Patterns
SOM.1 - Model the Bodily Contribution to a Movement
Type: Method pattern Status: Stable
SOM.1:1 - Problem frame
Use this Method when you know the result a movement should produce but need to understand the bodily action that contributes to it. A once-useful correction that now fails can raise the same question.
Choose a particular movement. Relate what the performer experiences and can deliberately change to what happens in the action. Report a connection the evidence supports, or propose one and identify an observation that would count against it. Where a correction is the aim, use that connection to choose a suitable change.
For a bodily attempt, use familiar technique and comfortable conditions whose limits you understand, or obtain suitable instruction from a qualified teacher. If technique, loading conditions or a question about pain makes the attempt uncertain, obtain the relevant movement or clinical guidance before attempting it.
SOM.1:2 - Problem
An instruction to “keep the line continuous” names the result. “Relax your hand” proposes a change, but the writer may still need to know where, by how much and with what effect. An anatomical name can identify a structure. That name does not show whether the writer can distinguish or regulate the change the correction requires.
A line can break because of pen control, the movement, contact or the pen and paper. Check which explanations the observations support before prescribing further bodily practice.
SOM.1:3 - Forces
Use the bodily detail the question requires. A change meant to guide the performer’s deliberate regulation must be one they can distinguish and use. Include the other actions that must continue. An observer may see a contact change the performer missed. The performer may feel a change an observer cannot see. A comparison can distinguish candidate explanations without identifying the full physiological mechanism.
SOM.1:4 - Solution
SOM.1:4.1 - Choose the action interval
Identify the required result and the interval in which the question arises. Establish the support, contact, timing and any other condition that could affect it. Identify what was happening at the same time that mattered to the movement, including what must continue during any proposed correction.
For a dancer, the interval may include transferring support during a turn while steps and partner interaction continue. For a writer, it may be the part of a stroke where forearm support changes. Use the technique and criteria of that practice.
SOM.1:4.2 - Relate three accounts
For the same interval, establish what the evidence supplies about each of the following. Leave an unavailable account open.
- Experience: where a change is felt, its direction and how it develops.
- Regulation: what the performer can deliberately increase, decrease, release or coordinate in those conditions.
- Movement result: what happened to the contact, position, timing or other outcome that matters to the task.
Locate the felt change by a bodily landmark and direction where the performer can distinguish them. Use a finer account of the felt region when the performer can make that distinction and it matters to the question. To identify tissue or a physical cause, use evidence for that separate claim.
Identify which observations come from the performer and which come from another observer. If the performer notices a difference but cannot yet describe it, a comparison, gesture or demonstrated contrast may help them communicate it.
Include an involuntary response if it affects the movement. Establish separately whether the performer notices it and whether they can regulate it. Investigate a previously unnoticed effort when the model gives a reason to expect it will matter.
SOM.1:4.3 - Propose a change and a test
For a proposed change, state the bodily change the performer would try, its expected effect in the movement and the other actions that must continue. For example, “With a lighter hold I expect to keep the pen in contact while guiding the stroke.” Identify an observation that would count against the expectation.
Use a suitable existing comparison when it answers the question. If a new attempt is needed, try a small, familiar change within the limits of the practice and compare the bodily report with the movement result. Separate observations or attempts can help when attending to everything at once would disrupt the action. Account for differences between attempts before attributing a result to the change.
For comparison or feedback, describe the conditions, what was felt, what was deliberately changed, what could be repeated, any help received and what happened in the movement. A short spoken account or note can suffice. Distinguish felt intensity from the position or extent of the region if that affects the correction. Assess noticing, regulating and reproducing the change from their respective evidence.
If bodily regulation appears available but the intended result still fails, check external conditions. If a different condition is permitted, compare it using suitable existing observations or an attempt. A restored result may justify using the alternative while the cause of the earlier failure remains open.
SOM.1:4.4 - Choose the next move
Use SOM.2 if a needed change cannot be distinguished, SOM.3 if it can be distinguished but the required regulation is missing, and SOM.4 if available parts have yet to work together. Use SOM.5 when changing support or load affects the action. Return the resulting finding to the movement you are investigating.
Keep a permitted external adjustment that works. If the task requires the original conditions, establish what suitable explanation or technique is available for them. If the remaining explanations cannot be distinguished, identify the evidence that would distinguish them and the limit this places on the conclusion.
If the local correction fails in the whole action, reconsider the proposed connection. Report what the observations support under the conditions examined, a usable alternative or the relation still unresolved. When another attempt is needed, base it on that unresolved relation. Stop a physical attempt if pain, dizziness or an unfamiliar loss of control occurs.
