P1CognitiveEleganceAdequacy | Does the object expose decisive structure without ornamental formalism? | The reader sees the smallest structure that changes the action. |
P2DidacticPrimacyAdequacy | Does human comprehension stay ahead of formal, tooling, or review purity? | Working situation, recognition reason, first move, and payoff stay visible. |
P3ScalableFormalityAdequacy | Can formality strengthen as the use requires while preserving meaning and grounds, with an explicit rewrite or branch when meaning changes? | Staged strengthening is usable; a semantic change remains identifiable and its affected uses are reconsidered. |
P4OpenEndedKernelAdequacy | Do kernel concepts stay meta-level while domain knowledge stays in patterns? | New content extends FPF without smuggling domain doctrine into the kernel. |
P5FPFLayeringAdequacy | Do modular pattern layering and neighbour authority stay intact? | Patterns can be added, replaced, or removed without shadow authority. |
P6LexicalStratificationAdequacy | Are Plain, Tech, Formal, and mathematical registers recoverable for the declared use? | Decision-governing wording maps to fields named by value, kinds, lenses, or neighbours. |
P7PragmaticUtilityAdequacy | Do proofs, measures, models, and reviews change real admissible action? | The object changes prediction, decision, diagnosis, design, repair, stop, or assignment. |
P8CrossScaleConsistencyAdequacy | Do composition, aggregation, boundary, emergence, and method-side relation structures stay consistent across scales? | Cross-scale claims name preserved structure, lost structure, lens or algebraic representation, and boundary. |
P9StateExplicitnessAdequacy | Are the states, transitions, currentness, editions and qualification windows that affect the declared use explicit? | Readers can identify the usable version and state, the conditions that change them, and relevant transition cost and risk. |
P10OpenEndedEvolutionAdequacy | Can justified improvement, revision, replacement or branching continue at acceptable cost and risk, while retention, stopping and retirement remain available? | The selected continuation or stop has a practical reason and a reopen condition; a completed Work occurrence is distinguished from a later Method, object version or Work. |
P11SoTAAlignmentAdequacy | Does current knowledge discipline the object without citation theatre? | Current sources change moves, boundaries, examples, checks, or stop rules. |