DOCA.8:5.1 - A narrower data permission does not preserve the old whole-use estimate
This is a constructed continuation of a review-support inquiry. The indexed manual arrangement S1 has now been realized. A separate retrieval-assisted direction remains prospective and concerns data classes A and B. Its estimated contribution was described for that combined workload; no later retrieval arrangement has been implemented.
The data steward supplies a qualified change: external processing of class B is no longer permitted, while the existing local manual use of both classes and the stated external use of class A remain permitted. The update must distinguish the receiving claims.
| Inspected claim | Present result |
|---|---|
| Indexed local manual contribution | Its existing permission and support basis are unchanged in this case. Preserve the actual arrangement and its incurred setup history. |
| Retrieval direction using A and B externally | The broad configuration no longer meets its permission condition. Retire that route for this use. |
| Retrieval direction using A only | A revised conditional candidate. The old whole-workload estimate does not qualify class-A performance, maintenance, verification burden, or the incremental transition from actual S1. |
| Index as a stepping stone to broad retrieval | Reconsider that enabling claim. The independent manual contribution survives even if the broad retrieval connection is retired. |
| Earlier advice to consider the broad evaluation probe | Return the changed permission and affected scope to PSD.14; recover any actual probe decision separately. |
This result can finish with the actual manual arrangement preserved, the prohibited broad route retired, and the class-A direction conditional on its unqualified performance and transition. A class-A evaluation or finite transition result becomes a request to the relevant AI or engineering practice only when its attainable contribution warrants the whole burden relative to continuing from S1. DOCA.5 qualifies the revised joint conditions when that question is pursued.
If a probe was already authorized or begun, the responsible operational owner applies the applicable permission and protection rules. The adviser does not infer continued authority from the earlier recommendation. If no decision or implementation evidence exists, those remain unknown.
The update can close with the short return in :4.4. The narrowed branch is retained as a possibility while its qualification is missing; the realized manual arrangement is not silently reverted.