SIE.5:11 - SoTA-Echoing
The best-known line combines explicit identifier ownership and restrictions, provenance-qualified alternate/specialization relations, and domain traceability practice. The serious default is entity resolution that optimizes a match score or golden record. Its defect is not probabilistic matching itself; it is allowing the score or merged record to erase grain, issuer, interval, and decision authority. SIE.5 mutates the line into a bounded disposition consumed explicitly by downstream semantic results.
| Source line | Adopt, adapt, or reject | Role and limit |
|---|---|---|
| Current FPF identity and relation law | adopt | Keeps identity and direct relations as explicit claims; generic law does not decide a domain pair. |
| ISO 8000-115:2024 | adapt | Contributes identifier owner, use restriction, semantics, and resolution inputs; excludes identifier creation, query/response syntax, and resolution method and does not decide equivalence. |
| PROV-O | adapt | Supplies specialization, alternates, derivation, attribution, revision, and invalidation relations useful to evidence; provenance relations are not blanket identity. |
| SEMI traceability standards and GS1 EPCIS 2.0.1 | adapt | Supply semiconductor and event-based identity/traceability probes; scheme use does not create enterprise master identity or authorize recall. |
| golden-record or score-only merging | reject as sufficient | It may support candidate generation or a steward decision but cannot erase source identifiers, relation kinds, and authority. |
Reopen when an identifier scheme or issuer rule changes, new event/configuration evidence changes the disposition, the required grain or interval changes, or repeated cases show that the disposition vocabulary cannot preserve an action-changing relation.