SOM.1:5 - Archetypal Grounding
Suppose a writer can distinguish a lighter pen hold but the line still breaks on some strokes. The writer and observer compare the following observations from a short attempt.
| Question for this attempt | What the writer or observer reports |
|---|---|
| What was tried, and under what conditions? | A familiar short stroke with the forearm supported, using the same pen and paper. The aim was a continuous mark. |
| What could the writer distinguish? | “The squeeze around the pen feels lighter.” |
| What could the writer regulate? | “I can produce and release that change while moving the pen.” |
| What could be reproduced, with what help? | After one demonstration, the writer repeated the short stroke without another cue and again reported the lighter hold. Later recall and other strokes have not been tried. |
| What happened in the writing? | The line still sometimes broke. |
The reported feeling, the writer’s regulation and the resulting mark answer different questions. The repetition occurred after a demonstration and without another cue. The continued breaks leave the cause open. If repetition requires a cue, retain it as a condition. Use SOM.4 for missing recall of the combination, SOM.2 for a missing distinction, SOM.3 for missing regulation or SOM.5 when the difficulty occurs as support or load changes.
Suppose the pen stays in contact and the writer keeps moving it. A change of paper restores a continuous mark with the same lighter hold. If the new paper is permitted, the writer can use it. If the original paper is required, investigate the pen and material under that condition. The successful stroke answers the practical question about the new paper while the cause of the earlier breaks remains open.
A salsa dancer may feel a more even change yet miss a step or disrupt the partner’s movement. That attempt does not establish the required turn. Reconsider the proposed connection in light of the steps and partner interaction that had to continue, while keeping the cause of any disruption open until the evidence supports it.
SOM.1:6 - Bias-Annotation
A teacher’s preferred body map may suggest useful questions. It may also influence what the performer reports and how the teacher explains a failure. Establish what the performer distinguished and what happened in the action. An unnoticed effort can affect the movement. Once noticed, it may still be beyond the performer’s voluntary control.
SOM.1:7 - Conformance Checklist
Identify the interval and the required movement result. Relate the available observations of the performer’s experience, deliberate action and movement result, including the actions that had to continue, the support and the conditions examined. State what the evidence supports and where an account is unavailable. If proposing a change, identify a result that could count against it and use the observations to select any further work the task requires.
SOM.1:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
An anatomical label leaves the action unclear. If the learner can repeat the label but cannot act on it, find a contrast they can distinguish and a change they can regulate. Use anatomy for the explanation it supports.
Every output failure becomes a training need. The broken-line case invites this mistake. Inspect the connection and external conditions before assigning more bodily practice.
SOM.1:9 - Consequences
A performer and teacher can use the model to discuss and test a correction. The comparison may show that a change outside the body already gives the required result. Claims about learning, physical cause or transfer require evidence appropriate to each. Describing all three accounts takes attention, so use the detail needed for the question.
SOM.1:10 - Architectural Rationale
The movement gives the three accounts a common episode. The performer can describe how the change felt, an observer can describe contact or timing, and either may have evidence about what the performer deliberately changed. Those observations help relate the bodily contribution to the other work the action requires.
SOM.1:11 - SoTA-Echoing
For a correction a performer can try and assess, we adapt the aim of system fitness to connect bodily description and regulation with the movement practice. That source proposes a method. Here we compare three accounts and check relevant external conditions. A claim about comparative effectiveness requires evidence of the compared teaching outcomes.
When a teacher can give a usable correction and identify the conditions in which it applies, the performer can use it directly. A model is worth the additional work when the referent or the effect of the correction remains open.
In Pawłowski and colleagues’ finger-force experiment, measured force drifted after visual feedback was removed. Participants later reported that they had followed the instruction to keep force constant. The researchers measured force and asked about compliance. They did not measure constancy of felt effort. We adapt that distinction when comparing the accounts in §4. Reassess this teaching proposal when a better explanation of the task or a comparative study changes which distinctions are useful.
SOM.1:12 - Relations
Use SOM.2–SOM.5 for the missing bodily learning or coordination. Use FPF A.6.P.RI to identify whose access supports an account, B.5.EA to express a distinction and B.1.5.EW to relate the bodily action to the concurrent activity. Use HCD.6 and HCD.9 for practice design and feedback. Obtain the technique and criteria of success from the movement practice.
SOM.1:End
SOM.2 - Make a Bodily Change Distinguishable
Type: Method pattern Status: Stable
SOM.2:1 - Problem frame
Use this Method when a bodily instruction is hard to act on because the performer cannot distinguish the location, direction or developing change it names. Report the difference the performer can notice again under suitable conditions, or the conditions under which they could not distinguish it. Identify what prevented recognition when the evidence supports that explanation. Assess control from evidence of regulation.
