Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-16 21:18:08 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-16 21:19:40 UTC · last check 2026-11-17 19:15:10 UTC

Cross-pattern applications

STR.Application:1 - APP-STR-01 - Choose SensorCo’s response to commoditized AI inspection

SensorCo is a constructed teaching case. Its figures, assignments, observations and subsequent decisions are stipulated for the comparisons below.

STR.Application:1.1 - The opening decision

SensorCo supplies inspection sensors and field service. Over twelve months the price of its generic AI inspection has fallen. The margin on that work helped fund service. SensorCo has a certified sensor platform and field-service knowledge. Demand for a new integrated service remains open.

The StrategyTeam turns “find our AI strategy for 2027” into a question for the Board. Which course can SensorCo pursue and which commitments can it make in this segment over the next twelve months while sustaining current service? Device-only continuation, integrated service, data licensing and exit remain under consideration.

A change could affect the offering, SensorCo’s service arrangement or the specialists’ capabilities. The existing platform can support a new contribution if the necessary access, incident cover and acceptance conditions can be established. Improving one such condition is also an option.

The team prepares the answer. The Board has authority to select direction and approve bounded internal commitments. Customer agreement, permission to use data, financing and demonstrated capability have separate grounds. The team can frame the choice while the eventual direction remains open.

STR.1 can finish with the bounded question. STR.2 examines how the price change affects it. A change of customer population or adopted choice rule would have its own consequences to establish. The later comparison distinguishes four days of preparation from the open twelve-month direction.

STR.Application:1.2 - Frame the uncertainty and preserve a serious rival

The lower price weakens the case for another generic device offer. Existing device and service contracts can still fund current service throughout the twelve-month horizon.

The PSDA.7 account concerns the same decision. Six interviewed customers expressed interest. The installed-base conversion rate remains unknown. The service-cost estimate omits travel and incident coverage. Licensing still lacks evidence of the required data-reuse right.

Two of the six customers are willing to discuss a bounded paid trial next quarter at a stated price ceiling. Agreement to participate and permission for the proposed use remain open. Four already-funded internal engineer-days can complete costing from existing records and specify the smallest relevant trial. This preparation needs no new purchase or customer-data use. Only four discretionary days fall before the Board’s next trial decision.

The Board’s criterion protects current service and its incident reserve first. It then seeks a repeat paid contribution less exposed to generic-inspection price competition. The Board is willing to postpone four days of device-diagnostic improvement for an attainable answer that could alter the service decision.

With STR.3, the team frames two concerns. Existing customers still need the contracted inspection service. For SensorCo, a worthwhile opportunity would provide repeat paid value to customers while reducing exposure to generic-device prices and protecting the incident reserve. A differentiated service would have to meet the customers’ reliability needs at an acceptable price and a support cost the company can sustain. Device-only continuation remains a serious alternative. The licensing option requires an applicable data-reuse right.

For the exit comparison, assume that both orderly exit and device continuation protect current service under the three conditions below. Over twelve months the Board compares exposure avoided, net disposal proceeds, the best attainable use of released resources and consequential later effects. Under its criterion these advantages of exit are outweighed by the continuing device contribution forgone and the full customer-transition burden.

Under those assumptions the Board has grounds to prefer continuation. Reconsider if an exit benefit, transition burden, continuing contribution or protected-service condition could reverse the comparison. A feasible continuation can still lose to a better exit.

STR.Application:1.3 - Use different futures because they change the comparison

STR.4 and STR.9 compare the same twelve-month question under three plausible conditions. No probability is assigned.

Future conditionDevice-only continuationFour-day service preparationConsequence for the present choice
Commoditization continues and customers seek accountable serviceSustains contracted service. The differentiated contribution remains missing.Can establish whether a bounded paid trial is economically plausible and worth pursuing.The Board’s accepted trade-off favours four days of preparation over device diagnostics. The twelve-month direction remains open.
Purchasing freezes for the full horizonSustains existing contracts without service-development work.No customer can undertake a paid trial in time to inform this choice.If established before preparation, continue device-only and retain the four days for diagnostics.
Customer-data reuse is restrictedContinues under existing permitted uses.A customer-local service may be possible under an applicable permission.Continue preparation if an attainable permission determination could leave a worthwhile local option. Otherwise favour device-only. Cross-customer licensing needs its own rights.

The futures are conditions for comparison. Their occurrence remains unknown. STR.5 distinguishes the directions and their selection rules. STR.6 develops complete courses within them. AI, training and a platform make different contributions to those courses.

SensorCo could deliver a customer-local service internally or use a provider. Those options need different support and access. The team can retain an unselected option’s description without funding its trial. A new contribution or constraint may justify constructing a different option.

STR.Application:1.4 - Decide whether more inquiry is worth doing

STR.7 first uses incident records and seeks to establish delivery cost, including travel and support. If complete costing rules out an affordable service configuration at the customers’ price ceiling, the team can return a device-only recommendation and close the trial inquiry. A missing material cost leaves the comparison open.

If a feasible trial remains and its attainable contribution to the commitment decision warrants its burden, design it. With participant agreement and the necessary permissions, the trial could establish whether the two customers use and pay for the specified service and whether the bounded arrangement delivers it. The results would concern those customers and conditions.

Before using customer data or starting the trial, establish the required agreements, permissions, exposure limits, resources, interpretation and closure arrangements. Running an experiment would not establish the right to use those data. Authorizing the four-day preparation would cover only that internal work.

STR.Application:1.5 - Make the whole proposed arrangement visible

STR.8 connects the proposed service with the platform, learning and support it requires. STR.10 and STR.14 compare the combined resource demands for the first shared month, including the four preparation days proposed for authorization.

