PSDA.20:4 - Solution
Connect the question to the relevant purposes and provision. Use the model to infer what follows from its relationships and stated premises, then interpret that result in the working situation. If an omitted condition affects the answer, revise the relevant model or question. Close with the finding, limit or next inquiry the receiving work needs.
The connected contributions are PSDA.12 for whose concerns enter, PSDA.3 for what the model can answer, PSDA.5 for alternatives, and PSDA.8:4.2.1 for qualitative analysis. Enter at the unresolved question and retain usable answers. If a current direct calculation or an already qualified comparison settles it, use that result.
The car-park case follows the inquiry through a staffing conflict and a revised allocation. Enter the general method at the part the question needs. An existing model may supply the relationships, a precise question may be ready for analysis, and an unexpected result may identify one missing premise. The exhibition case in §5 examines permissions and supply.
PSDA.20:4.1 - Let the question determine what to model
Identify what the inquiry needs to explain or support. Follow the result from the person or service that needs it to the work or outside provision on which it depends. Open a contribution when two ways of supplying it could change the answer, its grounds or the permissible action. Stop at a supplier’s qualified result when it settles the commissioned question. If a specific performance was promised, establish whether it was carried out. Use existing records, relevant accounts and observations that establish the operating conditions. For a participant’s intention or experienced burden, use an attributable account or ask when needed and feasible. State any material gap. Participation in building the model may help correct it. To report agreement with a proposal, use evidence of the relevant response.
Consider a car park whose unreliable sensors sometimes send drivers towards occupied floors. Attendants walk the floors and correct the displayed counts. Management proposes replacing the entire system, since the sensors cannot simply be exchanged in the current design. The inquiry asks, Does replacement address the service difficulty better than continuing manual correction? This is an adaptation of the parking exercise in the iStar tutorial, slide 57. The following participants, conditions and judgements are constructed for this walkthrough.
Include drivers because the guidance affects finding a place; attendants because correction requires their work; the operations manager because staffing and service arrangements are theirs to decide; and the technical supplier because replacement feasibility and installation depend on its contribution. Management cares about operating cost and reputation. Drivers care about usable guidance and protection of their cars. An attendant’s account of an assignment is evidence about that work, not a statement of every driver’s preferences.
Keep the questions distinct. What would make the displayed count trustworthy? Can the work supply it when needed? How would the alternatives affect cost and the concerns behind reputation? A model of intentions can expose these questions before it has the technical estimates needed to answer all of them.
PSDA.20:4.2 - Connect provision to the reasons on both sides
Distinguish a desired state, action, required entity and quality. Current guidance is a desired result. Walking the floors and entering a corrected count prescribes work. The supplied count is information used in the display. Accuracy concerns how well it represents available and occupied spaces for the intended guidance. Evidence of a completed round needs a further connection to support a claim about accuracy.
For a material dependency, identify who needs the contribution, why, and what must be supplied. Establish who could or did supply it and how, insofar as the question needs those facts. Keep an unknown provider or an unsettled means open. For example, an agreed assignment might read as follows.
The operations manager needs a checked floor count from the attendant so that the service can issue current guidance; the attendant obtains the count by inspecting the floor and entering the result before the next update.
Distinguish the checking task, supplied count and manager’s need. State any missing method, deadline or condition that limits the result. To claim availability, acceptance or completed work, use evidence for the particular claim.
Requiring a count with stated fitness conditions leaves room to choose its production method. Requiring a specified inspection task restricts that choice. State which relationship the work needs. Similarly, two recipients needing information called “the floor count” may need different intervals or accuracy; matching names do not establish interchangeable provision.
For this service, a suitable count and a working display are both needed. A recent manual inspection or supported automatic sensing might supply the count. Check the operating conditions for the means under consideration. Manual correction needs staff time and access. Replacement needs an applicable design, installation and operation. Investigate a proposed external delivery as a supplier contribution.
