes can be expressed as actions and prerequisites. Atmosphere, association, unstable identity or unresolved motive may call for an exploratory scene or a craft method suited to those effects. Examine a cultural expectation about plausible conduct as a premise in this story.
NSTD.10:7 - Conformance Checklist
- The question being explored and the premises that constrain it are recognizable.
- The proposed scene or sequence develops the event, relationship or possibility needed for the intended effect.
- Consequential prerequisites and effects are followed under the chosen world conditions.
- The author’s desired outcome remains distinguishable from participant knowledge, motives and choices.
- The scene supports the intended interpretation or gives readers grounds to see which issue remains open.
- A changed premise reopens the dependent construction while sufficient unrelated content is retained.
- For a real-world scenario, identify what is observed, what is assumed and which feasibility claims are established or remain open.
NSTD.10:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | Repair |
|---|---|
| A necessary resource appears at the moment of need. | Construct its availability, change the action or revise the premise. |
| Every character serves the desired ending. | Recover their perspectives and develop compatible or conflicting actions. |
| A reveal repairs an impossible event. | Repair the event’s world conditions before choosing when to reveal them. |
| A causal chain is treated as sufficient artistic quality. | Examine the experience and meaning the chosen use requires. |
| Every story must end in goal achievement. | Use an open or exploratory construction when it serves the work. |
| Hypothetical success is used as authority to act. | Use actual feasibility evidence and the applicable decision authority when committing to a real action. A conditional scenario can be complete before that commitment. |
NSTD.10:9 - Consequences
Working from premises can produce a scene, a relationship or an open possibility. Following its consequences can change the creative question. Consider the cost of a more detailed model alongside what it would let the team do. A branch map might help an author make a choice, verify coverage of known paths or pass their conditions to a co-author. Claims of novelty relative to other works, an audience effect or feasibility in the real world each need evidence about that claim.
NSTD.10:10 - Rationale
Choosing what happens and choosing when it is disclosed are connected decisions. Working backward identifies what a desired result needs. Working forward tests whether the means are available and reveals other possibilities. Comparing those consequences with the creative question can change the events or the question. The two-cup vignette reaches a useful scene from an open image.
NSTD.10:11 - SoTA-Echoing
For a fixed ending, work backward to expose its prerequisites. For an open scene, work forward from what a participant might do or notice. In either case, trace consequences that could defeat the proposed sequence. A fixed plan may give a character no reason to act, while unchecked exploration can invent knowledge or resources the world never supplied. Sections 4.1–4.4 let the resulting scene revise the plan or an open premise.
Riedl and Young (2010) distinguish a planning goal from a character’s intention. Their formal narrative planning supplies a way to examine prerequisites when a story has a desired outcome. STORYTELLER (Li et al., 2025) connects a developing plot line with a graph of narrative entities during automatic generation. Sections 4.2–4.4 adapt the questions about intention, prerequisites and changing event information. For manual work, a short scene can carry them. A computational plan can be useful when dependencies warrant it.
The bargain gives the travellers a means and reasons to travel together. An obligation for A to stay can prevent joint travel even when the route and both travellers’ motives remain the same. If the apprentice already has suitable care and that meets the condition, the journey can proceed as planned. The two-cup vignette develops a possible shared routine before its ending is known. A short scene can carry simple interacting branches. Use a more explicit plan when it helps with their dependencies, or a suitable craft method when atmosphere or association organizes the work.
Reconsider the construction when the brief requires control of every consequential branch, when the chosen form needs a different craft method, or when a different way resolves an observed continuity or intention problem at lower cost. New generator scores matter only if they change the grounds for the author’s actual choice.
NSTD.10:12 - Relations
NSTD.1 identifies the use and constraints. NSTD.9 interprets existing material or a new scene. NSTD.2 orders disclosure, NSTD.3 examines a connection, NSTD.4 develops voice and viewpoint, and NSTD.5 helps choose an expressive device. NSTD.7 supports automated drafting and inspection. NSTD.8 can teach the construction by varying a premise, and NSTD.6 evaluates the resulting narrative. A.6.3.NAR addresses rendering selected content, including a proposal explicitly presented as such. When a real scenario still requires a new project arrangement, C.32.P2S can develop its architectural basis. An existing arrangement or qualified feasibility finding may already answer the underlying question.