HCD-EVIDENCE - Decide what a successful attempt permits you to rely on
Situation: A learner reaches a correct answer after help, or succeeds in familiar work, and someone needs to decide what this permits them to rely on in later work.
Question: Which contribution is supported, under what conditions, and does the development arrangement need to change?
First useful result or blocker: A bounded performance conclusion and, when needed, a targeted change to the task or assistance; an unresolved transfer, delay or support question remains separate.
Start with: HCD.11 - Assess Human Performance in Representative Work, using the attempt and its actual conditions. If practice is being conducted, HCD.9 - Perform Deliberate Practice with Feedback preserves the first attempt, supplied help, feedback, learner correction or supported retention. A correction requires a targeted retry; after retaining an action, retry only for a remaining practice question.
Stop or return: Stop when the available evidence is sufficient for the intended reliance or local revision. Seek a further observation when it can settle or materially improve a consequential claim and its value warrants the cost.
- Separate the successful product from the person’s contribution. In the constructed APP-HCD-02, a teacher initially helps Learner-L17 reject a release proposal supported by the wrong firmware evidence. That correction is assisted. Two later fresh attempts show L17 detecting the mismatch before a teacher or AI cue, supporting a narrower independent configuration-checking conclusion.
- Change the condition relevant to the next use. HCD.12 - Test Transfer to Unfamiliar Work or Learning from a New Source uses unfamiliar work when transfer matters. A compatible release case requires two hours per change plus one hour per batch of at most four changes. Ten changes need
20 + 3 = 23hours and fit a 24-hour allowance. At 22 hours, ten no longer fit; nine need18 + 3 = 21. L17’s corrected nine-change answer after feedback supports helped resource adaptation while preserving the earlier configuration result. - Repair the development contribution exposed by that result. HCD.14 - Revise the Human Capability-Development Arrangement from Evidence can replace a cue-led resource exercise with cases requiring both a justified proposal and a justified refusal. It need not discard sound arithmetic or configuration practice. HCD.10 - Choose Whether and How to Vary, Space, Interleave, or Progress Practice uses the attempt history to select a consequential variation, separated return, competing task or assistance change; select the condition that matters to the learner’s next use.
- Open a delay or support question only when it affects reliance. HCD.13 - Test Human Capability Retention and Dependence on Tools or Other Support compares performance after a delay and under changed support with suitable earlier conditions. A delayed attempt with AI also removed tests the combined condition. Isolating either effect requires a comparison that distinguishes delay from the withdrawal of help. Keep intervening practice and remaining tools visible. An immediate local repair need not wait for this separate investigation.