HCD-MATERIAL - Find what instructional material supports and what to repair
Situation: An explanation, worksheet or learning route is meant to support a reader’s task, but a correct reader answer may have depended on prior knowledge or help.
Question: What does the material supply for the promised use? Where a contribution is missing, which conclusion or repair depends on it?
First useful result or blocker: A compatible specification, a supported finding about what the material supplies, a limiting defect and its reach, or the particular criterion or evidence still needed.
Start with: HCD.19 - Evaluate Instructional Material through Representative Reader Work and Diagnose Its Repair when a compatible specification exists. Otherwise use HCD.18 - Select or Construct a Characterization and Evaluation Specification for Instructional Material to connect the promised task, audience, permitted help, criteria and evidence to the question or decision the evaluation must support.
Stop or return: Finish with the requested material finding or the supported use or repair conclusion. Identify any gap that limits a stronger claim. For a requested improvement, use E.23 with the affected material and use. Apply a human-performance method when the question concerns the person’s contribution or learning.
- Use the specification to decide what must be inspected. The instructional-material evaluation profile explains how HCD.18 and HCD.19 work together. Select the properties needed for the requested finding or decision. Inspection can establish a local false relation.
- Distinguish material contribution from reader repair. In its Time-use S1 case, an uninterrupted example gives the same value for active effort and elapsed turnaround, so it cannot distinguish the two rules. A prepared reader separates them correctly using prior knowledge. HCD.19 preserves that fact rather than crediting the missing distinction to the material.
- Repair the relation and inspect its affected use. The revised material distinguishes the quantities, changes the columns, adds interruption and population conditions, and supports a changed two-person comparison of three consumed person-hours with four available person-hours. This supports the bounded repair and use, not a novice-learning claim.
- Return remaining requirements at their actual reach. The full specification still requires a concurrent-person example, an inspected task and key, and suitable explanatory and feedback evidence. Keep these gaps visible without withholding the narrower supported repair. Seek additional reader work when its attainable contribution to the requested conclusion or decision warrants its full burden.