ME.10:5 - Worked Build and Test Replays
ME.10:5.1 - Minimal One-Task Manual Replay
This small constructed replay shows the cheap branch without claiming field evidence. Assume that the named Method and MethodDescription editions are admitted and that the two retrieval occurrences are independently admitted under A.15.1; an actual use must supply those bases rather than inherit them from the example.
CalibrationEngineer-5 must retrieve the current description of admitted Method M-Calibrate-Sensor-B for planned calibration Work. The pass criterion is: return MD-Calibrate-Sensor-B-v4, its current status, applicability to sensor family B, and the stop for an unknown serial class. The failure criterion is return of another edition or omission of status, applicability, or stop.
This is one receiver and one exact action. Candidate REP-Cal-B-Retrieval-1 is a C.2.1 episteme constituted by the maintained index row. Its exact use claim is that v4 is the current family-B description and carries the unknown-serial stop for this retrieval. It exposes currentness, applicability, the stop, and publication link; it withholds a stable audit digest and makes no capability, permission, authority, Work, or calibration-result claim. The ME.10 task row is the owning domain result for this use and carries the receiving task criterion, observation, and return. That one embedded realization supplies the complete one-result/one-use selection boundary, so the C.37 direct exit applies: no ME.9 profile row and no duplicate standalone C.37 account are created. If a later decision relies on the retrieved content as evidence, its exact A.10 path and disposition must be added for that later use.
The initial shared-folder route contains v3 and v4 but exposes neither currentness nor applicability. In W-ME10-Retrieve-Cal-B-0, the user retrieves v3; the task returns task-fail[wrong-edition] without changing either edition or admitting a capability claim.
| Candidate configuration | Criterion coverage and burden | Disposition |
|---|---|---|
| Rename v4 to “FINAL” and leave both files in the folder | Cheap, but the label supplies no governed currentness relation, applicability, or stop and obscures why v3 remains. | Insufficient for the declared criterion. |
| Add one manually maintained index row naming the Method, v4, currentness basis, family-B applicability, unknown-serial stop, and publication link | Covers every current criterion with one new episteme and no new platform. The folder remains a carrier; the index does not become the Method, publication occurrence, Work, or authority. | Retain as the only currently supported sufficient configuration for this one-task set; this does not exclude the untested portal. |
| Build a search portal with automated recommendations | Could add later functions, but no present criterion requires them and their provider, access, suggestion-use, and authority relations are ungrounded. | Untested and larger than this one-task need; do not claim failure. |
The repair adds only the retained index row and its maintained currentness cue. In W-ME10-Retrieve-Cal-B-1, the same user retrieves v4, sees family-B applicability, and stops on an unknown serial class. The receiving task result is task-pass for this exact retrieval action, so the use-bounded row disposition is select inside the stated v4/family-B window. Return if the source edition, currentness cue, applicability, unknown-serial stop, or task observation changes.
For the bounded set containing only this task, the currently supported set is the singleton containing the index row: the rename route is insufficient by its declared missing features, while the portal remains untested and is not ruled out as logically insufficient. This establishes neither unique sufficiency nor multi-task minimality, Method fit, general user capability, a selected A.22 structure, or worth in another project.
ME.10:5.2 - Two-Task Trade-off with Two Retained Candidates
Extend the constructed case with a second mandatory action. CalibrationEngineer-5 must retrieve the current description for planned family-B calibration Work. Computational user System AuditService-2 must use the exact v4 edition in ReleaseAudit-7 under a stable digest and audit currentness record. These are different receiver/action pairs, so they require different use-bounded claim groups even when one maintained source could realize both. No AuditService-2 task Work has yet occurred.
