ME.10:5.3 - EC-417 B2 Bounded Task Set and Evidence
The EC-417 B2 material exists, but TraceReviewer-17, SafetyReviewer-17, and ReleaseDecider-17 need support for three distinct tasks. The intended task set has the following criteria; its tailoring operation still lacks the definition needed for reuse:
| Task row | Mandatory pass and stop observations |
|---|---|
retrieval by TraceReviewer-17 | Recover MBE-EC417-B2-1, candidate status, prompt episteme ATP-2, confidentiality boundary, and D0 stop. |
tailoring by SafetyReviewer-17 | Use the non-confidential fixture, preserve signed-before-closure, reject a stale edition, and stop on missing permission or authority. |
branch selection by ReleaseDecider-17 | Distinguish A, B2, and R and stop when assignment, permission, authority, confidentiality, or reversibility is absent. |
The receiving relations remain direct: TraceReviewer-17 retrieves the edition and prompt episteme for trace-review preparation; SafetyReviewer-17 uses the tailoring aid in named tailoring Work; ReleaseDecider-17 uses the selection aid in named branch-selection Work. None is release Work or the release decision.
| Candidate configuration | Evidence against the same three rows | Disposition for this case |
|---|---|---|
| Published files and manual lookup only | The case supplies no performed task evidence for current status, ATP-2, D0, stale-edition rejection, signed-before-closure, or A/B2/R stops through this route. | Untested. Do not call it failed or insufficient from absent task evidence alone. |
| Bounded PLM retrieval and selection aids plus the non-confidential CI tailoring fixture | Retrieval and branch-selection pass their declared checks through the identified PLM and CI Systems. Tailoring observations cover the fixture, signed-before-closure and stale-edition rejection, but not the permission/authority stop. | Supported for the observed actions; The missing tailoring definition and missing-task-test[tailoring-permission-authority-stop] prevent a pass for the complete three-task set. No claim of global minimality or parity superiority. |
| Add an AI-provider route and feedback path | The case supplies no AI-provider interaction, used suggestion, review of such a suggestion, feedback Work, or feedback receiving use. No mandatory row currently requires this branch. | Outside the supported pass and untested; retain as named gaps, not features. |
The configured PLM/CI route includes the Method Base edition and status cues, PLM retrieval and branch-selection aids, the CI fixture and stale-edition rejection, ATP-2, and the confidentiality, signed-evidence, assignment, permission, authority, reversibility, and D0 stops. The manual and AI routes lack parity evidence, so this table does not select the globally smallest arrangement. It identifies the only configuration with performed observations across all three tasks; the missing tailoring definition and tailoring-stop test still prevent complete task-set support. It is not an A.22 selected structure.
ME.10:5.3.1 - Missing Tailoring Definition
The case names tailoring aid TAIL-EC417-B2-1 and Work W-MESUP-EC417-Tailor-1, but does not identify the object and edition to adapt, the alteration or selection performed, or the resulting tailored object. The fixture and guard observations below do not recover those missing values. The method engineer configuring this support task must recover them before offering it as a repeatable tailoring instruction or claiming tailoring coverage. Until then, return missing-task-set[tailoring-input-action-result] and retain only the described CI-use, signed-before-closure and stale-edition observations. This missing definition is separate from the untested permission/authority stop; neither gap turns the admitted Work into a performed failure.