B.1.6:9.2 - SoTA-Echoing
Source qualification was checked against the publishers’ current surfaces on 2026-07-30. Because ISO and GHG Protocol announced active joint development of an updated product-accounting standard in 2026, these decisions remain qualified only through 2027-01-30 unless a new draft, amendment, confirmation status, or published replacement appears earlier. Internal FPF neighbour authority stays in Relations; it is not presented as an external source decision.
| Exact source and source-use decision | Visible B.1.6 mutation | Rejected overread | Smallest source-change replay |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISO 14040:2006 with Amendment 1:2020, confirmed current in 2022, and ISO 14044:2006 with Amendments 1:2017 and 2:2020, confirmed current in 2022 — adapt goal/scope, system-boundary, inventory, allocation, reporting, and intended-use discipline to one exact work-resource aggregation. | Exact policy, Overlap and shared stocks, the engine-programme case, and CC-B1.6-2/3 require boundary, work set, allocation, overlap/deduplication, output kind, and intended use before a total is admitted. | An LCA boundary, inventory table, category, or reported total does not establish FPF work parthood, measurement, aggregation work, result identity, or admissibility for every later use. | Reopen only Exact policy, Overlap and shared stocks, the engine-programme allocation paragraph, and CC-B1.6-2/3 if ISO changes boundary or allocation requirements. |
| GHG Protocol Product Life Cycle Accounting and Reporting Standard, 2011, including its allocation and double-counting requirements — adapt process subdivision/system expansion before allocation, physical or other justified allocation, and explicit double-count control for shared processes/stocks. | The ledger’s shared-resource row, Overlap and shared stocks, the manufacturing-cell case, and CC-B1.6-2/3 require an independently grounded overlap/shared-use fact and one edition-pinned allocation or deduplication rule. | Co-listing, a common meter, corporate/category membership, or a convenient allocation key does not prove disjointness, work structure, or a universal resource share. | Reopen only the shared-resource ledger row, Overlap and shared stocks, the manufacturing-cell case, and CC-B1.6-2/3 when the joint ISO/GHG replacement changes shared-process allocation or double-count rules. |
| JCGM GUM-6:2020, Developing and using measurement models — adapt input-quantity, model-adequacy, covariance, and uncertainty-propagation discipline to the edition-pinned aggregation policy. | Uncertainty and provenance, the engine-programme case, and CC-B1.6-1/3 require the input measurement uncertainties, correlations/conversions, propagation method, and qualified output uncertainty to remain distinct from provenance. | Adding source refs, estimates, or point totals does not propagate uncertainty; aggregation does not make incompatible models or quantities commensurable. | Reopen only Uncertainty and provenance, the engine-programme uncertainty sentence, and CC-B1.6-1/3 if GUM changes model or propagation requirements. |
| ISO 80000-1:2022, Quantities and units — Part 1: General — adapt quantity-kind, unit, quantity-value, dimension, and coherent-unit discipline only for typed aggregation inputs and outputs. | Typed resource basis, the model-training case, and CC-B1.6-1/3 keep joules, hours, mass, currency, bytes, and attention distinct unless an exact conversion/normalization and output kind are declared. | A shared numeral, unit label, normalized score, or vector slot does not authorize cross-kind addition, scalarization, efficiency, or comparability. | Reopen only Typed resource basis, the affected typed component in the model-training case, and CC-B1.6-1/3 if ISO 80000 changes the mapped quantity/unit distinction. |
Source refresh is local: replay the row’s named rule, case, and checklist rows first. Widen only when that replay contradicts another current B.1.6 locus; a changed accounting source cannot by itself create work, overlap, measurement, result episteme, provenance, or a downstream verdict.