SIE.6:11 - SoTA-Echoing
The best-known line combines claim individuation, provenance, authority-aware data integration, and explicit uncertainty. The serious default is master-record survivorship or source ranking. Those Methods can be valid under an authorized MDM use, but they are defective as a universal semantic-integration default because they hide non-comparability and transfer authority. SIE.6 adapts the line by making the qualified composition or explicit conflict the domain result.
| Source line | Adopt, adapt, or reject | Role and limit |
|---|---|---|
Current FPF C.2.1 | adopt | Keeps claims as distinct representational objects; SIE supplies the cross-source use composition. |
Current FPF A.10 | adopt | Governs claim-bound evidence and provenance reliance; evidence law does not choose the domain truth or action. |
| PROV-O | adapt | Supports derivation, attribution, revision, and invalidation traces; provenance alone establishes no truth, priority, or comparability. |
| MDM survivorship and golden-record practice | adapt only under direct authority | May supply an authoritative-value result for a bounded domain; SIE preserves its source and scope rather than generalizing it. |
| last-write, average, or global source-rank defaults | reject as universal | Each may be a justified local rule, but none is semantically safe without compatible claims and authority. |
Reopen when a source claim, identity premise, authority rule, interval, uncertainty model, or receiving use changes, or when representative conflict cases cannot be expressed without hiding action-changing information.