Give each relationship its intended meaning, such as necessity, sufficiency under stated conditions, a favorable or adverse contribution or a quality of a provision. The manager considers accuracy helpful to reputation and also values protection of parked cars. Evidence of protection is still needed to count it as provided.
PSDA.20:4.3 - Show the part of the model needed for the current question
A view showing only participants and external provision helps locate a missing supplier. Opening the manager’s and attendant’s internal reasons exposes why the count is needed and what work supports it. Opening the supplier’s proposed arrangement becomes useful when installation or later maintenance can change the answer.
In iStar the strategic dependency view, strategic rationale view and their selective combinations expose different parts of one model. Use the view that answers the question. Preserve the identified dependency across views. Check underlying conditions when the display omits a detail that matters. Asking whether the same count suffices for two floor allocations tests a different issue. A total can settle how many spaces remain while leaving the driver’s choice of floor open. Use a model that retains the locations, or a timely observation that distinguishes the available floors, when answering that question.
For this car park, an overview can show “attendant supplies count”. To examine availability during a shift, open the checking task and its staffing conditions. For a whole-cost comparison, use an applicable cost account, calculate it from qualified inputs or state the cost still unknown. The iStar 2.0 Guide, §§2–8 supplies the notation, distinctions and integrity rules when an actual iStar model is wanted. This prose walkthrough uses those distinctions without claiming to be a solver-ready model.
PSDA.20:4.4 - Turn a working question into an analysis, then recover its meaning
For each alternative the question concerns, identify which work or assumptions differ from the current arrangement. Alternative A retains the existing displays and uses manual correction. Alternative B installs the proposed replacement and uses its automatic counts. For the initial comparison, suppose staffing for A is available and the supplier has described a technically plausible B, while B’s installation interval and whole cost remain unknown. Do not compare A in its troublesome current state with B in an unexplained ideal state.
In this question, label each initial value as an observation or a stipulated assumption. To examine B if installed and operating as proposed, assume installation and the specified sensing performance. Keep installation and whole cost open for any investment decision. The conditional service comparison can proceed on its stated inputs.
Omitting manual rounds from B defines the proposal. It supplies no evidence about the attendants’ capability to inspect a floor. Use any independent evidence available for that question. Distinguish an unexamined element, an examined effect for which evidence is insufficient, a negative observation and conflicting grounds.
Follow the relevant relationships for each alternative. Use PSDA.8:4.2.1 for a needed qualitative analysis. Keep the initial assumptions and intermediate judgements with its result. For A, a sufficiently recent and correctly performed round supports a corrected count; publication still needs the working display. For B, the stipulated sensing performance supports the count conditionally; it does not establish the installation date or remove all future maintenance work.
Use the source that can support an unresolved contribution, such as a relevant participant’s stated judgement, an operating record or a specialist assessment. Here management judges that fewer misleading indications would help reputation. That supports a favorable contribution from guidance. The overall judgement about reputation remains open while protection is unresolved. Manual inspection can improve counts and increase staff burden at the same time. Assess those effects on their own grounds.
Return the conditional comparison in the terms of the car-park inquiry.
| Question | A: retained system with manual correction | B: proposed replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Can it provide useful counts? | Supported only while the stated inspection, freshness, staffing and publication conditions hold. | Supported conditionally on the proposed installation and sensing performance. |
| What happens to work and cost? | Inspection remains a recurring demand. | Some inspection may be displaced, but acquisition, transition and operating costs remain to be established. |
| Does it meet the concerns behind reputation? | Better count information addresses one concern; protection of cars needs its own grounds. | The same limit applies; a better sensor is not evidence of protection. |
The comparison identifies a possible service improvement under its assumptions. Installation timing and total cost remain open, so it leaves the investment decision unresolved. Return the conditional comparison if that answers the question. Seek the missing facts when their attainable contribution warrants the work.
PSDA.20:4.5 - Use surprising results to discover a different problem
Trace a surprising answer to the relationships, premises and analysis rules that produced it. Check whether the model misrepresents the work or the original question omitted a consequential condition. Correct an established error and reconsider the affected conclusions. Use the corrected model if it answers the original inquiry.
