B.5.PI:4.4 - Ask from the situation before naming a solution

State what the work should enable, what comparison or experience raised the question, under which conditions, and why the answer could matter. Ordinary words are enough: “How can this figure help price the next batch when it has no numerical value on some days?” is a usable question without the phrase “division by zero”. Search a library or ask a colleague using the situation and needed result. A PatternID is one way to obtain an answer after its relevance becomes intelligible, not a prerequisite to inquiry.

Let the first answer change the question. A calculation can be correct for the wrong quantity. An explanation can answer an easier question than the one the recipient needs. Return to the original use before accepting either as closure. B.5.QD develops a consequential question when the initial one needs reconstruction; B.5.QD.CF examines assumptions behind an apparent conflict. Use those contributions only while the question needs them.

An adequate known explanation, instruction or direct correction may finish this use. If the question needs a new construction, explanation or test, B.5 connects the reasoning contributions. Keep later investigation and problem formulation under their own conditions; a provisional question need not be promoted immediately to a fully specified Problem or research programme.