Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-22 12:18:55 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-22 12:19:56 UTC · last check 2026-11-22 13:10:10 UTC

PSDA.20:4.1 - Let the question determine what to model

Identify what the inquiry needs to explain or support. Follow the result from the person or service that needs it to the work or outside provision on which it depends. Open a contribution when two ways of supplying it could change the answer, its grounds or the permissible action. Stop at a supplier’s qualified result when it settles the commissioned question. If a specific performance was promised, establish whether it was carried out. Use existing records, relevant accounts and observations that establish the operating conditions. For a participant’s intention or experienced burden, use an attributable account or ask when needed and feasible. State any material gap. Participation in building the model may help correct it. To report agreement with a proposal, use evidence of the relevant response.

Consider a car park whose unreliable sensors sometimes send drivers towards occupied floors. Attendants walk the floors and correct the displayed counts. Management proposes replacing the entire system, since the sensors cannot simply be exchanged in the current design. The inquiry asks, Does replacement address the service difficulty better than continuing manual correction? This is an adaptation of the parking exercise in the iStar tutorial, slide 57. The following participants, conditions and judgements are constructed for this walkthrough.

Include drivers because the guidance affects finding a place; attendants because correction requires their work; the operations manager because staffing and service arrangements are theirs to decide; and the technical supplier because replacement feasibility and installation depend on its contribution. Management cares about operating cost and reputation. Drivers care about usable guidance and protection of their cars. An attendant’s account of an assignment is evidence about that work, not a statement of every driver’s preferences.

Keep the questions distinct. What would make the displayed count trustworthy? Can the work supply it when needed? How would the alternatives affect cost and the concerns behind reputation? A model of intentions can expose these questions before it has the technical estimates needed to answer all of them.