Start with the distinction the movement requires. Use SOM.1 if its relevance is uncertain. If the performer already distinguishes the change, use that finding and address any regulation or combination the movement still needs. For practice, choose familiar comfortable conditions or obtain suitable instruction from a teacher before using unfamiliar loading.
SOM.2:2 - Problem
A performer can understand “less effort” yet have no bodily difference they can recognize. More specific anatomical words may leave the same difficulty. An observer may see a difference that the performer cannot feel. A difference the performer feels may leave the external result unchanged.
SOM.2:3 - Forces
Choose a contrast large enough for the performer to notice and suitable for the movement. A support can make the difference accessible and also change the task. Use detailed language once the performer can recognize what it describes. Noticing and regulating can develop in the same attempt. Use evidence for each claim.
SOM.2:4 - Solution
SOM.2:4.1 - Construct an accessible contrast
For a new comparison, select two comfortable ways the performer can already carry out one task-relevant change. Vary the support, intended direction or amount as needed to make that contrast accessible. Keep other conditions alike where possible and note any differences that could also explain the observation.
For a new trial, compare the first variant, the second and then the first again. An existing sequence showing those comparisons can supply the same evidence. Examine what changes during the action and after release. The return tests whether the performer can recognize the contrast again under these conditions.
In familiar writing, compare the usual pen hold with a slightly lighter hold while the forearm rests in its usual supported position. Return to the usual hold. Do not deliberately increase load to obtain a stronger sensation.
SOM.2:4.2 - Locate what is distinguishable
Establish where the performer experiences the change, in which direction and how it develops. A first answer may be a broad region, a gesture or “no reliable difference.” A bodily landmark can help the performer locate the experience again. Identifying the tissue responsible requires other evidence.
If the task still requires a distinction the performer cannot make, try a coarser contrast or other suitable support. Accept the performer’s account, including that they could not tell the two variants apart. Refine the region when the movement question requires a finer distinction.
Whether the performer notices an effort and whether it is voluntary are separate questions. The performer may learn to report a previously unnoticed change while still being unable to regulate it.
SOM.2:4.3 - Connect the contrast to action
To establish whether the difference is available in the receiving movement, use the variants in a suitable part of that movement or examine an adequate existing comparison. Relate the performer’s experience to the external result. For a familiar pen stroke, check security, guidance and contact. If a lighter hold changes these together, account for their coordination.
If the lighter hold leaves the pen insecure, use a hold that keeps it secure. The comparison still identifies a bodily distinction and a limit on using that variant for the stroke.
Use SOM.3 if the performer recognizes a needed change but cannot yet regulate it. If the distinction disappears in the full action, report where it remained available. Use the relevant combination or support transition if the performer needs it in motion. A claim of transfer needs observations in the relevant changed condition.
SOM.2:5 - Archetypal Grounding
In the writing comparison, one performer may report a change around the fingers and another a broader change in the hand and forearm. Check whether each can recognize their difference again. When the question concerns choosing or regulating an action, establish what that distinction helps the person do. The appropriate resolution depends on the person and the task.
Suppose the writer distinguishes the usual and lighter hold while stationary and loses that distinction during the stroke. This supports recognition in the preparation and leaves its use in motion unresolved. Another writer might feel the difference while moving and produce the same continuous line with either hold. In that case the mark alone gives no reason to prefer one hold.
A dance teacher may choose a familiar supported preparation in which a dancer can distinguish two directions before using them in a turn. Use dance instruction for the directions and safe preparation. Compare the variants and return to the first to check the distinction under that support.
SOM.2:6 - Bias-Annotation
A performer may agree with the teacher’s description without recognizing the contrast. Accept the performer’s description or the finding that it remains indistinguishable. If several conditions changed together, keep the cause of a reported difference open to the extent the observations leave it uncertain.
SOM.2:7 - Conformance Checklist
Identify the needed action, the variants compared and the conditions that made a comparison suitable. Report what the performer could distinguish, with what support, or what remained indistinguishable. State the evidence for its use in the receiving action if that is part of the question. Keep claims about regulation within the evidence of deliberate control.
SOM.2:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
Finer wording is treated as finer perception. A learner repeats a detailed bodily description without distinguishing the changes. Return to an accessible contrast.
A supported preparation is used to claim whole-task capability. Report the distinction under its support conditions. To claim that it guides an unsupported moving task, use suitable observations in that condition.
SOM.2:9 - Consequences
The performer and teacher can use the recognized contrast to refer to the same correction. This may reduce time spent repeating an instruction. An estimate of time saved or learning improvement needs evidence. Keep the support or the broader distinction when it serves the receiving task.