The team has 80 engineer-days. Current service needs 52 and incident recovery has a protected reserve of 8. The proposal adds 16 for trial preparation and use, 8 for the platform and 6 for learning and support. Its total of 90 exceeds the available 80 by 10.

The smaller proposal assigns 8 days to preparation and, if separately permitted, initial use and interpretation. It assigns 6 to the platform subset and 4 to learning and support. Service and reserve bring the total to 78. The two unallocated days carry no extra recovery commitment.

Within the six platform days, two preserve device-compatible interfaces and maintenance instructions. Four remain for the service-specific subset, postponing a two-day service-diagnostic enhancement. The two fallback days are included in 78. The two unallocated days and the four-day device improvement forgone for preparation are separate. Maintaining the fallback keeps a device-only return possible through the first decision. Longer retention needs its own cost and capability assessment.

The smaller configuration fits the aggregate workload assumptions. A critical-day collision or unavailable skill can still make it infeasible. If the reduced scope cannot deliver the complete service and handle its exceptions, the proposal needs revision or rejection.

OCE.9 can help design an organization-capability increment. If the Board selects implementation, check whether the platform provider can supply the tool and access, whether the necessary human preparation is available and how the service owner will protect the operating limit. Use existing adequate provision or arrange the missing contribution. Customer time, vendor charges, financing and consequences for affected parties also matter to the economic comparison.

STR.Application:1.6 - Select only the supported commitment

The team recommends four internal preparation days while retaining device-only continuation. Its grounds are what the existing records and the conditions already stated by two customers can establish at the sacrifice the Board has accepted. Participation in a trial still needs agreement.

The Board authorizes four preparation days from the eight-day preparation-and-use allowance. Of the 18 proposed development days, 14 remain unauthorized. Trial execution, wider service obligations and capital commitment require their own decisions. The twelve-month direction remains open.

STR.11 carries the PSDA.7 limits into the decision. The six reports establish interest among those respondents. A completed cost comparison and the relevant licensing right remain separate requirements for the options that need them.

STR.Application:1.7 - Reconsider in time and preserve independent work

STR.12 connects two illustrative signals to different returns.

A qualified forecast above 80 engineer-days next month, including the protected 8-day reserve, must arrive before allocation. During preparation the team returns the infeasible allocation proposal. If a trial has since been authorized and the agreed suspension rule applies, the service owner suspends it under that authority and the Board reconsiders its scope.

If complete costing during preparation rules out a worthwhile service configuration, the team can end the inquiry and recommend device-only continuation. The same finding after an authorized trial blocks expansion and returns the preference to the Board. If a material cost is missing, report that gap.

Changes in permissions, finance or conditions for affected parties can also require reconsideration in this case. Keep independent device commitments and service protection while their grounds hold.

STR.Application:1.8 - Sustain useful methods and cultural practice separately

STR.13 examines whether the scenario-and-staged-option method is useful for the next question. If a full-horizon purchasing freeze is already established, a direct comparison can settle current eligibility. The scenario-and-staged-option method may still be useful under different uncertainties.

Suppose the team’s archive retains rejected directions and the Board receives the qualified uncertainty, while recognition in the discussions still favours confident sales claims. STR.15 can finish with the bounded finding that the archive retained those directions, the qualification reached the Board and confident sales claims still received recognition. If a choice about the archive is requested, the evidence can support keeping it. Changing how the Board considers premises and rivals requires the relevant authority and conditions for participation. To claim that the practice changed, look for evidence from later discussions.

In this case the team frames the question and compares courses, the Board authorizes four days, and the larger configuration remains conditional. Decisions about permissions and later review have their own holders and times.

STR.Application:2 - APP-STR-02 - A professional considering a new practice

After current obligations a professional has eight hours a week. A proposed paid practice needs six hours of study and six hours of client development. An adviser can identify opportunities and their limits. The professional decides how to use their time.

The immediate question is what the professional can take on. STR.5–STR.10 can compare current work, a smaller exploration, substitution for specified existing work or deferral. The proposed twelve hours exceed the available eight by four.

Compare a two-hour exploration with using existing information or postponing it. One prospective client could clarify whether they experience the problem. Preparation, conversation and closure must fit the permitted scope and time. If the existing information answers the question, or a conversation is unlikely to add enough to justify its cost, the professional can stop or defer.

The professional can choose a smaller commitment or stop. Compare the implications for livelihood, learning and the person’s other purposes, including non-monetary ones.

STR.Application:3 - APP-STR-03 - A public service under deep uncertainty

In this constructed case a municipal service faces uncertain demand for two delivery channels. The responsible body can reallocate a limited budget. A protected-access obligation remains in force throughout the comparison.

STR.3 distinguishes uncertainty about consequences from a disagreement about whose access might be lost. STR.9 compares configurations under the same demand conditions. STR.10 checks each configuration against the protected limit. A temporary pilot that excludes the most dependent users violates that limit even if its average benefit is favourable.

For a separate numerical comparison, assume A and B both protect access. In two demand conditions the estimated waits are 10 and 12 for A, and 4 and 16 for B. Minimizing worst waiting time favours A (12 against 16). A’s regrets are 6 and 0. B’s are 0 and 4. Minimizing the largest regret favours B (4 against 6). The estimates are the same under both rules.

If the body has requested a comparison, return the two conditional preferences. For an actual allocation, use its adopted criterion or obtain the decision from the body authorized to choose. Existing evidence may justify continuing one channel with a reversible addition. Evidence on demand cannot settle whose access the body may sacrifice. If a later adjustment is needed, STR.12 can connect the observation to a capable authorized responder in time to act.

STR.Application:End