PSDA.20:4.5 - Use surprising results to discover a different problem
Trace a surprising answer to the relationships, premises and analysis rules that produced it. Check whether the model misrepresents the work or the original question omitted a consequential condition. Correct an established error and reconsider the affected conclusions. Use the corrected model if it answers the original inquiry.
When the original question omits a necessary contribution, state the required joint result and the conditions that make it possible. Explain how the dependency changes the question for the intended use. A supported account of that dependency can finish an inquiry about the original proposal.
If the task needs another arrangement, work backward from the joint requirement. Look for feasible changes to the provider, means, timing or support. Use PSDA.5 when generating alternatives needs further work. A proposed relaxation of the requirement needs the applicable authority and the conditions of the recipient’s use.
Test each candidate combination under the same conditions, including competing assignments and shared resources. When a premise changes, revise the dependent conclusions and keep those still supported. Return the resulting candidate, supported rejection or open condition with the reason it matters.
Suppose the first model gave A an unqualified favorable result because it represented the round but omitted other assignments. Ask what must be true for that result to hold. Inspecting the rota now reveals that the same attendant must be at the security desk from 10:00 to 10:15, while the modeled correction requires leaving it for a round from 10:00 to 10:10. No substitute is assigned. These stipulated facts defeat the simultaneous arrangement.
The discovery changes the model and the problem. Add the required desk coverage and its relation to the attendant’s available work; then revise A’s count availability for this interval. The earlier claim that a completed, timely inspection can supply a count still holds. B’s separate technical hypothesis also survives. What fails is the premise that A’s work can coexist with the retained service obligations.
If the manager needs a remedy, the next question is how can the service provide current guidance and cover the desk during this interval? A different allocation or contributor would need to meet both requirements. The manager holds assignment authority. Use OCE.11 when the proposed change competes with continuing service.
Current guidance requires an adequate count and publication. Desk coverage requires someone at the desk. A competent relief checker could perform the round while the attendant remains at the desk. Establish whether the checker could obtain and publish the count in time with the required access and without leaving another necessary assignment. Until then the proposed allocation is conditional.
For a bounded continuation, suppose the manager assigns a competent relief worker for this interval, verifies that no other required assignment overlaps, and provides the permitted access and existing checking procedure. In the stipulated trial the relief worker obtains and publishes a count meeting the agreed freshness and accuracy conditions, while the attendant remains at the desk. Both required contributions are supplied in this interval. The added staffing cost belongs in A’s cost account. If relief is available only today, retain today’s result and reopen the staffing question before promising tomorrow’s service; the earlier investment question remains open.
A different candidate might change the update interval or the information promised to drivers. That changes the service requirement, so return to whether the altered guidance remains useful and acceptable. Do not weaken the criterion silently to make the diagram succeed. An incompatible candidate can be rejected without proving that all possible arrangements fail; an unsupported candidate stays conditional.
Retain the failed combination and its reason where another decision or attempt depends on it. In formal backward analysis, identify which premises or judgements produce the incompatibility. A proof of incompatibility establishes it within the encoding, premises and restrictions. A search that exhausted its allowance without finding a solution leaves compatibility unresolved. An organizational claim about all remedies needs evidence covering those remedies.