SOM.2:10 - Architectural Rationale
A recoverable contrast gives the bodily instruction a referent the performer can recognize. Returning to the first variant checks whether they can recognize the difference again. Comparison in the receiving action tests whether it matters there. Evidence of deliberate change is needed to establish regulation.
SOM.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing
To make a bodily change distinguishable, we adapt the contrast and return in HCD.6.1 to the support, direction or other felt change relevant to the task. A verbal or anatomical explanation can suffice when the performer already knows the bodily referent. If it is missing, choose a suitable encounter with a difference the performer can experience.
Support and contrasts in direction or effort are proposed ways to teach the distinction. Which contrasts and which forms of support suit this performer and task remain questions for comparison. Use a qualified movement method when it supplies a suitable answer, and adjust the contrast or support to the evidence.
Preparing and supporting the contrast takes time. It can supply a bodily referent that guides the next attempt. Reconsider the choice if the performer cannot recognize it again, if it fails to help the receiving movement, or if suitable instruction can provide the needed connection with less effort.
SOM.2:12 - Relations
Use SOM.1 to identify a distinction that matters to the movement and investigate its effect when that is the question. Use SOM.3 for missing regulation, SOM.4 for coordination and SOM.5 for changing support. HCD.6.1 gives the general contrast-and-return method. Use HCD.6 to design representative practice and HCD.10 to vary or progress it in response to performance. Use FPF B.5.EA to express a distinction the performer can now recognize.
SOM.2:End
SOM.3 - Regulate Bodily Effort in Discernible Steps
Type: Method pattern Status: Stable
SOM.3:1 - Problem frame
Use this Method to investigate how a performer regulates a distinguishable bodily change, or to develop the increase, reduction or release a movement requires. For practice, work under familiar, suitable conditions and identify the required result.
Establish which increments or releases the performer could regulate, under what conditions and with what observed effect. Report any relevant limit. Use SOM.2 when practice requires a difference the performer cannot distinguish. Obtain suitable instruction if the intended attempt requires an action or load whose suitability is unknown.
SOM.3:2 - Problem
The performer may first notice a change after release, overshoot the desired change or report constant effort while the output drifts. To develop control, begin with a change the performer can recognize and practise adjusting it as the action unfolds. Compare the report of effort with the external result the movement requires.
SOM.3:3 - Forces
Smaller increments can allow finer control until the performer can no longer distinguish them. Feedback may expose drift and also become necessary for the result. Judge a reduction in effort by whether the performer retains the contact, support and other actions the movement requires.
SOM.3:4 - Solution
SOM.3:4.1 - Establish an available change
Identify the required result and the proposed bodily change. Use SOM.1 if the connection is unclear. Find a contrast the performer can already distinguish with the relevant support and contact. Start at a familiar amount that serves the task.
Establish what the performer notices as the change develops and after release. If the difference is first noticed at release, use that observation when planning any further attempt.
SOM.3:4.2 - Adjust in discernible increments
For practice, make a small increase, reduction or release within the familiar technique’s limits. Observe the change as it develops, what follows release and the effect on the movement. Choose another increment if the result gives a reason to refine or adjust it.
Refine the increment while the performer can still distinguish it and finer control matters to the task. If the change becomes indistinguishable, restore a usable increment or adjust the support within known limits. If a reduction loses required contact or support, return to an amount that works. Report that limit on the usable range.
If the performer needs to learn to adjust during the action, practise while the effort develops. After-release reports can guide learning. To establish control during the action, use evidence from that interval. If a reported change leaves the expected external effect absent, reconsider the proposed connection.
SOM.3:4.3 - Compare experience and effect
Observe the result the task requires, such as tool security, continuity of contact or position. An instrument can help when it measures a relevant quantity at a suitable resolution. Identify the quantity and what changes the reading can resolve.
Compare the performer’s report with the observed movement result. Establish what each shows about the intended regulation under the conditions examined. If force is measured, distinguish the force reading from the report of sensation. A stable reading alone leaves open which bodily action produced it.
SOM.3:4.4 - Restore the conditions of use
Use feedback permitted in the intended work. If later performance must occur without a display or a teacher’s cue, use evidence from that condition and arrange a suitable attempt when needed. If continuing feedback is permitted and supports the required result, the performer can retain it.
For a claim about the whole movement, use evidence under its required conditions, including the actions that must continue. Restore those actions when a new attempt is needed. Use SOM.4 when checking one element after another prevents joint performance and SOM.5 when changing support or load disrupts regulation. Stop an attempt if pain, dizziness or unfamiliar loss of control occurs. A failed increment identifies a limit in that attempt. Its cause requires other grounds.
