SIE.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing
The best-known line combines terminology work, metadata-registry discipline, provenance, and source-local meaning recovery. The serious default is schema inspection plus organizational folklore. Its defect is not informality alone; it leaves no stable relation among the source claim, edition, authority, and mapping premise. SIE.2 adapts the line into a use-qualified manifest with an explicit inadequate-model return.
| Source line | Adopt, adapt, or reject | Role and limit |
|---|---|---|
Current FPF F.0.1 and F.0.2 | adopt | Recover source-local meaning and episteme identity; do not establish a cross-source correspondence or domain truth. |
| ISO 704:2022 | adapt | Keeps objects, concepts, definitions, and designations distinct; it does not decide the receiving integration. |
| ISO/IEC 11179-3:2023 and its item-mapping amendment | adapt | Contribute registry-item identity, versions, definitions, and mapping metadata; no automatic cross-source identity or fitness follows. |
| PROV-O | adapt | Distinguishes entities, activities, agents, derivation, revision, invalidation, attribution, and primary source; provenance establishes neither truth nor permission. |
| schema-only discovery | reject as sufficient | Structure and samples can locate questions but cannot replace source-local meaning, edition, authority, and applicability. |
Reopen when a source change alters a relied-on meaning, scheme, edition, effectivity, authority, access condition, or provenance chain, or when repeated cases show that an inventory position cannot support the downstream decision.