The Method-specific problem is now cross-use allocation of complementary governed representation results. The ME.9 profile branch applies. Each row below embeds the applicable complete C.37 group and preserves admitted Method M-Calibrate-Sensor-B and current ME.8 result MD-Calibrate-Sensor-B-v4 as its source. The rows select for their own actions; they do not yet constitute the ME.9 cross-use result or select a support configuration.
| ME.9 row and exact action | Direct result, exact claim, and reliance | Exposure and loss | Receiving result, disposition, and return |
|---|---|---|---|
MRP-Cal-B-Retrieve-1: CalibrationEngineer-5 retrieves material for planned family-B calibration Work. Qualification window: the currentness cue is checked at retrieval and remains usable only for that v4 family-B use through the planned Work. | REP-Cal-B-Retrieval-1 is the directly governed C.2.1 index episteme. Exact claim: v4 is current for family B and carries the unknown-serial stop and publication link. A.2.4 classifies the intended status-evidence use. A.10 path P-Cal-B-Retrieve-v4 carries that currentness/applicability premise with RelianceDisposition=pass inside the stated window. | Exposes current edition, family-B applicability, stop, and link; omits the stable audit digest and audit currentness record, which this action does not require. | task-pass from W-ME10-Retrieve-Cal-B-1; select for this retrieval action. Return to ME.8 for changed source claims, C.2.1 or A.10 for a failed direct result, or this row when the use, window, disposition, or observation changes. Stop if the edition or cue changes, applicability no longer covers family B, or the serial class is unknown. |
MRP-Cal-B-Audit-1: AuditService-2 uses the exact edition in ReleaseAudit-7. Qualification window: at audit start the currentness record must identify v4 and the stable digest must identify the exact v4 bytes used by that audit run. | REP-Cal-B-Audit-1 is a governed C.2.1 audit-register episteme tied to a separately identified E.24.PUB publication result. Exact claim: the named digest and record bind the audit use to the current v4 edition. A.2.4 classifies the intended audit-evidence use. A.10 path P-Cal-B-Audit-v4 returns RelianceDisposition=abstain until the digest/currentness pair is checked inside the audit window; missing, stale, out-of-window, or mismatched values stop before reliance. | Exposes edition identity, stable digest, and audit currentness record; omits the human applicability explanation and unknown-serial stop, which this action does not consume. Publication does not supply reliance or the task result. | missing-task-test[AuditService-2]; no audit task Work exists and no task-pass is claimed. The row is unresolved, not failed. Return to ME.8 for changed source claims, C.2.1, E.24.PUB, or A.10 for a failed direct result, or this row when its use, window, stop, task observation, or disposition changes. |
ME.9 now returns cross-use profile result MRP-Cal-B-Retrieve-Audit-1 rather than treating row colocation as composition:
| Profile position | Cross-use result |
|---|---|
| shared Method source | Both rows return to admitted Method M-Calibrate-Sensor-B and current MethodDescription MD-Calibrate-Sensor-B-v4. |
| cross-use correspondence | The retrieval currentness cue and the audit digest/currentness pair must designate the same exact v4 edition. Matching the label v4 is insufficient; a changed edition reopens both rows and this correspondence. |
| conflicting omissions | Retrieval needs family-B applicability and the unknown-serial stop but omits the stable digest. Audit needs the digest and audit-currentness record but omits the human applicability explanation and serial-class branch. Combining the presentations does not erase either omission or prove consistency. |
| edition relations | The retrieval row is qualified for the planned family-B Work window; the audit row is qualified only for the named ReleaseAudit-7 run after its digest/currentness check. A serial-class change can reopen retrieval alone; a digest mismatch can reopen audit alone. |
| keep-separate decision | REP-Cal-B-Retrieval-1, REP-Cal-B-Audit-1, their C.37 dispositions, and their receiving task results remain separate. The profile creates no super-representation, common task pass, publication, or support arrangement. |
| profile return | Retain retrieval as select and audit as unresolved; return missing-task-test[AuditService-2] and the unchecked digest/currentness relation. Reopen both rows only when their shared source identity or correspondence changes. |
The configurations below compare how those two governed results and the explicit cross-use relation could be supplied and maintained. C.37 does not choose among them, and the ME.9 profile does not rank them; ME.10 retains that configuration decision.