SOM.3:5 - Archetypal Grounding
With the forearm in a familiar writing position, the writer can distinguish a small release of the pen hold. The writer tries a smaller release step and makes a short mark, checking whether the pen remains secure. If reducing the holding effort makes guidance unreliable, the writer returns to the preceding usable hold. Report the range of effort the writer can control while making this mark.
Suppose a learner keeps measured force near its target while watching a display. With the display hidden, force drifts although the learner reports unchanged effort. The first attempt supports control with visual feedback. The drift alone does not tell us whether the unaided force stayed within a permitted tolerance. If the task permits feedback, the teacher can retain it. If it requires unaided control, compare the reading with that requirement and consider another contrast or practice if control is missing. A conclusion about which muscle caused the drift needs other evidence.
A dancer might regulate an adjustment in a familiar preparation and lose it in a turn. Report the regulation under the preparation conditions. To assess the turn, use observations in motion. To learn a missing combination, choose an attempt that retains the relevant turning action.
SOM.3:6 - Bias-Annotation
Judge control by the movement criterion and evidence of the performer’s regulation. Comfort, agreement with the teacher’s description and a stable display can each answer a narrower question. If the performer notices an involuntary effort, establish separately whether they can regulate it.
SOM.3:7 - Conformance Checklist
Identify the distinguishable change, suitable conditions and increments relevant to the task. Compare the evidence about felt or deliberately regulated changes with the observed external result, identifying any unavailable account. Distinguish what was noticed after release from regulation during the effort. Report the feedback, support and limits that qualify the finding.
SOM.3:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
The increment becomes too small to distinguish. Return to a contrast the performer can recognize. Use an observable change and its effect to assess control.
A constant-effort report certifies constant output. Compare the report with the task’s external result. When feedback is removed, observe the resulting performance rather than carrying over the supported conclusion.
SOM.3:9 - Consequences
Incremental practice can produce a usable change or identify its present limit. A contrast can also expose a mistaken model. The resulting range applies under the observed conditions. Choose training duration or progression from the task and the performer’s response. Seeking finer resolution after the criterion is met can consume attention without improving the movement.
SOM.3:10 - Architectural Rationale
Use the performer’s experience to choose an adjustment and the external result to assess its usefulness. When someone else evaluates the attempt, distinguish what the performer reported from what was observed. What happened while the effort developed can support a claim about control during the action. The after-effect can help the performer choose a further attempt.
SOM.3:11 - SoTA-Echoing
To regulate effort while retaining the required result, we adapt bodily increment practice and the feedback and retry in HCD.9. When the performer already has the required control, a familiar instruction can suffice. If control is uncertain, compare the attempted change and its effect. This takes time and attention.
Pawłowski et al. observed force drift after visual feedback was removed. Participants later reported following the constant-force instruction. The study measured force and asked about compliance. The effort report in §5 belongs to the constructed example. We adapt the comparison of feedback conditions in §4.4. To judge incremental practice as a remedy, one would need evidence that the practice improves the required regulation.
Herzberg, Halperin and Wolpe studied overall effort ratings in relation to force and task features. We reject using that measure as a scale for a localized felt change. Reconsider the practice if it fails to provide the needed regulation or if another method achieves that result at lower cost.
SOM.3:12 - Relations
Use SOM.2 for a missing distinction, SOM.1 for the proposed relation to the task, SOM.4 for coordination and SOM.5 when the conditions of support change. Use HCD.9 for practice with feedback and retry, HCD.10 for its distribution and HCD.11 to interpret performance evidence. Obtain technique and loading limits from the movement practice.
SOM.3:End
SOM.4 - Build and Recall a Coordinated Bodily Change
Type: Method pattern Status: Stable
SOM.4:1 - Problem frame
Use this Method when the performer can make the necessary bodily changes separately but checking them one by one disrupts an action that requires them together. The aim is a coordination the performer can recall as it unfolds.
An ensemble is the combination of bodily changes the task requires. Its contributing regions may be separate, including regions that are not anatomically adjacent. Judge the combined change by its result in the receiving movement under the conditions examined.
To learn recall, first identify a workable portion the performer has experienced. If the required combination has never been available, construct a suitable portion or obtain the instruction needed to do so.
SOM.4:2 - Problem
Holding and guiding a tool, transferring support during a turn, or keeping time while coordinating with a partner can require actions to develop together. Correcting them one by one may interrupt the movement. Remembering its end posture leaves open how the performer enters, sustains and leaves it.
SOM.4:3 - Forces
Detailed observation helps the performer build a coordination but takes attention during use. Recalling its unfolding feel may reduce that demand. Keep the required external result in view, especially when adding a change that can disturb one already available.