When the original question omits a necessary contribution, state the required joint result and the conditions that make it possible. Explain how the dependency changes the question for the intended use. A supported account of that dependency can finish an inquiry about the original proposal.
If the task needs another arrangement, work backward from the joint requirement. Look for feasible changes to the provider, means, timing or support. Use PSDA.5 when generating alternatives needs further work. A proposed relaxation of the requirement needs the applicable authority and the conditions of the recipient’s use.
Test each candidate combination under the same conditions, including competing assignments and shared resources. When a premise changes, revise the dependent conclusions and keep those still supported. Return the resulting candidate, supported rejection or open condition with the reason it matters.
Suppose the first model gave A an unqualified favorable result because it represented the round but omitted other assignments. Ask what must be true for that result to hold. Inspecting the rota now reveals that the same attendant must be at the security desk from 10:00 to 10:15, while the modeled correction requires leaving it for a round from 10:00 to 10:10. No substitute is assigned. These stipulated facts defeat the simultaneous arrangement.
The discovery changes the model and the problem. Add the required desk coverage and its relation to the attendant’s available work; then revise A’s count availability for this interval. The earlier claim that a completed, timely inspection can supply a count still holds. B’s separate technical hypothesis also survives. What fails is the premise that A’s work can coexist with the retained service obligations.
If the manager needs a remedy, the next question is how can the service provide current guidance and cover the desk during this interval? A different allocation or contributor would need to meet both requirements. The manager holds assignment authority. Use OCE.11 when the proposed change competes with continuing service.
Current guidance requires an adequate count and publication. Desk coverage requires someone at the desk. A competent relief checker could perform the round while the attendant remains at the desk. Establish whether the checker could obtain and publish the count in time with the required access and without leaving another necessary assignment. Until then the proposed allocation is conditional.
For a bounded continuation, suppose the manager assigns a competent relief worker for this interval, verifies that no other required assignment overlaps, and provides the permitted access and existing checking procedure. In the stipulated trial the relief worker obtains and publishes a count meeting the agreed freshness and accuracy conditions, while the attendant remains at the desk. Both required contributions are supplied in this interval. The added staffing cost belongs in A’s cost account. If relief is available only today, retain today’s result and reopen the staffing question before promising tomorrow’s service; the earlier investment question remains open.
A different candidate might change the update interval or the information promised to drivers. That changes the service requirement, so return to whether the altered guidance remains useful and acceptable. Do not weaken the criterion silently to make the diagram succeed. An incompatible candidate can be rejected without proving that all possible arrangements fail; an unsupported candidate stays conditional.
Retain the failed combination and its reason where another decision or attempt depends on it. In formal backward analysis, identify which premises or judgements produce the incompatibility. A proof of incompatibility establishes it within the encoding, premises and restrictions. A search that exhausted its allowance without finding a solution leaves compatibility unresolved. An organizational claim about all remedies needs evidence covering those remedies.
PSDA.20:4.6 - Stop with a usable answer and preserve the right return
In the stipulated interval the original assignments conflicted and the revised allocation supplied both services. The initial conditional comparison leaves the replacement investment open. A repaired rota can settle allocation for the interval. A cost comparison contributes to an investment question, while assignment of a checker needs a separate authorized act.
Close when the result answers the receiving question at the required strength. Return the supported comparison, explained incompatibility, fact about provision or precise missing information with the conditions needed to use it.
When a new fact matters, trace it to the affected premise, relationship and dependent conclusions. Keep independent results. For a needed technical result such as an accuracy bound or failure probability, use suitable existing evidence or an appropriate model. If the input or model is unavailable, identify the remaining limit.
If the analysis is difficult to interpret, try a small question whose expected answer can be traced through the relationships. Check for omitted providers or intentions relevant to the claimed coverage. The researchers also suggest extreme hypothetical settings and realistic alternatives for examining a model. Their usefulness for diagnosis and their feasibility as actual plans are separate questions. If the chosen language is unfamiliar, seek or provide the preparation the task needs.