| Candidate configuration | Engineer retrieval row | Audit-service row | Cross-task burden and disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manual index row only | Observed pass in W-ME10-Retrieve-Cal-B-1. | Insufficient: the editable row supplies no stable publication digest or audit currentness record. | Exclude for the two-task mandatory set. |
| One signed read-only register supplies separate retrieval and audit presentations | Untested for the engineer; its declared retrieval presentation can expose applicability and the stop. | Untested for AuditService-2; its declared audit presentation can expose the digest and currentness record. | One maintained source for two governed results, but the case lacks approval-latency evidence. Retain. |
| Manual retrieval index plus a signed audit log | The existing retrieval pass remains relevant to the index route. | Untested for AuditService-2; its declared design can expose the audit record. | Lower expected retrieval delay but duplicated currentness maintenance and an untested consistency relation. Retain. |
The last two candidates cover the declared features differently, but the case supplies neither audit-task evidence nor a priority between approval latency and duplicated currentness maintenance. The audit profile row therefore remains unresolved, the cross-use profile returns its unchecked correspondence and missing-task-test[AuditService-2], and reliance stops; retain both candidates with unresolved-configuration-choice[approval-latency-vs-duplicate-currentness-maintenance]. If a receiving decision authorizes a split, name the user/task boundary, currentness owners, and consistency relation; do not call the union globally minimal.
ME.10:5.3 - EC-417 B2 Bounded Task Set and Evidence
The EC-417 B2 material exists, but TraceReviewer-17, SafetyReviewer-17, and ReleaseDecider-17 need support for three distinct tasks. The intended task set has the following criteria; its tailoring operation still lacks the definition needed for reuse:
| Task row | Mandatory pass and stop observations |
|---|---|
retrieval by TraceReviewer-17 | Recover MBE-EC417-B2-1, candidate status, prompt episteme ATP-2, confidentiality boundary, and D0 stop. |
tailoring by SafetyReviewer-17 | Use the non-confidential fixture, preserve signed-before-closure, reject a stale edition, and stop on missing permission or authority. |
branch selection by ReleaseDecider-17 | Distinguish A, B2, and R and stop when assignment, permission, authority, confidentiality, or reversibility is absent. |
The receiving relations remain direct: TraceReviewer-17 retrieves the edition and prompt episteme for trace-review preparation; SafetyReviewer-17 uses the tailoring aid in named tailoring Work; ReleaseDecider-17 uses the selection aid in named branch-selection Work. None is release Work or the release decision.
| Candidate configuration | Evidence against the same three rows | Disposition for this case |
|---|---|---|
| Published files and manual lookup only | The case supplies no performed task evidence for current status, ATP-2, D0, stale-edition rejection, signed-before-closure, or A/B2/R stops through this route. | Untested. Do not call it failed or insufficient from absent task evidence alone. |
| Bounded PLM retrieval and selection aids plus the non-confidential CI tailoring fixture | Retrieval and branch-selection pass their declared checks through the identified PLM and CI Systems. Tailoring observations cover the fixture, signed-before-closure and stale-edition rejection, but not the permission/authority stop. | Supported for the observed actions; The missing tailoring definition and missing-task-test[tailoring-permission-authority-stop] prevent a pass for the complete three-task set. No claim of global minimality or parity superiority. |
| Add an AI-provider route and feedback path | The case supplies no AI-provider interaction, used suggestion, review of such a suggestion, feedback Work, or feedback receiving use. No mandatory row currently requires this branch. | Outside the supported pass and untested; retain as named gaps, not features. |
The configured PLM/CI route includes the Method Base edition and status cues, PLM retrieval and branch-selection aids, the CI fixture and stale-edition rejection, ATP-2, and the confidentiality, signed-evidence, assignment, permission, authority, reversibility, and D0 stops. The manual and AI routes lack parity evidence, so this table does not select the globally smallest arrangement. It identifies the only configuration with performed observations across all three tasks; the missing tailoring definition and tailoring-stop test still prevent complete task-set support. It is not an A.22 selected structure.
ME.10:5.3.1 - Missing Tailoring Definition
The case names tailoring aid TAIL-EC417-B2-1 and Work W-MESUP-EC417-Tailor-1, but does not identify the object and edition to adapt, the alteration or selection performed, or the resulting tailored object. The fixture and guard observations below do not recover those missing values. The method engineer configuring this support task must recover them before offering it as a repeatable tailoring instruction or claiming tailoring coverage. Until then, return missing-task-set[tailoring-input-action-result] and retain only the described CI-use, signed-before-closure and stale-edition observations. This missing definition is separate from the untested permission/authority stop; neither gap turns the admitted Work into a performed failure.
