PSDA.20:4.4 - Turn a working question into an analysis, then recover its meaning
For each alternative the question concerns, identify which work or assumptions differ from the current arrangement. Alternative A retains the existing displays and uses manual correction. Alternative B installs the proposed replacement and uses its automatic counts. For the initial comparison, suppose staffing for A is available and the supplier has described a technically plausible B, while B’s installation interval and whole cost remain unknown. Do not compare A in its troublesome current state with B in an unexplained ideal state.
In this question, label each initial value as an observation or a stipulated assumption. To examine B if installed and operating as proposed, assume installation and the specified sensing performance. Keep installation and whole cost open for any investment decision. The conditional service comparison can proceed on its stated inputs.
Omitting manual rounds from B defines the proposal. It supplies no evidence about the attendants’ capability to inspect a floor. Use any independent evidence available for that question. Distinguish an unexamined element, an examined effect for which evidence is insufficient, a negative observation and conflicting grounds.
Follow the relevant relationships for each alternative. Use PSDA.8:4.2.1 for a needed qualitative analysis. Keep the initial assumptions and intermediate judgements with its result. For A, a sufficiently recent and correctly performed round supports a corrected count; publication still needs the working display. For B, the stipulated sensing performance supports the count conditionally; it does not establish the installation date or remove all future maintenance work.
Use the source that can support an unresolved contribution, such as a relevant participant’s stated judgement, an operating record or a specialist assessment. Here management judges that fewer misleading indications would help reputation. That supports a favorable contribution from guidance. The overall judgement about reputation remains open while protection is unresolved. Manual inspection can improve counts and increase staff burden at the same time. Assess those effects on their own grounds.
Return the conditional comparison in the terms of the car-park inquiry.
| Question | A: retained system with manual correction | B: proposed replacement |
|---|---|---|
| Can it provide useful counts? | Supported only while the stated inspection, freshness, staffing and publication conditions hold. | Supported conditionally on the proposed installation and sensing performance. |
| What happens to work and cost? | Inspection remains a recurring demand. | Some inspection may be displaced, but acquisition, transition and operating costs remain to be established. |
| Does it meet the concerns behind reputation? | Better count information addresses one concern; protection of cars needs its own grounds. | The same limit applies; a better sensor is not evidence of protection. |
The comparison identifies a possible service improvement under its assumptions. Installation timing and total cost remain open, so it leaves the investment decision unresolved. Return the conditional comparison if that answers the question. Seek the missing facts when their attainable contribution warrants the work.