SOM.4:4 - Solution
SOM.4:4.1 - Select the needed combination
Identify the actions that must occur together in the chosen interval. Use SOM.1 if the relevant relation is unclear. A writer might need to guide the pen while maintaining contact. A dancer might need to balance, step and keep the relation to a partner.
A cue about the movement’s effect may already give the required action. Use it when it works, or try a suitable cue if its contribution is open. If it leaves the coordination unresolved, examine the uncertain parts in the conditions in which they must work together. Use SOM.2 for a missing distinction and SOM.3 for missing regulation. Success with each part under different conditions leaves their combination to be established.
SOM.4:4.2 - Assemble from a workable portion
Start with a combination the performer can carry out. Add a needed change and observe its effect on the actions already in the combination. Reduce irrelevant demands while preserving what needs to be learned. In writing, shorten the drawing if that helps, but keep the support transition when the failure occurs there.
If checking every part during one movement interrupts it, distribute observations over comparable attempts. Attend to a bodily relation in one attempt and observe a concurrent contribution or movement result in another. Retain differences between attempts and identify any help received from an observer.
When an added change disrupts the combination, locate the failure before adding another. Prepare the missing relation, adjust support within the practice’s limits or obtain a demonstration that makes the change available to investigate. Recall practice starts once the performer can produce a workable combination.
SOM.4:4.3 - Learn and recall the development
Attend to how a workable combined change starts, develops and releases. Practise recalling how the coordinated action feels as it unfolds in another instance of the receiving movement. Judge it by the observable result and the other actions that must continue.
When joining portions, overlap them and check the overlap in motion. A pause can serve preparation. To support a claim about continuous coordination, use observations during continuous movement. Use SOM.5 if changing support or load affects the connection.
When a bodily contribution is added or changed, check whether the other required actions still work with it. Use an already workable revised combination, and practise it when it is missing.
SOM.4:4.4 - Return to whole performance
For a new attempt at the receiving movement, restore the duration, speed, support, timing and interactions it requires. Identify any assistance received. When later use requires independence from a particular aid, assess that condition from suitable existing observations or a new attempt. Where attentional focus still needs to be chosen, compare a cue about the movement’s effect with bodily monitoring and retain what serves the whole action.
When familiar recall yields an unsuitable result, locate the discrepancy. The missing contribution might be a bodily distinction, regulation, coordination or a suitable account of the task. Report which combination, if any, worked and under what conditions. A broader capability claim requires evidence covering its scope.
SOM.4:5 - Archetypal Grounding
A writer can hold a pen securely and guide a stroke but pauses to check grip, wrist and forearm in turn. The writer starts with a familiar short mark in which hold and guidance work together, attends to how the combination develops and tries to recall it for another mark. Across attempts the writer and any observer can examine different details. The written line provides evidence about whether the repeated stroke remained continuous.
If the stroke requires a transition in forearm support, successful short marks under fixed support leave that transition untested. Use SOM.5 to construct it when learning the transition is the task. Shortening the movement helps only if the reduced task retains the relation that matters.
For a salsa turn, identify the bodily change that must work with the steps and the partner’s movement. If the adjustment interrupts either, reproducing its isolated feel does not yet give the required turn. Use dance instruction for the turn and suitable preparation.
SOM.4:6 - Bias-Annotation
A clear description can coexist with unreliable coordination. A familiar feeling can also outlast the conditions in which it gave the required result. Judge the action and let the task determine which regions and effort changes need to participate. Different bodily organizations can give the same suitable outcome.
SOM.4:7 - Conformance Checklist
Identify the concurrent requirements and any available portion or missing construction. For learning, distinguish detailed preparation from recall of the developing movement. Check how an added or changed contribution affects the others. For a claim about the whole action, use evidence under its conditions. Paused preparation, aided performance and success at endpoints support findings limited to those conditions.
SOM.4:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
The performer is asked to recall a combination they have never produced. Work from a usable portion or get a demonstration that helps construct one. Then practise recalling the combination once it has worked in the task.
The preparation removes the relation that fails. Easy fixed-support marks are practiced for a changing-support difficulty. Retain the transition in the reduced task and test it in motion.
SOM.4:9 - Consequences
Recall may make a combined bodily action available while leaving more attention for other requirements. Establish any amount of attention saved from observations. If a new contribution disrupts the combination, rebuilding it takes additional work.
SOM.4:10 - Architectural Rationale
Construction makes a workable combination available. Recall lets the performer reproduce how it develops during movement. Judge each by the action it serves. The task determines which bodily changes belong together. Anatomical subdivisions and the levels of work in the encompassing activity answer different questions.