ME.10:5.4 - Three Performed Tasks and Their Bounded Reach
| User Work | System interaction and observed result | Result boundary |
|---|---|---|
W-MESUP-EC417-Retrieve-1 by TraceReviewer-17 | The user retrieves MBE-EC417-B2-1 through SYS-EC417-PLM-1 and recovers candidate status, ATP-2, the confidentiality boundary, and the D0 stop. The local SupportSystemUsedInWork@EC417 occurrence obtains for that Work-System pair and interaction interval. | The result establishes this retrieval task only; it creates no general access entitlement, capability, or authority. |
W-MESUP-EC417-Tailor-1 by SafetyReviewer-17 | The user applies the tailoring aid with a non-confidential SYS-EC417-CI-1 fixture, recovers signed-before-closure, and rejects the stale edition. Its separate direct System-use occurrence obtains. | The result establishes these observations only; the tailoring operation remains undefined, and stopping on missing permission or authority remains untested. It neither performs release Work nor approves closure. |
W-MESUP-EC417-Select-1 by ReleaseDecider-17 | The user applies the selection aid through SYS-EC417-PLM-1 to distinguish pre-entry A, bounded B2, and post-entry R and stops B2 when a named assignment, permission, authority, confidentiality, or reversibility condition is absent. Its separate direct System-use occurrence obtains. | The result establishes this bounded selection task only; the tool does not make the release decision or acquire authority. |
RES-MESUP-EC417-B2-1 returns task-pass for retrieval and branch selection. It retains the observed tailoring fixture, signed-before-closure and stale-edition results, but returns missing-task-set[tailoring-input-action-result] and the separate missing-task-test[tailoring-permission-authority-stop] for the full tailoring task. The other user’s branch-selection stop does not fill that gap. No AI-provider interaction, used AI suggestion, review of such a suggestion, feedback SpeechAct, or feedback receiving use is part of that pass. Retrieving ATP-2 is not provider use.
No repair and rerun occurrence is asserted for EC-417: no performed task is reported as failed, and an untested tailoring stop is not a performed failure. If a later task fails, apply step 12 and add its Work and rerun rather than rewriting these histories. The minimal one-task replay supplies the filled failure-repair-rerun branch; the two-task extension supplies the unresolved-trade-off branch.
ME.10:5.5 - Proposed Organization, Not a Selected Structure
PSO-EC417-B2-Use-1 is a case-local proposal designator. Its four candidate A.22 groups remain disjoint:
- the identified collection, entries, edition, aids, prompt episteme, Systems, and three Work occurrences;
- two instituted entry-membership occurrences and the three direct PLM and CI System-use occurrences;
- current-edition, status, confidentiality, signed-before-closure, assignment, permission, authority, reversibility, and D0 constraints; and
- the use frame for retrieval, comparison, tailoring, and bounded PLM and CI use for
WP-EC417-B2-Trial-1.
The case supplies no selecting System, enacted selection Method, dated structure-selection Work, or direct participation or operation-binding facts. ESA-EC417-B2-1 returns missing-selection-basis and designates no selected U.Structure. This gap does not erase the three task observations.
ME.10:5.6 - Collection and Edition Remain Subordinate Results
MBC-EC417-B2-1 identifies the project collection and its entry-disposition rule. Two admitted curator Work occurrences, their permissions and operation applications, positive result bindings, and identified MethodBaseEntryBelongsTo@Project predicates establish membership for the candidate-account and WorkPlan epistemes. The collection, membership episodes, assertion or evidence accounts, optional construction account, edition, publication occurrence, and named-use reliance episteme remain separate results.
Those facts make the named material eligible for the three user tasks; they do not show that the tasks succeeded. Conversely, the bounded task results do not prove general capability, select the proposed structure, admit C-EC-Release-v2 as a Method, perform release Work, or establish Method fit or effectiveness.