MDPE.30:5.3 - Change the receiving condition without confusing the two action rules
The revised accompaniment now needs the low right-hand sound at pulse 0 of every eight-pulse cycle. Continuous alternation on three audible attacks gives the left hand that pulse on alternate cycles. To put the right hand on that entry every cycle, change the action rule or arrangement. If only the low sound matters, a different instrument assignment may suffice. Practising the same arrangement cannot change its predicted first hand.
Compare a second action rule from chapter 32. Alternate the hands on every pulse, including silent motions, and sound only positions 0, 2 and 5. Capitals below mean audible strokes; lowercase letters mean the indicated hand moves without an audible attack, stopping short or using an appropriately silent motion.
pulse: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
motion: R l R l r L r l
sound: x . x . . x . .
Eight pulse-wise motions return the hands to their original allocation. The first two audible attacks are right-hand strokes and the last is left-hand, the smooth-toggle seed of chapter 32. The onsets and silence at 6 remain. This version calls for eight alternating motions per cycle, three of them sounded. Silent positions still require their specified motions. Whether that organization helps a performer depends on their technique and the conditions.
In this constructed rehearsal the percussionist initially sounds an unintended stroke at 4. The ensemble slows the passage to separate audible from silent motions, then restores the original tempo and accompaniment. The performer now supplies the required sounds and entry. The ensemble chooses this version for that arrangement and retains the two-cycle version for its earlier use. If the needed silent motion remains out of reach in the preparation time, consider another playable allocation or a change in instrument, entry condition or rehearsal provision.