SOM.4:11 - SoTA-Echoing
For using bodily changes together, we adapt construction of a coordination and recall of its unfolding feel, together with the whole-task practice in HCD.6. Detailed monitoring can help preparation when it leaves the action intact. A cue about the effect can help a performer recall the combination during use. If a choice of focus is needed, compare the alternatives in the whole movement as in §4.4.
Tarasova and colleagues found faster simulated cannulation with instructions focused on the needle and target than with instructions focused on the hand. The task used ultrasound, the study lacked a neutral-instruction group and follow-up on retention was limited. We adopt the cue about the effect as an alternative worth considering under those limits.
A 2024 reanalysis of attentional-focus studies reports heterogeneous effects and sensitivity to publication bias. Its abstract supports caution about a universal rule. A task-specific teaching protocol needs its own grounds. We reject ranking a cue from its “internal” or “external” label alone.
Assembly and recall offer a way to try the coordination. Preparation and any relearning take time. A comparative learning advantage for this procedure has not been established. Reconsider the method when a simpler cue supplies the action, recall disrupts another contribution or the preparation fails to produce the required combination.
SOM.4:12 - Relations
Use SOM.1 to identify the combination needed for the movement, SOM.2 and SOM.3 for missing distinctions or regulation, and SOM.5 when changed conditions alter their relation. Use HCD.6 to retain the relevant relation to the whole task during preparation. HCD.10 supports varying or progressing practice towards the conditions of use. FPF B.1.5.EW relates work occurring together, such as maintaining balance while performing a turn with a partner. Use movement knowledge to identify the bodily contributions involved.
SOM.4:End
SOM.5 - Adapt Bodily Coordination to Changing Support and Load
Type: Method pattern Status: Stable
SOM.5:1 - Problem frame
Use this Method to investigate or develop coordination through a change in support or load. The performer may succeed on both sides and lose contact, balance or timing during the transition. Identify which result must continue across the change.
Use observations from the transition to establish what happened, what portion works or which relation remains open. If developing a response, test the revised coordination through the required change. Use familiar technique within the movement practice’s limits. Obtain suitable preparation or instruction before attempting a new load beyond them.
SOM.5:2 - Problem
A writer can hold and guide a pen in two positions yet lose contact when moving between them. A dancer can balance before and after a turn yet lose the step during support transfer. Repeating a successful endpoint tests that position. An account of the intervening action needs evidence from the transition.
SOM.5:3 - Forces
When preparing an attempt, reduce unnecessary demands while preserving the support change being investigated. Slowing the movement may make the change easier to observe and may alter its mechanics. Where the adjustment depends on a timing cue, the performer must be able both to use the cue and to produce the response while the other actions continue.
SOM.5:4 - Solution
SOM.5:4.1 - Locate what changes
Locate the relevant interval and identify the required movement result. Use SOM.1 if their relation is unclear. Establish where support acts, which contact must continue and how the load changes. Link this observation to the performer’s experience or regulation where those accounts are available. State the limits of each finding.
Use existing observations where they cover the transition. If checking each part during one movement interrupts it, distribute observations across comparable attempts and identify any observer assistance. The evidence may suggest a relation worth testing before it establishes the cause of failure. If it supplies neither a supported finding nor a useful hypothesis, identify what is missing. Obtain a discriminating observation when the next task warrants it and it is feasible.
SOM.5:4.2 - Preserve the transition in preparation
When preparing the transition, choose a short movement that starts before the relevant change and ends after it. Reduce other demands while preserving the contact, support and concurrent actions that define the difficulty.
Use familiar slower execution, pauses or static positions when they help locate a relation. If they change the demand, use the result for preparation. A claim about successful continuous movement at the required speed needs evidence from those conditions.
SOM.5:4.3 - Extend an available coordination
To develop coordination, start from a portion in which the necessary actions work together and extend it towards the interval under investigation. Establish how far the combination works. If it fails, locate the first loss and compare suitable small, familiar adjustments while retaining the other actions.
When learning is needed, begin with a workable portion and extend it through more of the support change. Compare the developing feel and movement result with the preceding attempt. Use SOM.2 if a needed difference remains indistinguishable there, SOM.3 if the required regulation is missing, and SOM.4 if available actions still need to be combined.
When joining successful portions, overlap them and examine the overlap in motion. If the task requires an adjustment the performer cannot yet find or make, identify the relation that needs instruction and seek suitable help. If the task was to establish the limit of this attempt, report that finding.
SOM.5:4.4 - Connect adjustment and cue
For a new adjustment that needs a cue, identify a change the performer can notice before the loss and use while acting. It might be a shift in support or an external relation in the task. Connect the cue with the response that worked in the successful portion.
