Library / First Principles Framework (FPF) - Core Conceptual Specification
Jump to passage
In this reading

Link to current text

Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-10-03 08:25:59 UTC · snapshot created 2026-10-03 08:26:43 UTC · last check 2026-10-03 10:05:06 UTC

E.17.ID.CR:7 - Conformance Checklist

A conformance check is retained only if it changes the next bounded use of the comparative review unit, blocks a concrete overclaim, or preserves a source reference or reopen condition needed for the declared bounded use.

Use ID.CR-Core for ordinary comparison notes. Conditional rows apply only when the note touches neighboring-pattern relation, bridge declaration, or reader-fit fields. For fuller mixed-case read, read this checklist together with the neighboring pattern discipline and the boundary conditions gathered in this section.

Assurance recovery note. Use this checklist as a heavier check of the already-declared ComparativeReviewUnit governing rule, not as a second rule list. If a row cannot be recovered through the ordinary seven-row card, the nearest worked slices, or the practical safeguards already named in the pattern, the case is not yet stable enough to rely on checklist prose alone.

E.17.ID.CR:7.1 - ID.CR-Core ordinary checks

  1. CC-ID-1 - Bounded comparative review unit is explicit. The pattern distinguishes the bounded comparative review unit from the surrounding review or decision work.
  2. CC-ID-2 - Source references and comparison criterion are explicit. A reviewer can see what already-fixed source episteme or source publication is being interpreted and what declared comparison criterion or contrast is carrying the lift.
  3. CC-ID-3 - The lift stays bounded. The ordinary card keeps bounded lift, blocked downstream claim or effect, world-contact limit, and boundary trigger visible before any neighboring claim can be read from the unit.
  4. CC-ID-6 - Neighboring-pattern boundaries stay visible. When the boundary trigger fires, the neighboring FPF pattern carries that prompt, ontology, action, gate, authority, or downstream claim instead of leaving it hidden inside comparative prose.
  5. CC-ID-8 - The review unit does not over-claim authority. The unit remains review-only and non-executive; stronger authority use is carried only by the named governing pattern and project-side FPF kind and reference.

E.17.ID.CR:7.2 - ID.CR-Conditional checks

  1. CC-ID-4 - Base-case governing-pattern relation is explicit. A reviewer can tell why the case does not really belong to A.6.3.*, an F.9 Bridge or bounded-use branch, an F.9.1 stance-note branch, E.17.EFP, B.5.2(.0), OntologicalReframing, or A.6.4.
  2. CC-ID-5 - Bridge declaration does not hide. If the case depends on bridge-mediated comparison, bridgeOccurrenceRef and boundedUseClaimRef are required. The latter resolves a claim whose EntityOfConcern is that Bridge and whose use/direction/rule/loss/polarity tuple matches the comparative unit. Positive use requires affirmative polarity and, when A.10 or B.3 is triggered, current reliance for that exact use; degraded reliance narrows it, while a negative, abstaining, reopened, evidence-needed, blocked, or mismatched result stops it. Authorization and actual comparative-review Work remain separate. Optional bridgeCardRef remains packaging; optional bridgeStanceRef resolves a separate F.9.1 episteme whose EntityOfConcern is that claim.
  3. CC-ID-7 - Reader-fit stays bounded. targetUserModel, interactionMode, contrastiveQuestion, boundedComparativeUse, and overreadRisk are visible when needed, but they do not create an authority claim that the unit does not carry.

Checklist recovery map. If an assurance-side reader wants to recover one checklist row by value, use the nearest ordinary card row and worked recovery below before treating the checklist as self-sufficient:

Checklist rowRecover through firstNearest worked or practical recovery
CC-ID-1E.17.ID.CR:4.3.b.a rows Reviewed source and Shared review frame and alternative identitiesE.17.ID.CR:5.4.5, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6.a
CC-ID-2E.17.ID.CR:4.3.b.a rows Reviewed source, Source references, and Bounded liftE.17.ID.CR:5.4.5, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6.a
CC-ID-3E.17.ID.CR:4.3.b.a rows Bounded lift, Blocked downstream claim or effect, and World-contact limitE.17.ID.CR:5.4.6, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.10, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.11
CC-ID-4near-top Neighboring-work boundary, Quick working-fit check, and E.17.ID.CR:4.5 - Neighboring-work boundary glanceE.17.ID.CR:5.4.7 through E.17.ID.CR:5.4.10
CC-ID-5E.17.ID.CR:4.3.d bridge-declaration fields plus E.17.ID.CR:4.2 neighboring patternsE.17.ID.CR:5.4.1, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.2, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.3
CC-ID-6E.17.ID.CR:4.3.b.a row Boundary trigger plus the near-top boundary corridorE.17.ID.CR:5.4.7 through E.17.ID.CR:5.4.10
CC-ID-7E.17.ID.CR:4.3.d interpretant-side fields, kept subordinate to the ordinary card and blocked downstream claim or effectE.17.ID.CR:5.4.4, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.6.b
CC-ID-8E.17.ID.CR:4.3.b.a rows Blocked downstream claim or effect and World-contact limitE.17.ID.CR:5.4.6, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.10, E.17.ID.CR:5.4.11