OCE.15:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source | Retained contribution | Boundary and practitioner implication |
|---|---|---|
| Hagl et al., change-management intervention review | Intervention families and ability, motivation, and opportunity-to-contribute mechanisms support repertoire fields. | The synthesis is not a universal sequence; interactions, boundaries, measurement, and consequences remain open. |
| Ekendahl et al., context-based adaptation | Decision conditions must be assessed and reassessed while change unfolds. | Use the study’s entity/process perspectives to inspect changing conditions; qualify the local adaptation Method separately. |
| Kamarova et al., behavior and organizational-change synthesis | Mastery, meaning, belonging, and participation counter recipe and “resistance” reduction. | The synthesis is selective and primarily individual-level. |
| Wang et al., implementation-framework scoping review and Nilsen, taxonomy | Determinant, process, strategy, evaluation, and measurement purposes must remain distinct. | Use the taxonomies to distinguish functions, then select or construct the Method needed for the local result. |
| Powell et al., ERIC strategies | Discrete implementation strategies can be candidate contributions. | Determine the required sequence, local fit, and effects for the selected contributions. |
| Damschroder et al., updated CFIR and Reardon et al., CFIR User Guide | A determinant framework requires project-specific boundary and construct operationalization. | CFIR is not designed to develop an innovation or specify the implementation process and is not a universal OCE Method. |
| Proctor et al., implementation outcomes and ten-year review | Implementation outcomes need named referents and remain distinct from service, client, and organization results. | Causal relations among strategies, mechanisms, implementation outcomes, and downstream outcomes remain weakly established. |
| Current Method Engineering Principles Framework | General Method results, connected conceptual synthesis, and several viewpoints on one Work. | OCE.15 consumes the named ME results and adds only organization-change semantics and use. |
Reopen when a source or representative use exposes a materially different domain contribution, framework function, mechanism, situation change, outcome boundary, bundle interaction, or candidate-development need, or when Method Engineering makes an OCE move redundant.