Use a suitable observation of the adjustment with its cue, or try them together when a new attempt is needed. Identify a teacher’s prompt or temporary marker as part of the support. To claim performance without it, use observations under that condition. If the cue or response is missing, identify which contribution the task still needs.
SOM.5:4.5 - Return to the required action
To test the whole transition, restore the required interval, speed and concurrent demands. Use the bodily or task cue that supports the action. Judge what happened in the movement and what the performer could do while acting, with the relevant support.
If the transition fails, retain what the preparation established, including the limit of a portion that did not work. Determine whether the unresolved relation concerns a bodily action, cue, technique or missing observation. Revise the model when its proposed connection fails. Stop an attempt if pain, dizziness or unfamiliar loss of control occurs.
SOM.5:5 - Archetypal Grounding
An experienced writer draws a continuous line in two familiar forearm positions, but the line breaks during the support transition. Sequentially checking grip, wrist and forearm also stops the stroke. The pen and paper have been checked.
Across attempts, the writer relates the point where the line breaks to the change of forearm support. The writer selects a shorter stroke that retains the transition. Starting from the portion where contact and guidance work together, the writer compares small familiar adjustments near the point of failure. The writer learns how a workable portion develops, then joins overlapping portions in motion.
The writer can use a visible point on the drawing path to time an adjustment already learned. Once the transition works on the short stroke, the writer tries it over the longer stroke at the required speed. If the appropriate response is still unknown, the supported result identifies the relation between contact and support for which instruction is needed.
For a salsa turn, use dance technique to identify the transfer of support, steps and partner interaction. A reduced task must preserve the support change during which the failure occurred. Static positions can show what the dancer does at the endpoints. To assess the turn at the required tempo, use observations in motion at that tempo.
SOM.5:6 - Bias-Annotation
A change of support at the point of failure gives a relation to investigate. To attribute the failure to it, examine evidence that distinguishes plausible causes. A familiar successful endpoint gives evidence about that position. Use observations during the transition to identify the actions available there.
SOM.5:7 - Conformance Checklist
For an account of a transition, identify the changing relation, the movement result and the conditions observed. If a correction needs practice, preserve the transition in the reduced task. When joining workable portions, check the overlap in motion. If the adjustment requires a cue, connect an available cue to an available response. Base a claim about the whole transition on observations in the required conditions. Identify assistance, any change of speed and any explanation the evidence leaves open.
SOM.5:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
Two successful postures are taken as evidence of a successful transition. Examine the action between them. When the performer needs to learn it, construct a suitable portion and check how the portions join in motion.
The exercise omits the change under investigation. Success under fixed support leaves open what happens during the support transfer where the failure occurred. Keep the transfer in a suitably reduced movement.
A timing cue is offered when the bodily response is missing. Identify whether the performer can notice the cue and perform the adjustment. If the adjustment is missing, prepare it or obtain suitable instruction before practising an earlier response.
SOM.5:9 - Consequences
The performer can develop a usable portion before the full transition works. State which support, load, speed, tool and movement the evidence covers. A further claim about transfer needs grounds for the changed conditions, and progression beyond familiar limits needs suitable instruction.
SOM.5:10 - Architectural Rationale
A change of support or load can alter which actions must work together. Compare suitable observations to establish what happens through that change. If coordination needs work, identify the affected relation and use SOM.4 when it must be combined with other actions. When varying practice, preserve the relation the learner needs to develop.
SOM.5:11 - SoTA-Echoing
To carry coordination through changed conditions, we adapt HCD.6’s preservation of the relation being learned and HCD.10’s condition-sensitive variation and progression of practice to bodily support, contact and load. Rehearsing endpoints can prepare those positions. Investigate a failure in motion using evidence from the transition.
The proposed teaching procedure identifies what changes with support and load, prepares any missing regulation and joins it to the continuing action. A comparative learning advantage remains unestablished. When suitable movement instruction already gives the performer a working transition, use it directly.
Reconsider the approach if a new condition defeats the learned relation, preparation changes the demand enough to defeat the return, or simpler instruction gives the required result. Depending on the question, a usable answer may be another technique, a different support arrangement or a narrower learning aim.
SOM.5:12 - Relations
Use SOM.1 to examine the proposed relation, SOM.2 and SOM.3 for missing distinction and regulation, and SOM.4 for a combined change. Use HCD.6, HCD.9 and HCD.10 for representative practice, feedback and progression. Use HCD.12 when assessing transfer to unfamiliar work. Returning to a longer familiar stroke can have a narrower purpose. FPF B.1.5.EW relates the transition to the actions that continue throughout it. Use RHY when the task requires a rhythmic relation.